Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann back to reviews
Comments
Mecha Anime's Birth of a Nation
For those who don't know, Birth Of A Nation was the first film to explore the power of film. It employed innovative and revolutionary new camera and story telling techniques that would forever change cinema as we know it.

It was also the most racist movie ever made in the history of North American film.

This brings us to Gurren Lagann as it is know in the west. It's a great series, and likely to be remembered as such for decades to come. It way of manging to tell an epic tail in a very short amount of time is unparallelled. As is it's ability to balance both bitter realities of war and genocide with the comedic goofiness of bugs bunny cartoon.

All that however does not excuse the glaring chauvinism throughout the series. It's marred by blatant patriarchal sexism and homophobic caricatures and threats.

The series emphasizes "manly strength" and is filled with phallic imagery. Per se, those things aren't necessarily bad, but the series keeps driving through the importance of manliness, and constantly exemplifies the apex of that being bravado and protecting women. Trust me when I say I'm not inferring too much, they drive home this point at least once an episode. If all that weren't bad enough, the women of this show blindly accept and embrace men's chauvinistic attitudes. The men of the show are constantly swearing to protect "their" women, and the women never assert that they can protect themselves. Not that they can mind you, as after the first few episodes any woman resembling an action girl ends up as serving no greater role than as a damsel in distress.

I could go on, but I've limited word count, so to homophobia. The show has one gay character, and he's effeminate sexual predator. He'll hit on anything with a penis, including children. In addition to this whenever he makes a sight pass at male they react with both fear and violence. In the episode he first appears in, Kamina threatens to kill him for it; twice. Bad enough as that is, it gets worse as Kamina is cast as the embodiment of manliness, effectively teaching young males everywhere that homosexual men are a threat to masculinity itself, and should be treated as such.

It is a shame, like BOAN, it's brilliance is defiled by the writer's own social ignorance and bigotry, causing this potentially revolutionary series becomes nothing more than regressive.
Frankly, I'm dissapointed that someone who clearly didn't pay enough attention decided to review the show. The main female characters are all strong in their own right, the men just have giant robots. At no point do any of the men infer women to be 'theirs' and instead simply protect those they care about, which happens to include the women. Also at no point do the women ever blindly accept and embrace the so-called "chauvinistic" attitudes. They merely get used to the attitudes that anyone smart would call "Impulsive, but caring" And the gay character outright states in his first episode he acts like that to bug people, not because he's actually like that. He is very effeminate, but he exagerates it for fun. The writers of this show are neither ignorant nor bigots, and this show is most certainly revolutionary. The only ignorance I see is this sad excuse for a review.
38.116.200.46 16th Sep 09
This is a Stealth Parody, duh.
Someguy 16th Sep 09
Honestly, I couldn't get over the fact that the mecha were all faces with arms and legs. That creeped the fuck out of me.
WilliamWideWeb 19th Sep 09
Bad enough as that is, it gets worse as Kamina is cast as the embodiment of manliness, effectively teaching young males everywhere that homosexual men are a threat to masculinity itself, and should be treated as such?

Leeron's advances were nothing more than pure comic relife, Kamina's actions were ment to tickle the funny bone.
RoadBuster 8th Oct 09
>>the women never assert that they can protect themselves.

Come on. Yoko. Her rifle.

{Flamebait deleted}

82.179.218.10 17th Oct 09 (edited by: Madrugada)
It was not flamebait, but my view of the situation, but whatever =)

But still, Yoko and her rifle. Nia and her backhand to Guame. Yoko and Dayakkaizer. Women can protect themselves quite okay.
82.179.218.11 18th Oct 09
I really don't see what you're talking about. You sell Leeron really short; he is hands down the smartest character and his ingenuity often saves the loose cannon protagonists from early and violent deaths. Also, openly gay characters are hard to come by in anime in any situation where they are not totally played for laughs. Leeron's effeminate behavior is not his defining characteristic though it certainly looks that way at first glance. Furthermore, phallic imagery is often up to interpretation (albeit there's more drill jokes than you can shake a stick at) and it shouldn't be said that the drills are an exertion of masculine power (more like the rule of cool). The chauvinistic attitudes you perceive are being confused more for courage and bravery; if you feel that those are associated with masculinity more than femininity then that's your point of view. to compare Gurren Lagann to the Birth of a Nation makes me truly question how much you actually understood past chauvinism and penis-drills
DOTMW 23rd Oct 09
This review is just sad. Do you honestly think this series takes itself seriously? Just about everything in this series is played for laughs. I mean, come on, look at Leeron, and tell me that he's a serious attempt to put homosexuals in a bad light.
84.49.205.52 27th Oct 09
Actually, DOTMW, considering that the director of the series created another series with a character that had a drill codpiece, the one thing in this review that is spot-on is the "drills as phallic symbols" thing.
WilliamWideWeb 27th Oct 09
There is definitely chauvinism in TTGL. In particular, Yoko piloting Gurren Lagann only once, and never attempting to do so again; Stay In The Kitchen is such an obvious implication that it's practically an aesop.

Even still, this review is just exaggerated over-analysis. Considering the state of gender equality in Japan, it's almost progressive.
LeadPal 29th Oct 09 (edited by: LeadPal)
Normally I don't quote The Dark Knight, but why so serious, fellas?
Charlatan 29th Oct 09
"There is definitely chauvinism in TTGL. In particular, Yoko piloting Gurren Lagann only once, and never attempting to do so again; Stay In The Kitchen is such an obvious implication that it's practically an aesop."

This concerning the only person in the entire series to destroy a Ganmen without actually being in one?
Wicked223 11th Nov 09
I never really saw any chauvinism or homophobia with the female characters and Leeron. All of the female characters are strong, just in different ways from the male characters. Usually, it's in a Yamato Nadeshiko protect-don't-confront sort of way, but it still stands. Hell, Nia is arguably the biggest Determinator on the show if you really think about it. Yoko combines sexual confidence with sheer Action Girl strength and, later, the kind and caring hand of a teacher. Kinon had the strength to follow the one she loves through thick and thin, even if what he was doing was wrong. Kiyal became a kind and supporting auntie to her niece, but that doesn't mean she isn't still strong. (actually, when did she ever show that much strength? Episode 4 notwithstanding) Kiyoh, much like Simon, decided to make way for the next generation. Retiring =/= lack of strength. Leeron, as noted before, plays up his Camp Gay for laughs. Perhaps Kamina himself is homophobic for whatever reason? I can't imagine "It's okay to be gay!" was seen as a very important lesson in Jeeha Villiage, what with the constant threat of dying being kind of more... there.

I always imagined all of the different characters representing different kinds of strength. If you think the women are weak, examine the different kinds of strength there really are.
Dinru 12th Nov 09
  • headscratch*
75.170.93.201 12th Nov 09
back to reviews
Add a comment