TV Tropes Org
site search
My Little Pony Friendship Is Magic S 2 E 18 A Friend In Deed back to reviews
Comments
Very nice, except for one thing.
We've had at least one Pinkie episode already this season, but "A Friend In Deed" gives us some new things all the same. We get a little more info as to how other ungulates in Equestria function (the way a given universe works never fails to interest me), Pinkie Pie gets more character development, with some nods to the less cheerful aspects of her personality, and most important for me, every issue I have with her as a viewer is brought up and examined, and it's clearly shown that, in spite of her faults, at the end of the day she is a very good friend to have.

The only problem I have is with the ending. For one, it seems like a cop-out, and an extremely obvious one in retrospect; Matilda is the first donkey ever seen on the show, and female, so it only stands to reason she'd be Cranky's love interest, and it feels like she was created for that sole purpose. If she had been introduced in an earlier episode, the whole thing might have worked, but here it just seems contrived. A much bigger complaint is how much more emotionally powerful and resonating the episode could have been, if, say, the special friend had been Cranky's deceased wife. The concept of death does exist in Equestria, as shown in a blink-and-you'll-miss-it moment in the previous episode, and "A Friend In Deed" I think missed an opportunity to treat the matter in a more serious light. Cranky could have confided in Pinkie Pie, as she definitely has an understanding and sympathetic side, and we could have ended with, if not a full-blown grin from him, at least a small, warm smile at the comfort of having Pinkie always be around to brighten his day.

All that said, even if the ending didn't completely satisfy me, the episode as a whole did, and I think that's what counts.
Actually, we see a stubborn mule in the first season, but only for a few seconds.
comment #12866 Shota 18th Feb 12
I had the same feelings about the ending. The rest of the episode was humorous and entertaining, so it still gets a thumbs up in my book. Oddly enough, I had the opposite experience with the previous Pinkie Pie episode. In that episode, I wasn't particularly entertained throughout most of it (possibly because of my dislike of children), but found the ending to be particularly emotional and heartwarming. Either way, it's always good to know someone shares my opinion.
comment #12868 PAK215 18th Feb 12
And this is why i hate donkeys. Pinkie should have ran away from him when she first saw him after her song since she should know that donkeys are always up to no good.
comment #23832 animefanboy67 14th Apr 14
In order to post comments, you need to Get Known
TV Tropes by TV Tropes Foundation, LLC is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.
Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available from thestaff@tvtropes.org.
Privacy Policy