Back to Reviews

Reviews Comments: Great game overall, but disappointing in a few aspects. The Legend Of Zelda Phantom Hourglass game review by Ntroper

My first thoughts about Phantom Hourglass, as someone who was always in touch with the Zelda series, is that the gameplay is quite entertaining, and it has a good story, altough pretty subpar by Zelda standards, mostly if compared to the game it is a sequel to. It's pretty simple: After Link and Zelda, now Tetra, defeat Ganon once again in the previous game, which is even retold in the game intro, which is good if you aren't familiar with Wind Waker, the crew is shown in the midst of sailing, and they come across the Ghost Ship. Immediately after Tetra boards the ship, she screams for help. It ends up with Link falling into the ocean and washing up on an island where he meets the Exposition Fairy Ciela, who coincidentally, has Navi's voice clips. Link then embarks on a quest to save Tetra with the aid of local Ensemble Darkhorse and Jerk With A Heart Of Gold, Linebeck, after obtaining the Phantom Hourglass from an old man named Oshus.

As its predecessor, sailing is abundant, and everything is controlled by the DS' touch screen. The items, the sword, walking, everything. It also includes a few puzzles which involve drawing symbols using the touch screen. You can also customize your ship. It's a very entertaining game with many awesome bosses and other attracting features. Highly reccomended. It is, however, disappointing in a few aspects, which are:
  • The dungeon music. The music for all the dungeons is the same track, which is quite disappointing considering the series' history with awesome soundtracks. The game itself has excellent music, but the dungeon theme gets repetitive too quickly.
  • A pretty disappointing villain: Bellum doesn't quite have the uniqueness that the Zelda antagonists are known for.
  • The minigames: Some are plain evil, specially for those aiming for 100% Completion.
  • Temple of the Ocean King: Going through the same level, the same floors over and over again gets tedious quickly.

Overall, Phantom Hourglass, while not quite as challenging as most Zelda games (Except for the archery minigame), it's still a pretty fun game which maintains the charm of the series, with a rather nice story, and some good Character Development along the road for Linebeck, if only with a rather disappointing villain by Zelda standards.


  • MyFinalEdits
  • 30th Aug 13
Agreed. It's not a bad game, but it has some issues that are too difficult to ignore, let alone tolerate. One thing that really killed it for me was the lack of new items. Very jarring after playing games where you get amazing tools like the Spinner, the Sand Wand or the Beetle.
  • donkeykong75m
  • 1st Sep 14
I second this, phantom hourglass really was good, but for me it didn't feel very Zeldaish. The parts were there but they didnt mesh like they should. The music wasn't there for me and yeah the items dungeons and sailing Weren't that memorable. I'm happy Spirit tracks took what worked in this game and improved it making that one more enjoyable.

In order to post comments, you need to

Get Known