Follow TV Tropes

Following

History AdaptationDisplacement / LiveActionFilm

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Many people will be surprised to learn that ''Film/TheMummyTrilogy'' is a very loose adaptation of [[Film/TheMummy1932 a 1932-horror movie]]. It actually led to some confusion when Universal decided to do [[Film/TheMummy2017 another reboot in 2017]] as part of their planned Film/DarkUniverse which was based on the original movie instead of the more popular movies from the late 90s/early 2000s, as many people were unaware of it's existence in the first place.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Trope was cut/disambiguated due to cleanup


* ''Film/TheCrow''. The 1994 film was a critical and commercial success, but how many people have read [[Comicbook/TheCrow the original graphic novel]], first published in 1989?

to:

* ''Film/TheCrow''. ''Film/TheCrow1994''. The 1994 film was a critical and commercial success, but how many people have read [[Comicbook/TheCrow the original graphic novel]], first published in 1989?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Film/MammaMia'' is an adaptation of [[Theatre/MammaMia a musical]] that opened on London's West End in 1999 and on Broadway in 2001. Both productions were still running at the time of the film's release, with the Broadway production closing in 2015 while the West End production still runs to this day. Due to the film's popularity, the stage musical has become a popular choice for schools and community theatres to produce, although it leads some to believe that the stage musical is a ScreenToStageAdaptation, and not the other way around.

to:

* The 2008 musical film ''Film/MammaMia'' is an adaptation of [[Theatre/MammaMia a stage musical]] that opened on London's West End in 1999 and on Broadway in 2001. Both productions were still running at the time of the film's release, with the Broadway production closing in 2015 while the West End production still runs to this day. Due to the film's popularity, the stage musical has become a popular choice for schools and community theatres to produce, although it leads some to believe that the stage musical is a ScreenToStageAdaptation, and not the other way around. The movie was originally billed as ''Mamma Mia! TheMovie'', but the latter part was eventually dropped once it proved to be more popular than the original ''Mamma Mia!'' The original DVD release of the movie includes a promo for the stage musical.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
link


* ''Literature/GentlemenPreferBlondes'' is most remembered as the title of a 1953 movie starring Jane Russell and Creator/MarilynMonroe. It's sometimes forgotten that this was loosely adapted from a Broadway musical (but not so loosely as to discard the show's most famous songs) adapted from a best-selling novel by Anita Loos.

to:

* ''Literature/GentlemenPreferBlondes'' ''Film/GentlemenPreferBlondes'' is most remembered as the title of a 1953 movie starring Jane Russell and Creator/MarilynMonroe. It's sometimes forgotten that this was loosely adapted from a Broadway musical (but not so loosely as to discard the show's most famous songs) adapted from [[Literature/GentlemenPreferBlondes a best-selling novel by Anita Loos.Loos]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Film/TheDeep'': Like ''Film/{{Jaws}}'', this is another Creator/PeterBenchley adaptation better known than the book that it adapts, although not to nearly the same degree.

to:

* ''Film/TheDeep'': ''Film/TheDeep1977'': Like ''Film/{{Jaws}}'', this is another Creator/PeterBenchley adaptation better known than the book that it adapts, although not to nearly the same degree.

Added: 724

Changed: 5

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Film/TheHowling'': The [[Film/TheHowling1981 first film]] is based on the book of the same name...wait, what book? Yep, there was [[Literature/TheHowling1977 a book]], written by Gary Brandner and published in 1977, though few people have heard of it in comparison to the much more famous film. The film's basic plot follows the book (woman goes to stay in the countryside after a traumatic experience and gets terrorized by werewolves) but it's otherwise a rather loose adaptation. The book also had sequels, although the movie sequels don't follow them at all besides borrowing a few plot points here and there; the fourth film, ''The Original Nightmare'', is technically a TruerToTheText adaptation of the first book.



* The 1990 film ''Film/{{Mermaids}}'' was adapted from a 1986 novel of the same name written by Patty Dann. Seeing as how the novel was unacknowledged on the film's trope page for a while, it's probably safe to assume that the film has overshadowed the novel.

to:

* The 1990 film ''Film/{{Mermaids}}'' ''Film/{{Mermaids|1990}}'' was adapted from a 1986 novel of the same name written by Patty Dann. Seeing as how the novel was unacknowledged on the film's trope page for a while, it's probably safe to assume that the film has overshadowed the novel.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Not many people are aware, despite Daphne du Maurier getting due credit, that ''Film/TheBirds'' is based on one of her short stories.

to:

* Not many people are aware, despite Daphne du Maurier getting due credit, that ''Film/TheBirds'' is based on [[Literature/TheBirds one of her short stories.stories]], albeit it should be noted that the film is practically an InNameOnly adaptation that changes the plot, characters and setting, keeping only the title and the basic premise of birds attacking humans.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Literature/TheBlindSide'' has been almost completely displaced by the film version. Most fans of the film aren't aware that it's based only on part of the book, specifically on the life of the film's subject Michael Oher. The complete book title, ''The Blind Side: Evolution of a Game'', hints that there's a lot more to it. The book also discusses the "evolution" of Oher's position of left offensive tackle at great length.[[note]]The "blind side" is the side of the field that the quarterback can't see when in a normal throwing stance. For a right-hander, which the vast majority of quarterbacks are, that would be the left side of the field.[[/note]]

to:

* ''Literature/TheBlindSide'' has been almost completely displaced by the film version. Most fans of the film aren't aware that it's based only on part of the book, specifically on the life of the film's subject Michael Oher. The complete book title, ''The Blind Side: Evolution of a Game'', hints that there's a lot more to it. The book also discusses the "evolution" of Oher's position of left offensive tackle at great length.[[note]]The "blind side" is the side of the field that the quarterback can't see when in a normal throwing stance. For a right-hander, which the vast majority of quarterbacks are, that would be the left side of the field.field (as viewed from the offense's perspective).[[/note]]



* ''Film/TheExorcist''. Yes, there was a novel before the film, which in turn was based on allegedly true events that took place in the Alexian Brothers Hospital in St. Louis, Missouri. In RealLife, a young ''boy'' was allegedly possessed, but the novel's author changed it to a girl either out of respect or just for fiction's sake.

to:

* ''Film/TheExorcist''. Yes, there was a novel before the film, which in turn was based on allegedly true events that took place in the Alexian Brothers Hospital in St. Louis, Missouri.UsefulNotes/StLouis. In RealLife, a young ''boy'' was allegedly possessed, but the novel's author changed it to a girl either out of respect or just for fiction's sake.



* ''Film/MammaMia'' is an adaptation of [[Theatre/MammaMia a musical]] that opened on London's West End in 1999 and on Broadway in 2001. Both productions were still running at the time of the film's release, with the Broadway production closing in 2015 while the West End production still runs to this day. Due to the film's popularity, the stage musical has becoming a popular choice for schools and community theatres to produce, although it leads some to believe that the stage musical is a ScreenToStageAdaptation, and not the other way around.

to:

* ''Film/MammaMia'' is an adaptation of [[Theatre/MammaMia a musical]] that opened on London's West End in 1999 and on Broadway in 2001. Both productions were still running at the time of the film's release, with the Broadway production closing in 2015 while the West End production still runs to this day. Due to the film's popularity, the stage musical has becoming become a popular choice for schools and community theatres to produce, although it leads some to believe that the stage musical is a ScreenToStageAdaptation, and not the other way around.



* In an example of an adaptation into a third medium causing the displacement, the long-running ''[[Series/{{Mash}} M*A*S*H*]]'' series has led many people to forget that [[Film/{{Mash}} the film on which it was based]] is itself adapted from [[Literature/{{Mash}} a novel]].

to:

* In an example of an adaptation into a third medium causing the displacement, the long-running ''[[Series/{{Mash}} M*A*S*H*]]'' ''Series/{{Mash}}'' series has led many people to forget that [[Film/{{Mash}} the film on which it was based]] is itself adapted from [[Literature/{{Mash}} a novel]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Film/ShallWeDance2004'': Many western fans are unaware of the original 1996 movie at first, even though it has almost the same plot, got better reviews, and has a richer cultural experience to its plot due to ballroom dancing being less accepted by many people in 1990s Japan than in early-2000s America.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Theatre/{{Annie}}'' is a famous musical from TheSeventies about a little red-headed girl who goes through a RagsToRiches story. This became a movie in TheEighties (released in 1982, to be exact). The musical is based off a [[PrintLongRunners long-running]] comic strip called ''ComicStrip/LittleOrphanAnnie'', who most people probably only recognize from ''Film/AChristmasStory'' or ''WesternAnimation/RobotChicken''. Arguably both the stage musical and the strip have been displaced by the 1982 movie.

to:

* ''Theatre/{{Annie}}'' is a famous musical from TheSeventies The70s about a little red-headed girl who goes through a RagsToRiches story. This became a movie in TheEighties The80s (released in 1982, to be exact). The musical is based off a [[PrintLongRunners long-running]] comic strip called ''ComicStrip/LittleOrphanAnnie'', who most people probably only recognize from ''Film/AChristmasStory'' or ''WesternAnimation/RobotChicken''. Arguably both the stage musical and the strip have been displaced by the 1982 movie.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* While ''Series/UpPompeii'' is generally regarded as being superior to its [[Film/UpPompeii film adaptation]], the latter is generally more well-known to modern audiences, thanks to it getting a more widespread home video release and being repeated a little more often on TV.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Hardly anyone remembers the Patricia Highsmith novel that ''Film/StrangersOnATrain'' is based on (though the novel gets a reference in ''Series/{{Castle}}'').

to:

* Hardly anyone remembers the Patricia Highsmith novel that ''Film/StrangersOnATrain'' is based on (though the novel gets a reference in ''Series/{{Castle}}'').''Series/{{Castle|2009}}'').
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* While the novel ''Literature/CharlieAndTheChocolateFactory'' is hardly forgotten, its story and characters are better known from the 1971 film adaptation ''Film/WillyWonkaAndTheChocolateFactory'', which became a popular classic. People accuse the 2005 adaptation ''Film/CharlieAndTheChocolateFactory'' of not being "faithful" to the 1971 film, despite the fact the 2005 film is a much more faithful adaptation of the original novel, and it's actually the 1971 film that heavily deviates from the original source material.

to:

* While the novel ''Literature/CharlieAndTheChocolateFactory'' is hardly forgotten, its story and characters are better known from the 1971 film adaptation ''Film/WillyWonkaAndTheChocolateFactory'', which became a popular classic. People accuse It got to the point where the 2005 adaptation ''Film/CharlieAndTheChocolateFactory'' film adaptation, ''Film/CharlieAndTheChocolateFactory'', was called a remake of the 1971 film and was criticized for not being "faithful" to the 1971 film, it, despite the fact the 2005 film is that it actually ''wasn't'' a much more faithful remake -- it was a standalone adaptation of the original novel, book, and it's actually had restored elements of it that were not present in the 1971 film that heavily deviates from the original source material.adaptation.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Disney managed to displace itself with ''Franchise/PiratesOfTheCaribbean'', which is better known than [[Ride/PiratesOfTheCaribbean the ride]] in Ride/DisneyThemeParks that inspired it. They have since modified the ride to feature Jack Sparrow animatronics in place of some of the generic pirates they had before.

to:

* Disney managed to displace itself with ''Franchise/PiratesOfTheCaribbean'', which is better known than [[Ride/PiratesOfTheCaribbean the ride]] in Ride/DisneyThemeParks that inspired it. They have since modified the ride to feature Captain Jack Sparrow animatronics in place of some of the generic pirates they had before.before, after complaints from patrons wondering where Jack was.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Film/{{Lifeforce}}'', aka the "Naked Space Vampire Movie". While the movie is mostly cult, [[Creator/ColinWilson the book on which it is based]] is even more obscure nowadays.

to:

* ''Film/{{Lifeforce}}'', ''Film/Lifeforce1985'', aka the "Naked Space Vampire Movie". While the movie is mostly cult, [[Creator/ColinWilson the Creator/ColinWilson book on which it is based]] based is even more obscure nowadays. nowadays.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
The Pirates ride wasn't an adaptation of Treasure Island.


** Likewise, the ride displaced the film ''it'' was based on: the 1950 version of ''Film/{{Treasure Island|1950}}''. Hence, the film series is based on a ride, based on a film, based on [[Literature/TreasureIsland a book]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Removing complaining and redirect to Film.Children Of Men.


* ''Literature/ChildrenOfMen'' was originally a 1992 dystopian novel by author P.D. James, which has since been completely overshadowed in most pop culture circles by Creator/AlfonsoCuaron's overly gritty-realist [[Film/ChildrenOfMen 2006 film adaptation of the same name]] which features Hollywood stars Creator/CliveOwen, Creator/JulianneMoore and Creator/MichaelCaine.

to:

* ''Literature/ChildrenOfMen'' ''Film/ChildrenOfMen'' was originally a 1992 dystopian novel by author P.D. James, which has since been completely overshadowed in most pop culture circles by Creator/AlfonsoCuaron's overly gritty-realist [[Film/ChildrenOfMen 2006 film adaptation of the same name]] name which features Hollywood stars Creator/CliveOwen, Creator/JulianneMoore and Creator/MichaelCaine.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Film/AtomicBlonde'' is based on a graphic novel, ''The Coldest City'', but said graphic novel is so obscure that it doesn't even have a Wikipedia article. It doesn't help either that the movie was not promoted as a comic book adaptation (less so have a comic book tie-in, as some comic book adaptations have), possibly to distance itself from contemporary superhero films.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The 1938 film ''Film/{{Algiers}}'' is a remake of the 1937 film ''Film/PepeLeMoko''. The producers of the remake [[MissingEpisode tried to destroy all copies of the previous film]], and darn near succeeded. Also, in neither film did Creator/JeanGabin or Creator/CharlesBoyer say any variation of "[[BeamMeUpScotty Come with me to ze Casbah]].": Only ''Algiers''[='s=] [[MissingTrailerScene trailer did]].

to:

* The 1938 film ''Film/{{Algiers}}'' is a remake of the 1937 film ''Film/PepeLeMoko''. The producers of the remake [[MissingEpisode tried to destroy all copies of the previous film]], and darn near succeeded. Also, in neither film did Creator/JeanGabin or nor Creator/CharlesBoyer say any variation of "[[BeamMeUpScotty Come with me to ze Casbah]].": Only ''Algiers''[='s=] [[MissingEpisode now-lost]] [[MissingTrailerScene trailer did]].



* ''Film/GoneWithTheWind'', InUniverse example: On an episode of ''Series/{{Roseanne}}'', despite being told three times that ''Gone With the Wind'' was originally a book, Roseanne still can't contain her astonishment.

to:

* ''Film/GoneWithTheWind'', InUniverse example: On an episode of ''Series/{{Roseanne}}'', despite being told three times that ''Gone With the Wind'' ''Film/GoneWithTheWind'' was originally a book, Roseanne novel by Margaret Mitchell. While the novel is still can't contain her astonishment.relatively popular, is far less remembered than the movie. Generally, it's not discovered until adulthood.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
if it's averted it's just not used


* ''WesternAnimation/{{Jem}} and The Holograms'''s [[Film/JemAndTheHolograms2015 live-action adaptation]] was anticipated to be this to the target audience of teenagers, as the cartoon came out 30 years before the film. Ultimately averted, as both the cartoon and [[ComicBook/JemAndTheHologramsIDW IDW comic adaptation]] are well known, the film was too unfaithful for older fans and too poorly marketed to attract new ones, so it sunk like a stone at the box office.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Film/{{Hairspray}}'': Everybody knows the 2007 musical... which was adapted from a Broadway show that was based on [[http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0095270/ a movie released in 1988]] which ''wasn't actually a musical''.

to:

* ''Film/{{Hairspray}}'': ''Film/{{Hairspray|2007}}'': Everybody knows the 2007 musical... which was adapted from [[Theatre/{{Hairspray}} a Broadway show show]] that was based on [[http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0095270/ [[Film/Hairspray1988 a movie released in 1988]] which ''wasn't actually a musical''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Field of Dreams is also an example.

Added DiffLines:

* ''Film/FieldOfDreams'' is much better-known than the Creator/WPKinsella novel it was based on, ''Shoeless Joe''. And the novel was actually an expansion of an earlier and much less well-known Kinsella short story, "Shoeless Joe Jackson Comes to Iowa".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
index wick


* The movie ''Film/FastTimesAtRidgemontHigh'' is remembered for many things today. Creator/SeanPenn's breakout performance as Jeff Spicoli, his "Hey bud, let's party" CatchPhrase, his battles with Creator/RayWalston and the [[CaughtWithYourPantsDown poolside scene]] with Creator/JudgeReinhold and Creator/PhoebeCates. It has been almost forgotten that it was based on a novel by Creator/CameronCrowe, which was based on his year undercover at a Southern California high school.

to:

* The movie ''Film/FastTimesAtRidgemontHigh'' is remembered for many things today. Creator/SeanPenn's breakout performance as Jeff Spicoli, his "Hey bud, let's party" CatchPhrase, catchphrase, his battles with Creator/RayWalston and the [[CaughtWithYourPantsDown poolside scene]] with Creator/JudgeReinhold and Creator/PhoebeCates. It has been almost forgotten that it was based on a novel by Creator/CameronCrowe, which was based on his year undercover at a Southern California high school.

Top