TV Tropes Org
site search

A review is one person's opinion. TV Tropes doesn't have an opinion. The person who signed the review does.

sort by: type:
correct subject add a review about reviews
Absolute tripe
This show runs on stupidity (both in-universe and out of it) and angst from the Trauma Conga Line that character after unlikeable character goes through. (There's plenty of Deus Angst Machina and Wangst too, mind you.) The tropes run the gamut from Idiot Ball to Genre Blindness to Distress Ball to Forgot About His Powers to— well, you get the idea. We're talking about a show where:

  • a guy with super-hearing and X-ray vision is brought up short by an invisible villain
  • an evil genius uses a relative's name as a password
  • every other plot in the first half of the series is resolved by Laser Guided Amnesia; and
  • people walking toward someone or sitting at a table facing him in broad daylight don't notice him 'superspeed' off

Infrequent use could be forgiven, but when every plot hinges on everyone being a moron...

The effects were laughable at the start. Art Evolution brought them up to 'mediocre' by the end, for the most part; the season 10 Big Bad is the most hilarious example of what happens when your ambition outstrips your effects budget. It's also amusing how far the show goes in the last few seasons to avoid calling in the actors for less frequently seen characters by using 'clever' camera angles & lighting.

The only regular characters that I liked were Chloe, Lois, Oliver and Davis (before his character arc kicked into high gear). Lana/Clark is possibly the most annoying and tedious relationship I have ever seen. In contrast, I rather liked the way Lois/Clark was handled, at least until Lois's identity started being subsumed by Clark's. On the bright side, many of the most irritating characters leave over the years.

The forced melodrama and Soap Opera-style delivery grate on my nerves.

Just to be clear, Smallville did have its moments. It was at its best when heroes other than Clark got some screen time (see: Justice & Absolute Justice), which unfortunately didnít happen often, with the exception of Oliver. Add in the abysmal series finale, though, and you have 10 years of lousy writing, annoying characters, poor special effects and that awful theme song with zero payoff. Definitely one to avoid.

Incidentally, I think my brain will commit hari kari if I hear one more person say 'since X has been Y' (just one of the myriad abuses of the English language in this fine series).
  # comments: 7
flag for mods
Pilot Review
Nerdy as I am, I have never been much into comic books. Comic book movies were more my thing - and later, a certain comic book TV show. But I always used to ignore Superman entirely. For one thing, I typically associated it with the sort of camp that dominated the Batman franchise until Tim Burton came along, resurged after he left the project, and vanished again when Christopher Nolan took over. For another, I considered Superman a little too vanilla. And there was the little problem of Superman being an alien, making him extremely difficult to relate to.

Then, when I heard Nolan was working with Zack Snyder on a new Superman project, and I started finding a number of interesting Smallville references on this very wiki, I gave in and decided to check out the show for the first time. This morning, I watched the pilot, and enjoyed it much more than I had thought I would five or more years ago.

It's riddled with possibly the most extreme case of Dawson Casting I've ever seen, but the young actors were more than capable of otherwise being convincing as 14-to-15-year-old high schoolers. The story - a young man, his body frozen in time for twelve years and given a deadly electrokinetic ability - wouldn't have been out of place on an early Buffy. Clark's wish to be on the football team (and being denied by his father) made me think of what The Incredibles would have been like if Dash had been a teenager. The effects, while a bit dated, were nevertheless pretty damn good even compared to certain more recent shows. The writing is also really good, too - after all, the creators later wrote the movie I Am Number Four, one of my all-time faves.

But what I really liked was the scene in which Clark was stripped to his boxers and trussed up as the scarecrow. So many metaphors there. The Christ reference, obviously. The "S" on his chest, referencing not only Smallville High, but also the iconic Superman logo. And, of course, the whole idea of the scene being a symbol of the creators' intention to take the Superman mythos to its basics.

And thus beginneth my journey into the world of Smallville. Now cue the Archive Panic!
  # comments: 0
flag for mods
My Impressions So Far- Smallville Seasons 1-3: Haha very funny Smallville, now where's the real show?
Season 1-3 are slow moving. This much is certain. They are intent on keeping Status Quo Is God oh so much as well as having the usual Monster Of The Week. The actual real story, however, is interesting. The story takes place in small doses behind the idiotic Monster Of The Week plots.

One thing I have noticed is that, for the most part, every decision Clark makes makes things worse. He makes a huge mistake in not telling Lana, Chloe, and Lex his "secret." He's had many chances to tell every one of them, but in these three seasons he's so intent on keeping his super powers a secret from them that he loses sight of his relationships with them, making his friendships slip. Chloe searches for truth, but is lied to by Clark every day. Lana wants to love him, but is blocked by Clark's secrecy. Clark's friendship with Lex is perhaps the only thing keeping him from going down that inevitable descent into evil, yet Clark insists on keeping his secret.

Keeping it from Lex is especially damning because Lex is, or was, constantly investigating Clark. Lex also wants to get at the truth, and if Clark had just come forward in season 1, the inevitable dark side damage would not be done. One has to feel sympathetic with Lex for everything he goes through in season 3: marooned on an island, going through a messy divorce, being thrown into an insane asylum, and having shock therapy forced onto him. And than, to top it all off, Clark finds out that Lex has a room devoted to him and, again with his stupid decisions, ends their friendship by jumping to conclusions and not letting Lex explain. He also, jumps to the conclusion that Lex is his enemy, saying Lex had been lying to him from day one, but neglecting to mention he had been lying from day one too.

I'm waiting for this show to stop with Clark being stupid. Clark is fucking Superman, he shouldn't make such stupid decisions. I'm waiting for this show to move on from it's Monster Of The Week plots and actually become the awesome and interesting show I know it can be. This show needs to get off the farm and into the city before it can really achieve its potential.

Also, I find the Dedication to Status Quo Is God incredibly annoying. How, quite conveniently, whenever someone could come close to figuring out Clark's "secret," they pass out or kryptonite is around making him look normal.
  # comments: 0
flag for mods
A different twist to the Mythos
Although I always liked the Superman Mythos, I was never really familiar with it. Sure, I know the obvious stuff, and the not-so-obvious a little, but I considered myself a Superman Neophyte when I started watching Smallville. And I think that played a major part in me liking the series. It gives a different spin to all the mythology behind "World's Greatest Superhero" - Clark didn't decided someday that he would wear tights and save old ladies, but he had a long time to realize that this was his destiny, and that this was the destiny he wanted to follow. It may piss off hardcore fans that he fought all of his rogues' gallery before becoming Superman, but in my mileage, that makes the whole DC universe more diverse, and fun. All the other versions of the story are still there, waiting to be read and seen, and I like them, but I like Smallville more. I kinda grew up with Clark, and identified with him, and seeing him becoming the Man of Tomorrow makes my life feel much more epic. I admit that Smallville has the dumbest moments in Superman history (Lana Lang the Purity God Mode Sue being the biggest offender of all - I almost gave up on the series because of her), but, as a whole, I think is a great addition to the the whole mythology of Superman - like a different version of your old favorite bed time story.
  # comments: 0
flag for mods
A few more "whines"
I dropped out of Smallville around the time they introduced Tess Mercer. The show became all Fanwank, all the time — basically a runway shoot for obscure comic characters who don't merit a live-action production on their own. The problem lies in the shift from "Clark Kent before he was Superman" to "Young Superman" — contrary to what fans tell you, those are not the same. I didn't sign on to watch the JLA as tweens.

That's not to say its all bad. The acting stayed consistently good, as did the budget. Michael Rosenbaum is the best portrayal of Lex to date, Clark faces some genuine challenges to his moral compass. The vision of sleek modern day Metropolis was also exciting and gave hope the Superman franchise could modernize itself for a young audience, with its kitschy 70s aspects toned down. Emil is the most likable addition to the cast, though technically he's yet another walking shout-out — he's the preview of nerdy Clark Kent, which only serves to illustrate how our designated Clark Kent is a black hole of banality. Also, Emil is the one character whose dialogue isn't entirely composed of puns ("A WONDERful WOMAN who's going to throw you for a LOOP."). Too bad he doesn't show up until Season Eight. Get comfortable.

In the fourth year, the popular Lex segments were getting really dark, and ratings slumped a bit. CW ordered a writer overall, and eventually they realized that the more shout outs they made to the DCU, the less people care about the plot. Clark has now battled — and killed (consistency is nice!) — every villain in his rogues gallery. Even Silver Banshee.

Note also how the entire supporting cast is romantically tied to two or more characters at all times. It's a shipper's paradise over here. Practically none of these relationships last beyond a season, making it impossible to feel invested, especially since the Cartwright Curse is always in effect.

There really isn't much to this show. It's rote and lifeless, and seemingly keeps afloat on the goodwill of poor, oft-abused DC fans who are already used to having crap like Countdown force-fed to them. Don't support the abuse.
  # comments: 3
flag for mods
back to article
TV Tropes by TV Tropes Foundation, LLC is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.
Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available from thestaff@tvtropes.org.
Privacy Policy