Wall E back to reviews
Comments
My Infamous Opinions.
Big businesses and technology are destroying our lives and cutting us off from all human contact. Fair enough, but then why is a company so ruthlessly monomaniacal as Disney telling us this with the medium of a computer-generated movie that is entirely reliant on spectacle and stars a personality-free Number Five clone? Along the way, we get cheap shots at how technology is making us all fat, which would normally just be whiny and annoying, except that the film can't even commit to that; we're still required to sympathize with this God-damned CG robot.

This movie probably isn't aiming for comedy - which is good, because the only times I laughed were when I was reminded of a different, funnier movie I'd rather be watching (Space Mutiny, for example) - but it can't exactly be touching either with protagonists this unsympathetic and devoid of any characterization. It's like being asked to care about the moral plight of a sofa. I expected more from Pixar than a fight to the death with a cheap HAL 9000 ripoff.
I get the bad "Mega Corp is evil and terrible and you're all pigs" moral is fucking stupid.

I don't get the unsympathetic, uncharacterized bits.
Dick Richardson 17th Sep 09
Considering the athieism sub-text of Toy Story, and the Socialist all but out right text of A Bugs Life (I've seen meetings of the NDP which is Canada's Socialist-lite party use A Bug's Life to help illustrate their platform) I'd say that Pixar is very good at getting not quite Disney style messages past the higher ups somehow.

I have no idea how you don't manage to sympathize with Wall-E and EVE at all. Hell they were more enjoyable and relatable than half of the human characters that Hollywood throws at us these days.

I will give you that the comedic moments were rather weak and the climax was disapointing though.
Darkblade 4th Oct 09
I couldn't sympathize with the robot characters because they were basically inexpressive and didn't really speak, beyond Pokemon-like recitation of their names. When EVE is introduced, she flies around blowing shit up, and we never really find out why (or if we do, it wasn't communicated very well, and I missed it). She just, occasionally, flips out and blows shit up, and because she never speaks, it doesn't feel like part of her character so much as it feels like something the creators just felt like having her do. If it were just going for madcap, absurdist comedy, that would be fine. Also, when you consider that the main "characters" are a pair of inanimate objects, they become even less worthy of being taken seriously. You may as well watch a windup toy for hours, and then cry when it stops moving.
TheManWithoutABody 7th Oct 09
67.55.100.196 8th Oct 09
Are you sure this opinion is infamous? I mean, I have no freshly-baked-rhubarb-pieing idea who you are, but maybe that's just me. I also know of multiple people who didn't like Wall-E.
Cambdoranononononono 31st Oct 09
I know there are reasons to not like Wall-E. You've hit none of them.
Roihu 1st Nov 09
back to reviews
Add a comment