Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / GoodbyeLenin

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WhyWeAreBummedCommunismFell: And how it affected some people more than others. TV repairman Alex fairly quickly finds a better job as a satellite dish installer and his sister, finding her pursuit of a degree in Marxist-Leninist economics suddenly obsolete, gets a job at Burger King, but several neighbors in their 50s are unemployed with no prospects - too young to retire but too old to learn new skills, and many of the GDR's state-owned businesses they worked at were overstaffed, inefficient and redundant. Even East German cosmonaut Sigmund Jähn seems to have ended up as a cab driver after the fall of communism. Also Alex's mother, who reveals that her husband was waiting for the family to join him in the West - when the Wall fell, it became a bitter pill for many who had decided to remain and "stick it out", in light of the lost opportunities of a hypothetical Republikflucht, there was a degree of regret that they had wasted the best years of their lives in what was clearly a failed state in 1990.

to:

* WhyWeAreBummedCommunismFell: And how it affected some people more than others. TV repairman Alex fairly quickly finds a better job as a satellite dish installer and his sister, finding her pursuit of a degree in Marxist-Leninist economics suddenly obsolete, gets a job at Burger King, but several neighbors in their 50s are unemployed with no prospects - too young to retire but too old to learn new skills, and many of the GDR's state-owned businesses they worked at were overstaffed, inefficient and redundant. Even East German cosmonaut Sigmund Jähn seems to have ended up as a cab driver after the fall of communism. Also Alex's mother, who reveals that when she reveals [[spoiler:that the plan was for her husband was waiting for and the family children to join him in her husband in the West West]] - when the Wall fell, it became a bitter pill for many who had decided to remain and "stick it out", in light of the lost opportunities of a hypothetical Republikflucht, there was a degree of regret that they had wasted the best years of their lives in what was clearly a failed state in 1990.

Added: 435

Changed: 816

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheAlcoholic: Klapprath, the former principal of the school where Christiane taught, is shown as having been driven to drink. Presumably he didn't take the changes (and enforced retirement) too well.

to:

* TheAlcoholic: Klapprath, the former principal of the school where Christiane taught, is shown as having been driven to drink. Presumably he didn't take the changes (and enforced retirement) too well. As a SED (Socialist Unity Party of Germany, former GDR's ruling party) functionary, he would have been not only regarded as ideologically suspect, but due to GDR's constitutional guarantees of employment, the GDR civil service was very overstaffed and redundant.



** Alex getting a new job quite quickly after his old workplace, the PGH (craft production cooperative) is liquidated. Very likely, his skills in repairing TV sets and radios helped. In reality, the employment prospects for young GDR men tended to be a much more protracted and painful transition, in fact, his sister going from university student to Burger King drive through employee was more typical for young men of his generation.



* WhyWeAreBummedCommunismFell: And how it affected some people more than others. TV repairman Alex fairly quickly finds a better job as a satellite dish installer and his sister, finding her pursuit of a degree in Marxist-Leninist economics suddenly obsolete, gets a job at Burger King, but several neighbors in their 50s are unemployed with no prospects. Even East German cosmonaut Sigmund Jähn seems to have ended up as a cab driver after the fall of communism.

to:

* WhyWeAreBummedCommunismFell: And how it affected some people more than others. TV repairman Alex fairly quickly finds a better job as a satellite dish installer and his sister, finding her pursuit of a degree in Marxist-Leninist economics suddenly obsolete, gets a job at Burger King, but several neighbors in their 50s are unemployed with no prospects. Even prospects - too young to retire but too old to learn new skills, and many of the GDR's state-owned businesses they worked at were overstaffed, inefficient and redundant. Even East German cosmonaut Sigmund Jähn seems to have ended up as a cab driver after the fall of communism.communism. Also Alex's mother, who reveals that her husband was waiting for the family to join him in the West - when the Wall fell, it became a bitter pill for many who had decided to remain and "stick it out", in light of the lost opportunities of a hypothetical Republikflucht, there was a degree of regret that they had wasted the best years of their lives in what was clearly a failed state in 1990.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AlternateHistory: InUniverse. Alexander, along with his friends and family, sets up an elaborate alternate history where East Germany ends up dominant over West Germany to hide the truth from his mother. He finally shows her a conclusion in which Germany gets reunified, but not through East Germany being reabsorbed by West Germany; instead the Bonn Republic is dissolved so that its people can join the GDR!

to:

* AlternateHistory: InUniverse. Alexander, along with his friends and family, sets up an elaborate alternate history where East Germany ends up dominant over West Germany to hide the truth from his mother. He [[spoiler:He finally shows her a conclusion in which Germany gets reunified, but not through East Germany being reabsorbed by West Germany; instead the Bonn Republic is dissolved so that and its people can join become citizens of the GDR!GDR!]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AlternateHistory: InUniverse. Alexander, along with his friends and family, sets up an elaborate alternate history where East Germany ends up dominant over West Germany to hide the truth from his mother.

to:

* AlternateHistory: InUniverse. Alexander, along with his friends and family, sets up an elaborate alternate history where East Germany ends up dominant over West Germany to hide the truth from his mother. He finally shows her a conclusion in which Germany gets reunified, but not through East Germany being reabsorbed by West Germany; instead the Bonn Republic is dissolved so that its people can join the GDR!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
spoiler


** Any time Alex notices a sign of West Germany within proximity of his mother's bedroom. The first is when their neighbor is watching ARD's ''Tagesschau'', causing Christiane to wonder why he is watching West German television. And then there's the Coca-Cola banner.

to:

** Any time Alex notices a sign of West Germany within proximity of his mother's bedroom. The [[spoiler:The first is when their neighbor is watching ARD's ''Tagesschau'', causing Christiane to wonder why he is watching West German television. And then there's the Coca-Cola banner.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* ExcitedShowTitle: ''Good Bye, Lenin!'' is a title that officially includes an exclamation mark.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
rem 'houston we have problem' as not being known before 1995 - it was!


** At one point, Denis says "[[Film/Apollo13 Houston, we have a problem.]]" While the Apollo 13 mission did take place twenty years earlier, the phrase was not popularized until the film ''Apollo 13'' was released in 1995.[[note]]In fact, the actual phrase that Jim Lovell used when the accident occurred was "Houston, ''we've had'' a problem." The phrase Creator/TomHanks used in the movie is actually a misquote.[[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WhyWeAreBummedCommunismFell: And how it affected some people more than others- TV repairman Alex fairly quickly finds a better job as a satellite dish installer and his sister, finding her pursuit of a degree in Marxist-Leninist economics suddenly obsolete, gets a job at Burger King, but several neighbors in their 50s are unemployed with no prospects. Even East German cosmonaut Sigmund Jähn seems to have ended up as a cab driver after the fall of communism.

to:

* WhyWeAreBummedCommunismFell: And how it affected some people more than others- others. TV repairman Alex fairly quickly finds a better job as a satellite dish installer and his sister, finding her pursuit of a degree in Marxist-Leninist economics suddenly obsolete, gets a job at Burger King, but several neighbors in their 50s are unemployed with no prospects. Even East German cosmonaut Sigmund Jähn seems to have ended up as a cab driver after the fall of communism.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''Good Bye, Lenin!'' is a German [[{{Dramedy}} bittersweet comedy]] from 2003, directed by Wolfgang Becker and starring Creator/DanielBruhl. Has a lot of subtle humor, playing on the feeling of shell-shock many East Germans felt upon being catapulted into the Capitalist world and the almost overnight disappearance of their country. Many of the visual clues might be easy to miss for people not familiar with the common cliches about the GDR. The film also put actor Creator/DanielBruhl on the map.

to:

''Good Bye, Lenin!'' is a German [[{{Dramedy}} bittersweet comedy]] from 2003, directed by Wolfgang Becker and starring Creator/DanielBruhl. Has a lot of subtle humor, playing on the feeling of shell-shock many East Germans felt upon being catapulted into the Capitalist capitalist world and the almost overnight disappearance of their country. Many of the visual clues might be easy to miss for people not familiar with the common cliches about the GDR. The film also put actor Creator/DanielBruhl on the map.
was Brühl's StarMakingRole.

Added: 115

Changed: 36

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CentralTheme: The world around you can change faster than you wish, but you have to try and make the most of it.



* {{Reconstruction}}: Yes, Communism was not a really great thing and most of the GDR former citizens are happy about the change, ''but'', some find themselves without a job and the old organization was providing for everyone, even if very limited. Simply put, going from communism to capitalism is a massive shift that some people aren't really prepared for.

to:

* {{Reconstruction}}: Yes, Communism was not a really great thing and most of the GDR former citizens are happy about the change, ''but'', some find themselves without a job and the old organization was providing for everyone, even if very limited. Simply put, going from communism to capitalism is a massive shift that some people aren't really prepared for.for and doesn't give everybody benefits.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Reconstruction}}: Yes, Communism was not a really great thing and most of the GDR former citizens are happy about the change, ''but'', some find themselves without a job and the old organization was providing for everyone, even if very limitedly.

to:

* {{Reconstruction}}: Yes, Communism was not a really great thing and most of the GDR former citizens are happy about the change, ''but'', some find themselves without a job and the old organization was providing for everyone, even if very limitedly.limited. Simply put, going from communism to capitalism is a massive shift that some people aren't really prepared for.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RuleOfFunny: Alex's quest to find ''Spreewaldgurken'' (Spreewald pickles) for his mother. In reality, they were one of the few East German products that were available without interruption during and after reunification. You can still buy them today in most German supermarkets. But it helps underline that their supermarket has literally changed overnight.

to:

* RuleOfFunny: Alex's quest to find ''Spreewaldgurken'' (Spreewald pickles) for his mother.Christiane. In reality, they were one of the few East German products that were available without interruption during and after reunification. You can still buy them today in most German supermarkets. But it helps underline that their supermarket has literally changed overnight.

Removed: 1541

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
How is this not all just a tirade? At any rate, it's not Jerkass Has A Point unless other characters recognize it's true or the plot meant it to be true, which is debatable for all listed (certainly not the bankteller). And listing the main character as an inversion is just weird and surely must fit another trope if it's even true. This sounds more like Straw Man Has A Point, which is YMMV.


* JerkassHasAPoint:
** '''Alex:''' Inverted. For someone who claims to be doing the right thing, he comes across as a jerkass about it, and may even be totally misguided.
** '''Ariane:''' As far as she's concerned, she's trying her best to build a new life along with her boyfriend and to do the best for her daughter; and has a point when she's frustrated with Alex's scheme, given how totally unrealistic it proves and how [[spoiler: it's actually the painful memories of separation and how they were treated by the regime that kills their mother in the end, not its surprise downfall; she might have been better off in hospital.]]
** '''Rainer:''' Despite his portrayal (from Alex's viewpoint) as an entitled, unconcerned Wessi, like Ariane his life has basically been turned upside down by Alex's schemes. He has reason to protest things like the fact he's been paying the rent, he genuinely has no reason given his upbringing to see why the East Germans around him are constantly complaining, and in spite of everything he does his best to play along and do the "right thing".
** '''The new doctor:''' It's not his fault that his predecessor moved to the West, and he's only giving his professional opinion, [[spoiler: which by the end would seem to be right.]]
** '''The bank employees:''' It's not the clerk's fault that he can't exchange the family's life savings; he doesn't make the rules, and doesn't personally deserve the harassment from angry East Germans. Likewise, the security guards who throw Alex out are only doing their jobs.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
This ain't true


** It's very unlikely that a Soviet nurse or medical student would be in East Berlin, since the Soviet Union was extremely restrictive about its citizens leaving the country even for short-term tourist trips or to visit friendly socialist nations. East Germany was not a Third World country in need of foreign professionals, and the Soviet Union didn't feel any need to send its students for training abroad. Certainly there were Soviet medics working in the GDR, but they were affiliated with the Soviet military or diplomatic missions, and mainly treated other Soviet citizens. Although emigration from the USSR had become more within the realm of possibility by 1989 due to Perestroika, it's also hard to imagine someone using this newly-found opportunity to go to the GDR, which remained a much more dogmatic and repressive communist regime than the Soviet Union under Gorbachev.

Top