TV Tropes Org
site search
Young Justice back to reviews
Comments
Invisible Script in the Sky
Young Justice is one of the best looking western animated series I've seen in a while, with great animation and character designs. But... it also has problems. Lots of problems.

My biggest problem with YJ is the characters. Miss Martian ("Hello Megan!") and Artemis are the worst offenders as far as bad characters go. Miss Martian provides the girly pink ranger character, who'se insecure and desperate for everyone to get along. This manifests as being dependant on male characters, baking cookies, and trying to get Superboy in bed. Then there's Artemis, who tries to balance things out by being Tough and Badass! Unfortunately she's also rude, incompetent, and awkwardly shoehorned into the team. Batman forces her into the team, so Artemis is here whether the rest of the characters like her or not.

This comes to the second problem for characters. The other characters have their moments- even though Aqualad usually has the emotional range of a brick wall, he gets fleshed out a bit in Downtime. The problem is their interactions with one another, which seem unnatural sometimes. When Artemis joins, she is very terse and pretty rude. She then screws up and lets the villain escape. The team's response? Universal acceptance! The only exception is Kid Flash, who finds himself caught up in the most obvious love-hate relationship ever. If it weren't heavy handed enough to begin with, shortly after Artemis joins the team, Dr. Fate makes incredibly unsubtle comments about how he thinks Flash should bone her. It's painful to watch.

Stilted character interactions like this hurt everyone. While some of the characters come across well at points, as soon as they start following the great invisible script in the sky, they stop being characters and start being robots. Another example is one where they decide to make Aqualad the temporary leader, until Robin can man up and be the actual leader. Why? The scene in question fails to make a convincing argument as to why either of them should lead, Robin being portrayed as an immature kid, Aqualad as a brick wall. The reason is, of course, the invisible script in the sky.

Hopefully the series will get over this and actually start to develop some of these characters into interesting people, but it's got a long way to go. Still, if they at least drop "Hello Megan" they'll be off to a good start.
I wouldn't call Artemis 'incompetent', but this is a fairly honest review.

I hope things will improve in the next few episodes, however.
comment #7660 Fulcon 12th May 11
Not every character is supposed to be 100% perfect, polite, and intelligent, Kamen.
comment #9313 Jobbeybob 17th Aug 11
Doesn't mean that the writers can't put more effort into their characterization. They haven't been given much development and it's starting to feel like they're already being a little Fladerized... and it's only ten episodes into the series.
comment #9450 BecauseIWasBored 25th Aug 11 (edited by: BecauseIWasBored)
Despite being a "brickwall" of emotion (I would prefer the most level headed, remember this is not a soap opera) Aqualad shows the maturity that both Kidflash and Robin lack, and the brains and experience that Megan and Superboy lack. However everything else you said is true. Gargoyle was way more subtle and the show benefitted from it.
comment #9451 SparkySparkyBoomMan 25th Aug 11
Sparky Sparky Boom Man: I think the brick wall thing stems from the fact that Aqualad doesn't really have any emotional range. Look at how he reacts when he finds out that his girlfriend hooked up with his best friend while he was away. He doesn't get very upset about it, he just sort of goes 'Oh. Darn.' and leaves it at that.
comment #9568 BecauseIWasBored 31st Aug 11
Points:

1. Could have been longer

2. Disagree about Artemis

3. Agree about Miss Martian

4."Brick Wall" line was funny. Shouldn't have repeated it, though.
comment #12397 noitsnot 19th Jan 12
Aqualad spent a couple of years doing mandatory Atlantean military service. i don't get why everyone says he's written badly when it would be easy to look into his past and see why she doesn't let his emotions run wild. Garth and Tula were still his best friends, regardless. Well, I really like Aqualad.
comment #14106 Blacknumber 2nd May 12
In order to post comments, you need to Get Known
TV Tropes by TV Tropes Foundation, LLC is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.
Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available from thestaff@tvtropes.org.
Privacy Policy