: I can't recommend it. While the premise is more or less solid, it drives Soun right into Ron The Death Eater territory during The Reveal... Not so much in his motive, but the perception everyone had for the reveal. We're supposed to believe that, more or less, everyone's memories were of the canon storyline... And everybody turns on Soun like he's a Complete Monster, when the way he presents it is as a case of Be Careful What You Wish For which the wish-granterrefused to set right. Nobody has an ounce of pity for the man until the same Literal Genie enables the plot to move forward for no reason by choosing to "unlock" Ranma's old, female memories. The entire drama with Soun feels needlessly arbitrary and Narmy, especially given how much everyone overreacts compared the rest of the cast's behavior in canon.
lanky's review
: I can't recommend it. While the premise is more or less solid, it drives Soun right into Ron The Death Eater territory during The Reveal... Not so much in his motive, but the perception everyone had for the reveal. We're supposed to believe that, more or less, everyone's memories were of the canon storyline... And everybody turns on Soun like he's a Complete Monster, when the way he presents it is as a case of Be Careful What You Wish For which the wish-granter refused to set right. Nobody has an ounce of pity for the man until the same Literal Genie enables the plot to move forward for no reason by choosing to "unlock" Ranma's old, female memories. The entire drama with Soun feels needlessly arbitrary and Narmy, especially given how much everyone overreacts compared the rest of the cast's behavior in canon.