Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / StarWarsTalesOfTheEmpire

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* UnintentionallyUnsympathetic: Despite her above-noted attempt at CharacterRerailment and her reforming, Barriss' redemption felt off to some. Her previous bombing of the Jedi temple aside, she did not really bring up her terrorist actions or show explicit remorse nor reflection on them. Additionally, her attempts to convince the young Jedi she and the Fourth Sister found come across as manipulation at best, as her attempt to "help" the Jedi would, at most have gotten the Jedi tortured into being an Inquisitor (although Barriss quickly leaves them) Also, in her third episode, [[spoiler:after stalling the Fourth Sister for a bit, Barriss stands aside and lets her continued to pursue the family with the force-sensitive baby she's after while they are in view, in a very misguided attempt to "redeem" her despite Fourth Sister implicitly trying to kill them and kidnap their baby. Combine this with the fact Fourth Sister massacred a village in the prior episodes without remorse and fanatically served an evil empire (albeit out of fear), even going as far as to let herself be stabbed and Barriss comes across as a borderline IdiotHero who takes unnecessary risks in a misguided effort to redeem someone who seems irredeemable. (It's probably worth noting that Barriss knows the other nature of this specific cave and that Fourth Sister would be trapped while the family escapes, but it still comes across a messed up to not directly stop her on principle.) Granted, this did seem to work at the end, but only time will tell. ]]

to:

* UnintentionallyUnsympathetic: Despite her above-noted attempt at CharacterRerailment and her reforming, Barriss' redemption felt off to some. Her previous bombing of the Jedi temple aside, she did not really bring up her terrorist actions or show explicit remorse nor reflection on them. Additionally, her attempts to convince the young Jedi she and the Fourth Sister found come across as manipulation at best, as her attempt to "help" the Jedi would, at most have gotten the Jedi tortured into being an Inquisitor (although Barriss quickly leaves them) Also, in her third episode, [[spoiler:after stalling the Fourth Sister for a bit, Barriss stands aside and lets her continued to pursue the family with the force-sensitive baby she's after while they are in view, in a very misguided attempt to "redeem" her despite Fourth Sister implicitly trying to kill them and kidnap their baby. Combine this with the fact Fourth Sister massacred a village in the prior episodes without remorse and fanatically served an evil empire (albeit out of fear), even going as far as to let herself be stabbed and Barriss comes across as a borderline IdiotHero who takes unnecessary risks in a misguided effort to redeem someone who seems irredeemable. (It's probably worth noting that Barriss knows the other nature of this specific cave and that Fourth Sister would be trapped while the family escapes, but it still comes across a as messed up to not directly stop her on principle.) Granted, this did seem to work at the end, but only time will tell. ]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** General Grievous' depiction in ''WesternAnimation/StarWarsCloneWars'' depicted him as an unstoppable badass, which left many fans disappointed when he was hit with BadassDecay during ''Film/RevengeOfTheSith'', depicting him more as a DirtyCoward. While ''The Clone Wars'' did restore his credibility as a threat somewhat, many were disappointed that he was still a {{Jobber}} in some episodes (he lost to ''Gungans'' for Pete's sake), and a mustache-twirling villain in others that was still willing to cut and run when the going got tough. He gets the Darth Vader treatment in this series, depicting him as unstoppable nightmare who decimates the Nightsisters with ease, and toys with them when he feels they aren't worth the effort.

to:

** General Grievous' depiction in ''WesternAnimation/StarWarsCloneWars'' depicted him as an unstoppable badass, which left many fans disappointed when he was hit with BadassDecay during ''Film/RevengeOfTheSith'', depicting him more as a DirtyCoward. While ''The Clone Wars'' did restore his credibility as a threat somewhat, many were disappointed that he was still a {{Jobber}} in some episodes (he lost to ''Gungans'' for Pete's sake), and a mustache-twirling villain in others that was still willing to cut and run when the going got tough. He gets the Darth Vader treatment in this series, depicting him as an unstoppable nightmare who decimates the Nightsisters with ease, and toys with them when he feels they aren't worth the effort.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** General Grievous' depiction in ''WesternAnimation/StarWarsCloneWars'' depicted him as an unstoppable badass, which left many fans disappointed when he was hit with BadassDecay during ''Film/RevengeOfTheSith'', depicting him more as a DirtyCoward. While ''The Clone Wars'' did restore his credibility as a threat somewhat, many were disappointed that he was still a {{Jobber}} in some episodes (he lost to ''Gungans'' for Pete's sake), and a mustache-twirling villain in others that was still willing to cut and run when the going got tough. He gets the Darth Vader treatment in this series, depicting him as unstoppable nightmare who decimates the Nightsisters with ease, and toys with them when he feels they aren't worth the effort.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The trailer shot of Marrok and the Unidentified Inquisitor from ''Tales of the Jedi'' raised hopes that they would receive some focus or even a proper name/title for the latter, but they're also just quick cameos.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It's been a long standing fan theory that after her exposure as a traitor to the Jedi Order, Barriss Offee would somehow be involved in the Inquisitorius. The first trailer for the series confirmed that she would play a significant role in its founding.

to:

** It's been a long standing fan theory that after her exposure as a traitor to the Jedi Order, Barriss Offee would somehow be involved in the Inquisitorius. The first trailer for the series confirmed that she would play a significant role in its founding. founding and many fans correctly guessed that she would betray the Inquisitorius and redeem herself.



** Luminara Unduli, Bariss's former Jedi master, was canonically captured and imprisoned by the Inquisitorius, as shown in ''Rebels'', meaning that Bariss could have interacted with her somehow, maybe even helping spark her apprentice's HeelFaceTurn. But she doesn't show up.
** In the final episode, Bariss mentions how an old friend of hers can help bring the family with the force-sensitive child to safety. It's ''heavily'' implied said friend is Ahsoka, but we never learn how they reconnected and reconciled.

to:

** Luminara Unduli, Bariss's former Jedi master, was canonically captured and imprisoned by the Inquisitorius, Inquisitorius before being executed by the Grand Inquisitor, as shown in ''Rebels'', meaning that Bariss Barriss could have interacted with her somehow, maybe even helping spark her apprentice's HeelFaceTurn. But she doesn't show up.
** In the final episode, Bariss Barriss mentions how an old friend of hers can help bring the family with the force-sensitive child to safety. It's ''heavily'' implied said friend is Ahsoka, but we never learn how they reconnected and reconciled.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Fixing a sinkhole


* SugarWiki/AwesomeMusic: As usual, Kevin Kiner delivers some new good tracks. Of particular note is "Morgan Elsbeth - End Credits", which incorporates her leitmotif from ''Series/Ahsoka''.

to:

* SugarWiki/AwesomeMusic: As usual, Kevin Kiner delivers some new good tracks. Of particular note is "Morgan Elsbeth - End Credits", which incorporates her leitmotif from ''Series/Ahsoka''.''Series/{{Ahsoka}}''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SugarWiki/AwesomeMusic: As usual, Kevin Kiner delivers some new good tracks. Of particular note is "Morgan Elsbeth - End Credits", which incorporates her leitmotif from ''Series/Ahsoka''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Doesn't' allow examples.


* {{Jossed}}: While the series shows Barriss Offee joining the Inquisitors, it also makes it clear once and for all that she did ''not'' become the Seventh Sister, a female Mirialan member of Inquisitorius featured in ''WesternAnimation/StarWarsRebels'', as some fans had speculated ever since the latter character first appeared.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ContinuityLockout: Just as with ''Tales of the Jedi'', this show is not meant to be a stand alone show and will require a bit of prior viewing to fully understand. In particular, ''WesternAnimation/StarWarsTheCloneWars'', possibly ''WesternAnimation/StarWarsRebels'', ''Series/TheMandalorian'', and ''Series/{{Ahsoka}}'' are all required viewing to understand both Morgan and Barriss's story arcs.

to:

* ContinuityLockout: Just as with ''Tales of the Jedi'', this show is not meant to be a stand alone standalone show and will require a bit of prior viewing to fully understand. In particular, ''WesternAnimation/StarWarsTheCloneWars'', possibly ''WesternAnimation/StarWarsRebels'', ''Series/TheMandalorian'', and ''Series/{{Ahsoka}}'' are all required viewing to understand both Morgan and Barriss's story arcs.



** Barriss attempts to kindly question a child after Lyn tries to intimidate the whole village. She even takes off her helmet when she realizes it scares the child. The child runs to her for protection after Lyn kills the village, Barriss even let the child take cover behind her when she thinks Lyn was going to strike the child.

to:

** Barriss attempts to kindly question a child after Lyn tries to intimidate the whole village. She even takes off her helmet when she realizes it scares the child. The child runs to her for protection after Lyn kills the village, Barriss even let lets the child take cover behind her when she thinks Lyn was is going to strike the child.



** It's been a long standing fan-theory that after her exposure as a traitor to the Jedi Order, Barriss Offee would somehow be involved in the Inquisitorius. The first trailer for the series confirmed that she would play a significant role in its founding.

to:

** It's been a long standing fan-theory fan theory that after her exposure as a traitor to the Jedi Order, Barriss Offee would somehow be involved in the Inquisitorius. The first trailer for the series confirmed that she would play a significant role in its founding.



** Barriss's characterization in ''[[WesternAnimation/StarWarsTheCloneWars The Clone Wars]]'' - an eventual fallen Jedi who bombed the Jedi Temple and later framed Ahsoka for the deed - was met with a degree of criticism from fans [[CreatorBacklash and her actress in]] ''Film/AttackOfTheClones'' due to both a perceived lack of buildup and how it differed from her ''Legends'' incarnation; a healer who remained loyal to the Jedi Order until her death during Order 66. Her plotline in ''Tales Of The Empire'' shifts her back towards both her ''Legends'' self and her initial characterization in ''The Clone Wars'' to a degree; while she does get recruited into the Inquisitor training program as a result of her crimes, [[spoiler:she never embraces the role in the manner her fellow Inquisitors do, and ultimately renounces the Empire and returns to the light by the end of the show, with her final episode having her risk her life to convince the Fourth Sister to do the same, and indicating that she became a wandering healer]].

to:

** Barriss's characterization in ''[[WesternAnimation/StarWarsTheCloneWars The Clone Wars]]'' - an eventual fallen Jedi who bombed the Jedi Temple and later framed Ahsoka for the deed - was met with a degree of criticism from fans [[CreatorBacklash and her actress in]] ''Film/AttackOfTheClones'' due to both a perceived lack of buildup and how it differed from her ''Legends'' incarnation; a healer who remained loyal to the Jedi Order until her death during Order 66. Her plotline in ''Tales Of The of the Empire'' shifts her back towards both her ''Legends'' self and her initial characterization in ''The Clone Wars'' to a degree; while she does get recruited into the Inquisitor training program as a result of her crimes, [[spoiler:she never embraces the role in the manner her fellow Inquisitors do, and ultimately renounces the Empire and returns to the light by the end of the show, with her final episode having her risk her life to convince the Fourth Sister to do the same, and indicating that she became a wandering healer]].



** Luminara Unduli, Bariss's former Jedi master, was canonically captured and imprisoned by the Inquisitorius, meaning that Bariss could have interacted with her somehow, maybe even helping spark her apprentice's HeelFaceTurn. But she doesn't show up.
** In the final episode, Bariss mentions how an old friend of hers can help bring the family with the force-sensitive child to safety. It's ''heavily'' implied said friend was Ahsoka, but we never learn how they reconnected and reconciled.

to:

** Luminara Unduli, Bariss's former Jedi master, was canonically captured and imprisoned by the Inquisitorius, as shown in ''Rebels'', meaning that Bariss could have interacted with her somehow, maybe even helping spark her apprentice's HeelFaceTurn. But she doesn't show up.
** In the final episode, Bariss mentions how an old friend of hers can help bring the family with the force-sensitive child to safety. It's ''heavily'' implied said friend was is Ahsoka, but we never learn how they reconnected and reconciled.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Jossed}}: While the series shows Barriss Offee joining the Inquisitors, it also makes it clear once and for all that she did ''not'' become the Seventh Sister, a female Mirialan member of Inquisitorius featured in ''WesternAnimation/StarWarsRebels'', as some fans had speculated.

to:

* {{Jossed}}: While the series shows Barriss Offee joining the Inquisitors, it also makes it clear once and for all that she did ''not'' become the Seventh Sister, a female Mirialan member of Inquisitorius featured in ''WesternAnimation/StarWarsRebels'', as some fans had speculated.speculated ever since the latter character first appeared.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Jossed}}: While the series shows Barriss joining the Inquisitors, it makes it clear once and for all that she did ''not'' become the Seventh Sister, another female Mirialan member of Inquisitorius featured in ''WesternAnimation/StarWarsRebels'', as some fans had speculated.

to:

* {{Jossed}}: While the series shows Barriss Offee joining the Inquisitors, it also makes it clear once and for all that she did ''not'' become the Seventh Sister, another a female Mirialan member of Inquisitorius featured in ''WesternAnimation/StarWarsRebels'', as some fans had speculated.

Added: 278

Changed: 14

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Spelling/grammar fix(es)


* {{Jossed}}: While the series shows Barriss joining the Inquisitors, it makes it clear once and for all that she did ''not'' become the Seventh Sister, another female Mirialan member of Inquisitorius featured in ''WesternAnimation/StarWarsRebels'', as some fans had speculated.



* UnintentionallyUnsympathetic: Despite her above-noted attempt at *CharecterRerailment and her reforming, Barriss' redemption felt off to some. Her previous bombing of the Jedi temple aside, she did not really bring up her terrorist actions or show explicit remorse nor reflection on them. Additionally, her attempts to convince the young Jedi she and the Fourth Sister found come across as manipulation at best, as her attempt to "help" the Jedi would, at most have gotten the Jedi tortured into being an Inqusitor (although Bariss quickly leaves them) Also, in her third episode, [[spoiler:after stalling the Fourth Sister for a bit, Bariss stands aside and lets her continued to pursue the family with the force-sensitive baby she's after while they are in view, in a very misguided attempt to "redeem" her despite Fourth Sister implicitly trying to kill them and kidnap their baby. Combine this with the fact Fourth Sister massacred a village in the prior episodes without remorse and fanatically served an evil empire (albiet out of fear), even going as far as to let herself be stabbed and Bariss comes across a borderline *IdiotHero who takes unnecessary risks in a misguided effort to redeem someone who seems irredeemable. (It's probably worth noting that Bariss knows the other nature of this specific cave and that Fourth Sister would be trapped while the family escapes, but it still comes across a messed up to not directly stop her on principle.) Granted, this did seem to work at the end, but only time will tell. ]]

to:

* UnintentionallyUnsympathetic: Despite her above-noted attempt at *CharecterRerailment CharacterRerailment and her reforming, Barriss' redemption felt off to some. Her previous bombing of the Jedi temple aside, she did not really bring up her terrorist actions or show explicit remorse nor reflection on them. Additionally, her attempts to convince the young Jedi she and the Fourth Sister found come across as manipulation at best, as her attempt to "help" the Jedi would, at most have gotten the Jedi tortured into being an Inqusitor Inquisitor (although Bariss Barriss quickly leaves them) Also, in her third episode, [[spoiler:after stalling the Fourth Sister for a bit, Bariss Barriss stands aside and lets her continued to pursue the family with the force-sensitive baby she's after while they are in view, in a very misguided attempt to "redeem" her despite Fourth Sister implicitly trying to kill them and kidnap their baby. Combine this with the fact Fourth Sister massacred a village in the prior episodes without remorse and fanatically served an evil empire (albiet (albeit out of fear), even going as far as to let herself be stabbed and Bariss Barriss comes across as a borderline *IdiotHero IdiotHero who takes unnecessary risks in a misguided effort to redeem someone who seems irredeemable. (It's probably worth noting that Bariss Barriss knows the other nature of this specific cave and that Fourth Sister would be trapped while the family escapes, but it still comes across a messed up to not directly stop her on principle.) Granted, this did seem to work at the end, but only time will tell. ]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In the final episode, Bariss mentions how an old friend of hers can help bring the family with the force sensitive child to safety. It's ''heavily'' implied said friend was Ahsoka, but we never learn how they reconnected and reconciled.

to:

** In the final episode, Bariss mentions how an old friend of hers can help bring the family with the force sensitive force-sensitive child to safety. It's ''heavily'' implied said friend was Ahsoka, but we never learn how they reconnected and reconciled.



* UnintentionallyUnsympathetic: Despite her above-noted attempt at *CharecterRerailment and coming reforming, Barriss' redemption felt off to some. Her previous bombing of the Jedi temple aside, she did not really bring up her terrorist actions or show explicit remorse nor reflection on them. Additionally, her attempts to convince the young Jedi she and the Fourth Sister found come across as manipulation at best, as her attempt to "help" the Jedi would, at most have gotten the Jedi tortured into being an Inqusitor (although Bariss quickly leaves them) Plus, in her third episode, after stalling the Fourth Sister for a bit, Bariss stands aside and lets her continued to pursue the family with the force-sensitive baby she's after while they are in view, despite Fourth Sister implicitly trying to kill them and kidnap their baby a very misguided attempt to "redeem" her, barring the fact Fourth Sister massacred a village in the prior episodes without remoures. (Its probably worth noting that Bariss knows other nature of this specific cave and that Fourth Sister would be trapped while the family escapes, but its still comes across a messed up to not directly stop her on principle.)

to:

* UnintentionallyUnsympathetic: Despite her above-noted attempt at *CharecterRerailment and coming her reforming, Barriss' redemption felt off to some. Her previous bombing of the Jedi temple aside, she did not really bring up her terrorist actions or show explicit remorse nor reflection on them. Additionally, her attempts to convince the young Jedi she and the Fourth Sister found come across as manipulation at best, as her attempt to "help" the Jedi would, at most have gotten the Jedi tortured into being an Inqusitor (although Bariss quickly leaves them) Plus, Also, in her third episode, after [[spoiler:after stalling the Fourth Sister for a bit, Bariss stands aside and lets her continued to pursue the family with the force-sensitive baby she's after while they are in view, in a very misguided attempt to "redeem" her despite Fourth Sister implicitly trying to kill them and kidnap their baby a very misguided attempt to "redeem" her, barring baby. Combine this with the fact Fourth Sister massacred a village in the prior episodes without remoures. (Its remorse and fanatically served an evil empire (albiet out of fear), even going as far as to let herself be stabbed and Bariss comes across a borderline *IdiotHero who takes unnecessary risks in a misguided effort to redeem someone who seems irredeemable. (It's probably worth noting that Bariss knows the other nature of this specific cave and that Fourth Sister would be trapped while the family escapes, but its it still comes across a messed up to not directly stop her on principle.)) Granted, this did seem to work at the end, but only time will tell. ]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* UnexpectedCharacter: Amongst the Inquisitors, few would have expected the Fourth Sister would have such a large role in the show, after her brief appearances in ''Series/ObiWanKenobi''.

to:

* UnexpectedCharacter: Amongst the Inquisitors, few would have expected the Fourth Sister would have such a large role in the show, after her brief appearances in ''Series/ObiWanKenobi''.''Series/ObiWanKenobi''.
* UnintentionallyUnsympathetic: Despite her above-noted attempt at *CharecterRerailment and coming reforming, Barriss' redemption felt off to some. Her previous bombing of the Jedi temple aside, she did not really bring up her terrorist actions or show explicit remorse nor reflection on them. Additionally, her attempts to convince the young Jedi she and the Fourth Sister found come across as manipulation at best, as her attempt to "help" the Jedi would, at most have gotten the Jedi tortured into being an Inqusitor (although Bariss quickly leaves them) Plus, in her third episode, after stalling the Fourth Sister for a bit, Bariss stands aside and lets her continued to pursue the family with the force-sensitive baby she's after while they are in view, despite Fourth Sister implicitly trying to kill them and kidnap their baby a very misguided attempt to "redeem" her, barring the fact Fourth Sister massacred a village in the prior episodes without remoures. (Its probably worth noting that Bariss knows other nature of this specific cave and that Fourth Sister would be trapped while the family escapes, but its still comes across a messed up to not directly stop her on principle.)

Changed: 100

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Barriss attempts to kindly question a child after Lyn tries to intimidate the whole village. She even takes off her helmet when she realizes it scares the child. The child runs to her for protection after Lyn kills the village.

to:

** Barriss attempts to kindly question a child after Lyn tries to intimidate the whole village. She even takes off her helmet when she realizes it scares the child. The child runs to her for protection after Lyn kills the village.village, Barriss even let the child take cover behind her when she thinks Lyn was going to strike the child.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ContinuityLockout: Just as with ''Tales of the Jedi'', this show is not meant to be a stand alone show and will require a bit of prior viewing to full understand. In particular, ''WesternAnimation/StarWarsTheCloneWars'', possibly ''WesternAnimation/StarWarsRebels'', ''Series/TheMandalorian'', and ''Series/{{Ahsoka}}'' are all required viewing to understand both Morgan and Barriss's story arcs.

to:

* ContinuityLockout: Just as with ''Tales of the Jedi'', this show is not meant to be a stand alone show and will require a bit of prior viewing to full fully understand. In particular, ''WesternAnimation/StarWarsTheCloneWars'', possibly ''WesternAnimation/StarWarsRebels'', ''Series/TheMandalorian'', and ''Series/{{Ahsoka}}'' are all required viewing to understand both Morgan and Barriss's story arcs.

Top