Broke new ground for machinima, but by itself isn't much.
Red Vs Blue and I go a bit back. The earliest mention I heard of it was a peer quoting
this line
back when I was in the 4th grade. And one can't go through a single
Halo forum without hearing a shoutout to it.
RvB's place is cemented in our culture. All I've seen is Season 1, some bits of "Recollection", the PSAs, and Season 9. But while I
really enjoy Rooster Teeth's
other work, I'm not
that impressed by
RvB.
Firstly, I rarely care about the plot. I understand the storyline well enough, but it tends to bore me. Half of this is because, with the exception of Caboose, I pretty much care nothing about Blue Team, who the story tends to center around. I find the comedic interactions between Red Team funny, and always look forward to their segments, but everyone else, Church, Tucker, Tex, are so unlikeable. None of them get my sympathy because because of how
callous they can often be. Sarge is a funny callous. Church is an annoying callous. I'd prefer Red Team getting the greater focus.
2nd, the new CG fight scenes don't impress me. While our page for
Haloid is overflowing with Gushing, I simply got bored watching it, despite the fusion of my two favorite franchises.
Monty Oum loves reveling in his
Matrix-esque fight scenes,
and reveling in cool can be nice. But since his fights pretty display nothing but one character eternally winning unless he/she picks up an
Idiot Ball, there's no effort in their movements, no strategy, no suspense, and no odds. It's just fighting for fighting's sake, fighting I simply can't take seriously.
Honestly, I find their PSAs funnier, since they're plotless, tend be "comedic interaction" orientated, feature Red Team more, and have the characters offer their own spin on some current issue I'm interested in, and care more about than their plot. I don't have any motive to watch the 7 seasons I've missed, because of
Archive Panic and because I know hearing
ClusterFBombs every episode is going to get on my nerves after a while. When
RvB's focus is just letting the characters do their funny thing, it can be great. But when it tries to shoehorn them into their plot, I lose interest.