Follow TV Tropes

Archived Discussion Main / IdenticalGrandson

Go To

This is discussion archived from a time before the current discussion method was installed.

Muninn: Changed the trope description from 'usually a subverted trope by this point' to "usually an averted trope by this point". Couldn't really see how this trope could be subverted.

Ununnilium: Took out the Futurama example, because that's not the same thing at all.

movie007: Somehow, the Futurama has made its way back on the page. Anyway, that example would fit better in My Own Grampa. I'm not sure if I should remove it, though.

wia: Is the Harry Potter example valid? After all, Harry isn't identical to either parent, merely 'very similar' to his father. The only person who ever mistook the two was Harry (when near-death and blinded), so they cannot have been entirely identical...

Looney Toons: Chowder, given that your contribution is the fourth example under "Real Life", emphasizing it with "Don't say this shit never happens" is unnecessary. Not to mention unnecessarily profane — you sound like someone started an argument with you somewhere on the page.
I just added a manga example for Suzumiya Haruhi in the anime section. Should I instead have added a manga section, or changed the anime to anime and manga?

Seikai: Typically, people just change the "Anime" section to being named "Anime and Manga" when they think of manga examples. I changed it to be named that here as well.

Demashita Powerpuff Girls Z. But I've never seen the anime, so I'm not sure how to write that one. I only remember it has something like "O-edo Superpowered Girls". —Kakurady Drakenar


Example of: