Back to Reviews

Reviews Comments: Really not that good... A Mothers Love fanfic review by Kereea

The premise—Kushina Uzumaki survives and is going to help her son—is wonderful. The execution is not.

On the author's side is the fact that Kushia had only been named and pictured about once by the time this was wirrten—not much was known about her personailty so that's not as up for debate as the rest pf the fic.I actually reallyy liked her niname "The Red Death" better than Kushina's canon nickname...but that's about it.

Naruto hits God Mode Sue at an alarmingly fast rate, the bashing makes less sense that usual (and I read this in a mood for the bashing of the people bashed in it), and no one is in character at all. Even remotely. Here's my biggest isues:

1—The Massive Protagonist Centered Morality. Everything Kushina does is right even whe it's horribly wrong, and the same goes for anyone she teaches/supports. You end up wanting her dead like in canon in very short order.

2—Cosplay. In the main story. At the chunin exams . I'm not kidding. The author even says exactly who they are. Naruto'd dressed like Dante from Devil May Cry and Hinata is dressed like the White Queen. Yes I mean Emma Frost from X Men and yes I mean in paintes and corset. And they sometimes dress like that at other times, if I remebr correctly.

3—Naruto uses a gun. In the chunin exam tournament. And when asked about the weapon, becuase it is clearly dangerous and could maybe be usueful to the Leaf Village, Naruto and Kushina blow the question off with "it's Whirlpool propety and we don't have to share it, kay?"

4—The Akasuki are taken out all at one in about 1-2 chapters, mostly as an afterthought since they weren't the "real villains" of the story if you read it porperly. The villains are anyone who doesn't do what Kushina wants.

This fanfic made me sick and made me hug the people I was reading in in hopes of their getting bashed. They only acted despicable in almsot cartoon-villain manner and only when needed. It was such a blatant case of Canon Defilement that I felt this heated reveiw had to be written to warn others off it.


  • arisboch
  • 17th Jun 12
2) There wasn't a word of it. Ever. In the whole story he didn't mention them. You mixed somethin up 3) The only gun's were a flare gun and guns on ship, Naruto never used ones... At least not in this fan fic. 4) Yes, e.g. trying to stage a coup d'etat and killing the Hokage, her son... Yes, Sasuke was a lil bit too cliche, letting him manipulating by his brother so easy... Just like in canon, where he became an emo terrorist because of his brother...
  • kay4today
  • 18th Jun 12

Like in the other review, you make things seem more sympathetic when they weren't like this in the story. And you take things out of context for your "arguments".

In order to post comments, you need to

Get Known