TV Tropes Org
site search

A review is one person's opinion. TV Tropes doesn't have an opinion. The person who signed the review does.

sort by: type:
correct subject add a review about reviews
One of the most undeservedly hated series there are
Alright, so I'll get the obvious out of the way first: yes, this is very similar to Harry Potter. I consider it sort of a homage, for the simple reason that Infernal Devices isn't similar to Harry Potter (or anything else) at all, but I'm not the biggest Harry Potter fan - if you're a fan of it, you're likely to feel like this series is treading old ground. But I don't. There are definitely some elements similar to Harry Potter, but again, I think it's an intentional homage. And it feels like an injustice to dwell on that, because this is a shockingly enjoyable series that, while it won't appeal to everyone, most definitely appeals to me.

The negatives:
  • The prose can sometimes give unnecessary details.
  • Clary is a Mary Sue, and with the exception of City of Ashes, she feels constantly undeveloped in every book.
  • The similes got a little annoying after a while.
  • Again, the Harry Potter parallels can get a little annoying. (The Twilight ones, by the way, are probably coincidental - by the time Twilight came out, Clare would've been almost finished writing this or beginning to query it.)
  • City of Glass had an unrealistically happy ending.

The positives:
  • Other than Clary, all the characters are well-developed and interesting. In particular, Jace is a great exploration of someone with abusive parents, and far less of a jerk than everyone detests him for.
  • The writing, other than the similes, was phenomenal.
  • The plots were well planned out and normally well-paced.
  • The world, while it had the occasional contradiction (as the previous reviewer pointed out), was cohesive, interestingly formed, and logical.
  • The dialogue is fucking hilarious.
  • Clare handles diversity really well, her homosexual characters in particular.
  • Magnus is awesome.

Basically, the series is definitely flawed, and it's not for everyone, but I really enjoyed it. And maybe you will, too, if you're the type of person that would enjoy it.
  # comments: 1
flag for mods
It tries, but... (Books 1-3)
The Mortal Instruments by Cassandra Clare is a series that focuses on a group of humans called Shadowhunters, defenders of humanity from demons thanks to the angel blood they have. Such is the premise of the series, and for the most part, it works. The setting gives way to fantastic storytelling and a great plot. However, there are two problems that reveal Clare's past as a Harry Potter Fanfic writer and works against the series.

The first is that the characters, who are mostly expies of characters from the Draco Trilogy, are supposed to be saviors of the human race, but don't seem to care about them in any way. Simon, a normal human, is mostly ignored by everyone (including his Shadowhunter best friend and female Lead) until he becomes a vampire, and there's tons of Fantastic Racism towards both humans and Downworlders (magical creatures). The narration never even bothers to call them out, except when it's convenient to create drama between Clary and Love Interest Jace, or to hypocritically call out the villain, Valentine.

The second problem is the world-building that, while interesting, makes no sense. Shadowhunters are supposed to live among us. They are not Harry Potter characters, and as such have to interact with Muggles (or "Mundanes") and their technology (they sometimes take the subway to move around), yet they have no idea of things like the Internet or TV shows, just because Clare obviously liked introducing the characters to those concepts and seeing them react humorously, even if, as I said, it makes no sense storywise. As a side-note, I also fail to see why the (in-story) world finds Jace attractive beyond shallow appearance, since the narration constantly puts him in a negative light, being quite the Jerkass to everyone but Clary (including, I should note, his adopted siblings).

Bottom line, I think the series has some very interesting concepts, and the story and humor is good, but the two problems mentioned above prevent it from actually being great books. They can be entertaining, however, and some twists and turns were very well thought out. I wouldn't recommend it, but see nothing particularly bad about the story or style (except for some descriptions where the prose turns very purple).

3.1/5
  # comments: 0
flag for mods
back to article
TV Tropes by TV Tropes Foundation, LLC is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.
Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available from thestaff@tvtropes.org.
Privacy Policy