TV Tropes Org
site search

A review is one person's opinion. TV Tropes doesn't have an opinion. The person who signed the review does.

sort by: type:
correct subject add a review about reviews
A great concept spoiled by a shoehorned moral
I would have liked Contact more if it had just decided to let its premise of realistic first contact play out by itself. And for the first half of the film it did. But gradually the story's fascinating exploration of the science became overshadowed by its unnecessary moral about "faith" and feelings, misunderstanding both and then claiming false reconciliation.

Contact's great points are the development of the discovery of an extraterrestrial message, naturally separated by their distance and language, but using other ways to respond to humanity, such as encoded television broadcasts, or mathematical plans of a portal device. The fact that it's happening in such a way makes it feel more real, knowing it's being done as best as we predict it'd happen. A film like this would not leave us with a "all's back to normal now ending", I thought.

Then the nagging flaws took over. The film over relies on caricatures; attractive good guys with all the right answers, ugly guys who are obstructive, smug bureaucrats. Matthew McConaughey's character I hated the most, at first expecting him to be a bad guy thanks to his sudden romancing of Dr. Calloway, then getting further annoyed when the film upheld him as a paragon of faith for his incredibly vague religion. As for Drumlin and Kitz, they could have been reasonable balanced characters but were forced to embrace their role as villains.

And the faith-science conflict, which the film misunderstands and mistakes as its own purpose. Faith isn't "blind" wandering based on just what you wish will happen, it's believing something you did not see was true BASED ON THE EVIDENCE. We have faith we were born on a certain day, and we don't doubt it since we trust that our parents are truthful. But a need for "blind faith" is forced into the film's latter half. Why make the aliens contact us then leave humanity alone? Why not run the machine again? Why doubt it happened when the capacity to fake a signal would take far more than ever deceivable (you would need HUNDREDS of satellites!) Why would the religious world freak out? The Catholic Church has announced it has no problem with extraterrestrial life, & there was a time when saints like Augustine said there could not be people living on other continents. They Wasted A Perfectly Good Plot.
  # comments: 6
flag for mods
This Film Makes No Sense!
To put this up summly, I will state what I think about mostly the movie's ending ala this quote found on Family Guy:

"So they spent a trillion dollars building this mile high space machine and Jake Busey blows it up. So, now they're all like: "Oh, no. We can't use the space machine, but then this other guy's like: "Hey, it just so happens, I built another identical trillion dollar space machine at my own expense, on the other side of the world." And we're supposed to believe no one noticed that? Well, I stood up in the theatre and I said: "No! You can't go into space because the machine already got blown up by Jake Cock-a-Doody Busey!""

So in other words, I really hated this movie. I mean this movie was the worst piece of garbage I ever wrote. And well, I felt like they ruined it and so I left afterwards. Take my advice people, you would have wasted moments of your life watching this.
  # comments: 0
this review has been flagged
back to article
TV Tropes by TV Tropes Foundation, LLC is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.
Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available from thestaff@tvtropes.org.
Privacy Policy