TV Tropes Org
site search
Abuse Cycle back to reviews
Comments
Korra's closer to The Chick than the Action Girl from canon
Gramatically, it actually is fairly well written. I'll give it that. The only problem is that, out of every character featured, only one or two are still pretty much in-character. It almost seems like Korra has been chickified. She's much wussier than normal, but I guess that, if you try, it can be Hand Waved as her just being nervous about having what might be her first long-term boyfriend. I absolutely hate seeing someone who is so strong and powerful in-series ruined. While Abuse Cycle might not be like How I Became Yours in quality, it definitely will be come as well known for the same reason: destroying good characters by making them total monsters.
I don't think that Korra's OOC characterization can be reasonably handwaved; the author's views on Korra are clearly misguided at best. Said author has gone on record claiming that canon Korra is the sort of person who can only find the strength to defend herself when she's fighting for other people, which is heavily contradicted by both actual canon and Word of Bryke. Once Korra's tendency towards overzealous defense of her own ego is taken from her, what's left can barely even be called Korra anymore.

It's easy to see why the author would do this of course, given that Korra's canon character is an exceptionally bad fit for victimization through stock Domestic Abuse tropes. Not only is she likely to come out as victor in any pure physical confrontation, but her personal hangups in regards to power and control make her highly inclined to escalate attacks against her self-worth into physical violence before they can impact her fighting ability severely enough to lose that advantage. A sadistic creator of sufficient talent might be able to work around that, but it would be both difficult to pull off and highly uncomfortable to write, so it's just easier to weaken Korra. (Of course, flipping the roles would also be easier without destroying canon quite so badly; it's considerably less of a stretch to expand Korra's need for power and control to pathological levels than it is to have her fail to resist attempts at control by someone else)

If the extent of the author's crimes against canon were the creation of a fanfic that's essentially original fiction with character names pasted on, that would be one thing. But the author's insistence that the Abuse Cycle's characterization is based in canon is indefensible.
comment #15743 Ikkin 10th Aug 12
In order to post comments, you need to Get Known
TV Tropes by TV Tropes Foundation, LLC is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.
Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available from thestaff@tvtropes.org.
Privacy Policy