Follow TV Tropes

Following

Archived Discussion WMG / AvatarTheLastAirbender

Go To

This is discussion archived from a time before the current discussion method was installed.


Aiguille: What's the etiquette on spoilerplate shelf-life for this particular show, exactly? Is it all right to reveal barred text once a given episode has aired in all American timezones? Should there be a given wait period after? I am wondering about the barred Day of Black Sun text. That's rather vintage.

Lale: Cut the last theory because it's not a "wild, off-the-wall" Epileptic Tree but a common, realistic interpretation.

Fast Eddie: Preserving the text is the way we do it, Lale

* Ozai favors Azula over Zuko not only because of her personality and talent, but also because of her birth order. Ozai is the second child of his father, and it's pretty clear that Azulon heavily favored Iroh and was rather disdainful of Ozai. Thus, Ozai sympathizes more with his own second child than with his firstborn, and treats them accordingly.

Ununnilium: Really, it doesn't have to be that off-the-wall to fit in Wild Mass Guessing. I say put it back.

Lale: No, keep this different from the Theories threads in fora.


Lale: Word of God has declared the card game characters to be officially not canon, so cutting:

"According to the card game there was indeed a surviving Air Bender aside from Aang who survived because he sold out his brethren. Whether or not this is canon is unknown."

Lale: Rebuttals are obsolete; the point is none of this is plausible anyway.


Ununnilium: There's a problem here; Air is one of the Eastern elements, but Earth isn't.

Nickel: Here's the thing: The elements featured in Avatar are Water, Earth, Fire, Air, and to a lesser extent, the Void, or Spirit. This specific grouping of elemental concepts, as well as the idea of an Avatar, stem from Hindu religion. (see these links: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Avatar http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Five_elements_%28Japanese_philosophy%29

Nickel Okay, maybe this belongs on the It Just Bugs Me! page, but can anybody tell me why Toph dying is such a popular theory? Is it because she's disabled, and therefore regarded by a disturbing amount of the fanbase as "expendable?" Or is it the same situation, but I should just replace "disabled" with "single"? (grumble...)

Gloating Swine: Four Is Death. Joined fourth. Though of the Gaang as it stands now, she's actually the fifth, or possibly even ninth member to appear on the show, depending on who you count. Zuko, Suki, Haru, Pipsqueak, and The Duke all appeared before her.


Theories cut from the main page:


Lale: Okay, all the plot theories about Day of Black Sun and the finale are not Epileptic Trees or Wild Mass Guessing according to use of the term on this site. They're just... generic theories, the type fans discuss in communities and in fora. I think genuine predictions about how the plot would play out should be cut. That is a common Internet fandom practice, but it's just not Wild Mass Guessing. None of the other WMG pages look as messy as this because of such theories written amongst the Epileptic Trees, not even Harry Potter.

More cut theories:

Lale: There is a category of threads at Distant Horizons called Theories. Wild Mass Guessing is not a Theories forum thread. "Ursa is Lyra Belacqua" is Wild Mass Guessing. Valid theories are just speculation. Besides, it's inviting thousand of bullets points with evidence pointing to Yay or Nay.

Since no one else seems to care, I'm cutting at-one-time-valid plot predictions for the same reason; people only posted them here so they could have gloated if they came true, anyway. Get this page into some semblance of legibility.

Plot Predictions Now Moot:


Black Charizard: Even after all the cutting, this page is still pretty messy. We should thing some categorization system to sort all the theories here.

Top