Markup View

Author: justanotherrandomlurker

Dec 3rd 2013 at 7:48:06 PM

Again, this ''could'' work, ''but'', it would ''have'' to be a YMMV, certainly because of differences of opinions. Personally, almost all of the examples I listed above that could be used towards this YKTTW are based entire on the overall opinion within the fandoms, and such as the case of M*A*S*H, as noted, the episode, "Major Fred C. Dobbs" is hated by the actual cast and crew, and a lot of fans do also consider it a poor episode; likewise, with Seinfeld, it's been mentioned in many different interviews with different cast members that many fans hated "The Finale". So, it would certainly help only if examples that are submitted are episodes that a majority of the fandom agree are pretty poor.

On the other hand, yes, I can see the concern some people are expressing about this turning into a complaining trope, or fueling edit wars... but ya know what? A ''lot'' of YMMVs already garner a lot of that kind of stuff. Getting back to Seinfeld as an example, the SeasonalRot on that show's YMMV page is edited ''all the time''.

And yes, I agree it would be nice if the OP would take care of this YKTTW and added some of these examples to the description.