Follow TV Tropes

Following

History BaseBreaker / SURVIVOR

Go To


Added DiffLines:

** It should be noted that Sandra has stated in an interview about the Goat incident that she was just repeating what a certain Farmer was saying, and that said certain farmer did in fact eat the goats while she was doing a confessional.

Added DiffLines:

** Chris' victory. While it's agreed his risky move was universally agreed to be impressive, a lot of fans are torn on whether he deserved to win due to the fact he only really played 12 days or if he was best choice of the final 3 due to being the only one with a true gameplay


* Sebastian "Seabass" has a couple of fans for his {{Cloudcuckoolander}} tendencies. However, he has a couple of haters thanks to his poor performance in his final tribal council in which he doesn't use his extra vote despite it being his last chance to use it, the belief that he was generally not doing anything in the game at all (despite many post-game interviews stating he would have won if he made it to the FTC).

to:

* Sebastian "Seabass" has a couple of fans for his {{Cloudcuckoolander}} tendencies. However, he has a couple of haters thanks to his poor performance in his final tribal council in which he doesn't use his extra vote despite it being his last chance to use it, it as well as the belief that he was generally not doing anything in the game at all (despite many post-game interviews stating he would have won if he made it to the FTC).

Added DiffLines:

* Rick Devens from ''Edge of Extinction''. Due to being such a big character, he tends to get the spotlight more than the remaining castwawys, and this has people split; he's either an entertaining and fun character with a scrappy underdog story that people love, or he's an annoying and unlikable camera hog who's edit is growing very similar to that of [[MemeticLoser Ben's]], which has people worrying that he's going to win by less-than-stellar means. Especially as a lot of people are hoping for another female winner.


* Fans are ''torn'' about who deserved to win Ghost Island more - the winner [[TheSocialExpert Wendell]] or the close runner-up [[TheStrategist Domenick]]. Fans who are for Wendell believe he is proof that social game is still the most important attribute to have in a cut-throat game as Survivor, citing that the last five jurors and Laurel voted for him due to being around him longer and finding him more likable than Dom. Fans who are for Domenick think he was unfairly screwed by a bitter jury who couldn't accept his phenomenal strategic and Godfather-like play, or lay the blame on Laurel for voting for Wendell instead of him, with some even claiming she only voted for him because they're both black. [[RuleOfCautiousEditingJudgment That's all we'll say on that matter.]] But needless to say, this split debate has very little middle ground.

to:

* Fans are ''torn'' about who deserved to win Ghost Island more - the winner [[TheSocialExpert Wendell]] or the close runner-up [[TheStrategist Domenick]]. Fans who are for Wendell believe he is proof that social game is still the most important attribute to have in a cut-throat game as Survivor, citing that the last five jurors and Laurel voted for him due to being around him longer and finding him more likable than Dom. Fans who are for Domenick think he was unfairly screwed by a bitter jury who couldn't accept his phenomenal strategic and Godfather-like play, or lay the blame on Laurel for voting for Wendell instead of him, with some even claiming she only voted for him because they're both black. [[RuleOfCautiousEditingJudgment [[Administrivia/RuleOfCautiousEditingJudgment That's all we'll say on that matter.]] But needless to say, this split debate has very little middle ground.


** Zeke Smith. While initially a rather likable castaway who was seen as an underdog and charismatic character, his popularity took a rather nasty plummet in episode ten, where he became condescending, arrogant and rude. He was especially nasty in the second tribal council, when he openly mocked David for his anxiety and tauntingly questioned if he was going to cry. A lot of people online - especially those who face anxiety and neuroticism - grew disgusted with his attitude, and most have jumped ship from the Zeke bandwagon. It's hard to say currently if he's a BaseBreakingCharacter, or a full-on TheScrappy. This has increased even more when it was revealed that he would be cast on ''Game Changers'', over more popular male players from his season like David or Jay.

to:

** Zeke Smith. While initially a rather likable castaway who was seen as an underdog and charismatic character, his popularity took a rather nasty plummet in episode ten, where he became condescending, arrogant and rude. He was especially nasty in the second tribal council, when he openly mocked David for his anxiety and tauntingly questioned if he was going to cry. A lot of people online - especially those who face anxiety and neuroticism - grew disgusted with his attitude, and most have jumped ship from the Zeke bandwagon. It's hard to say currently if he's a BaseBreakingCharacter, or a full-on TheScrappy. This has increased even more when it was revealed that he would be cast on ''Game Changers'', over more popular male players from his season like David or Jay.


* Ryan Ulrich and Chrissy Hofbeck. On the one hand, they're liked because they're competent strategists, genuinely friendly, and both had a CrowningMomentOfAwesome before the merge. On the other hand, opinions have soured as the game wore on and revealed their weaknesses: Pride for Chrissy and ChronicBackstabbingDisorder for Ryan. Ryan gets the worst of it as his poor handling of alliances leads him to betray the same person twice in a row and lose the trust of everyone but Chrissy. The result is that, ironically, they are both pretty well liked on their own, but considered insufferable when they're together.

to:

* Ryan Ulrich and Chrissy Hofbeck. On the one hand, they're liked because they're competent strategists, genuinely friendly, and both had a CrowningMomentOfAwesome SugarWiki/MomentOfAwesome before the merge. On the other hand, opinions have soured as the game wore on and revealed their weaknesses: Pride for Chrissy and ChronicBackstabbingDisorder for Ryan. Ryan gets the worst of it as his poor handling of alliances leads him to betray the same person twice in a row and lose the trust of everyone but Chrissy. The result is that, ironically, they are both pretty well liked on their own, but considered insufferable when they're together.


* Fans are *torn* about who deserved to win Ghost Island more - the winner [[TheSocialExpert Wendell]] or the close runner-up [[TheStrategist Domenick]]. Fans who are for Wendell believe he is proof that social game is still the most important attribute to have in a cut-throat game as Survivor, citing that the last five jurors and Laurel voted for him due to being around him longer and finding him more likable than Dom. Fans who are for Domenick think he was unfairly screwed by a bitter jury who couldn't accept his phenomenal strategic and Godfather-like play, or lay the blame on Laurel for voting for Wendell instead of him, with some even claiming she only voted for him because they're both black. [[RuleOfCautiousEditingJudgment That's all we'll say on that matter.]] But needless to say, this split debate has very little middle ground.

to:

* Fans are *torn* ''torn'' about who deserved to win Ghost Island more - the winner [[TheSocialExpert Wendell]] or the close runner-up [[TheStrategist Domenick]]. Fans who are for Wendell believe he is proof that social game is still the most important attribute to have in a cut-throat game as Survivor, citing that the last five jurors and Laurel voted for him due to being around him longer and finding him more likable than Dom. Fans who are for Domenick think he was unfairly screwed by a bitter jury who couldn't accept his phenomenal strategic and Godfather-like play, or lay the blame on Laurel for voting for Wendell instead of him, with some even claiming she only voted for him because they're both black. [[RuleOfCautiousEditingJudgment That's all we'll say on that matter.]] But needless to say, this split debate has very little middle ground.


* Sebastion "Seabass" has a couple of fans for his {{Cloudcuckoolander}} tendecies. However, he has a couple of haters thanks to his poor performance in his final tribal council in which he doesn't use his extra vote despite it being his last chance to use it, the belief that he was generally not doing anything in the game at all (despite many post-game interviews stating he would have won if he made it to the FTC).

to:

* Sebastion Sebastian "Seabass" has a couple of fans for his {{Cloudcuckoolander}} tendecies. tendencies. However, he has a couple of haters thanks to his poor performance in his final tribal council in which he doesn't use his extra vote despite it being his last chance to use it, the belief that he was generally not doing anything in the game at all (despite many post-game interviews stating he would have won if he made it to the FTC).FTC).
* Fans are *torn* about who deserved to win Ghost Island more - the winner [[TheSocialExpert Wendell]] or the close runner-up [[TheStrategist Domenick]]. Fans who are for Wendell believe he is proof that social game is still the most important attribute to have in a cut-throat game as Survivor, citing that the last five jurors and Laurel voted for him due to being around him longer and finding him more likable than Dom. Fans who are for Domenick think he was unfairly screwed by a bitter jury who couldn't accept his phenomenal strategic and Godfather-like play, or lay the blame on Laurel for voting for Wendell instead of him, with some even claiming she only voted for him because they're both black. [[RuleOfCautiousEditingJudgment That's all we'll say on that matter.]] But needless to say, this split debate has very little middle ground.


** Survivor: San Juan Del Sur can be disliked for the lack of savvy cast that season. However, a lot of fans believed that they have a very interesting post-merge gameplay with a much more balanced edit compared to previous seasons and they felt they can't truly dislike that season because of that. Some other fans believe that season was VindicatedByHistory since the final five of Survivor: Cambodia ended up having all three representatives from San Juan Del Sur in it where one of them went on to win the show with an unanimous vote.

to:

** Survivor: San Juan Del Sur can be disliked for the lack of a savvy cast that season. However, a lot of fans believed that they have a very interesting post-merge gameplay with a much more balanced edit compared to previous seasons and they felt they can't truly dislike that season because of that. Some other fans believe that season was VindicatedByHistory since the final five of Survivor: Cambodia ended up having all three representatives from San Juan Del Sur in it where one of them went on to win the show with an unanimous vote.


* Sebastion "Seabass" has a couple of fans for his {{Cloudcuckoolander}} tendecies. However, he has a couple of haters thanks to his poor performance in his final tribal council in which he doesn't use his extra vote despite it being his last chance to use it, the belief that he was generally not doing anything in the game at all (despite many post-game interviews stating he would have won if he made it to the FTC), and unjustifiably getting mad Domenick in the finale for voting him off even when he was the one who tried to vote him off first.

to:

* Sebastion "Seabass" has a couple of fans for his {{Cloudcuckoolander}} tendecies. However, he has a couple of haters thanks to his poor performance in his final tribal council in which he doesn't use his extra vote despite it being his last chance to use it, the belief that he was generally not doing anything in the game at all (despite many post-game interviews stating he would have won if he made it to the FTC), and unjustifiably getting mad Domenick in the finale for voting him off even when he was the one who tried to vote him off first.FTC).


*** Prior to the finale, ''Heroes Vs Healers Vs Hustlers'' was praised for the cast and how many of them were willing to make big moves and take risks to win the game. However, the EndingAversion that includes the infamous fire-making twist at the end made fans turned on the season as many fans believe it was extremely unsatisfying. However, the season has slightly more tolerable thanks to the complaints that ''Ghost Island'' had making it more of a BrokenBase.

to:

*** Prior to the finale, ''Heroes Vs Healers Vs Hustlers'' was praised for the cast and how many of them were willing to make big moves and take risks to win the game. However, the EndingAversion that includes the infamous fire-making twist at the end made fans turned on the season as many fans believe it was extremely unsatisfying. However, [[VindicatedByHistory the season has been slightly more tolerable well-liked]] thanks to the complaints that ''Ghost Island'' had making it more of a BrokenBase.


*** Prior to the finale, ''Heroes Vs Healers Vs Hustlers'' was praised for the cast and how many of them were willing to make big moves and take risks to win the game. However, the EndingAversion that includes the infamous fire-making twist at the end made fans turned on the season as many fans believe it was extremely unsatisfying. However, the season has slightly more tolerable thanks to the complaints that ''Ghost Island'' making it more of a BrokenBase.

to:

*** Prior to the finale, ''Heroes Vs Healers Vs Hustlers'' was praised for the cast and how many of them were willing to make big moves and take risks to win the game. However, the EndingAversion that includes the infamous fire-making twist at the end made fans turned on the season as many fans believe it was extremely unsatisfying. However, the season has slightly more tolerable thanks to the complaints that ''Ghost Island'' had making it more of a BrokenBase.


* Sebastion "Seabass" has a couple of fans for his {{CloudCuckooLander}} tendecies. However, he has a couple of haters thanks to his poor performance in his final tribal council in which he doesn't use his extra vote despite it being his last chance to use it, the belief that he was generally not doing anything in the game at all (despite many post-game interviews stating he would have won if he made it to the FTC), and unjustifiably getting mad Domenick in the finale for voting him off even when he was the one who tried to vote him off first.

to:

* Sebastion "Seabass" has a couple of fans for his {{CloudCuckooLander}} {{Cloudcuckoolander}} tendecies. However, he has a couple of haters thanks to his poor performance in his final tribal council in which he doesn't use his extra vote despite it being his last chance to use it, the belief that he was generally not doing anything in the game at all (despite many post-game interviews stating he would have won if he made it to the FTC), and unjustifiably getting mad Domenick in the finale for voting him off even when he was the one who tried to vote him off first.

Added DiffLines:

* Sebastion "Seabass" has a couple of fans for his {{CloudCuckooLander}} tendecies. However, he has a couple of haters thanks to his poor performance in his final tribal council in which he doesn't use his extra vote despite it being his last chance to use it, the belief that he was generally not doing anything in the game at all (despite many post-game interviews stating he would have won if he made it to the FTC), and unjustifiably getting mad Domenick in the finale for voting him off even when he was the one who tried to vote him off first.

Showing 15 edit(s) of 94

Top

Example of:

/
/

Feedback