Back to Reviews

Reviews Comments: Mixed bag Final Fantasy XV game review by frogwidget

Final Fantasy seems to have gotten into a pendulum state where the way to correct one problem is to go super-hard in the other direction. The main complaint of 13 was that it was too linear and focused on cutscenes which naturally means the answer, Final Fantasy XV, should have a sprawling open world with a significantly trimmed down story. Along with the Development Hell this game went through between tight budget, swapping directors, pushed back release dates, tie-in merchandise... well, I\'d like to think they did the best they could.

The good news is that the game IS gorgeous, the main four are likable, and combat is fun. It\'s more in line with Kingdom Hearts than previous F Fs and in this case, it works. To balance out the long stretches of walking around, when you\'re in trouble a potion will generally help you out. And there is a lot of area to explore. The only major downside is that magic took a huge hit as it relies entirely on farming to make limited-use spells. (Think the draw system from 8, but having to be done with much smaller rewards.) There also isn\'t much variation in spells that you can cast either. Given that your main attack is with weapons, this isn\'t the end of the world but it is a change.

The bad news is... the game sacrifices a - lot - because of said openness. The plot isn\'t intricate nor really fully explained, as the creators assume a player will either watch the tie-in movie or the Anime episodes to fill in blanks. The gameplay becomes linear in later chapters to force the feeling of everything going to crap but some of the so-called tragedies aren\'t that tragic as the game itself has never built up WHY you should feel sad over some of the sacrifices. Some villains are completely shelved or forgotten about in a distant \"oh they\'re dead now sorry.\" That\'s right - you won\'t even get to fight a lot of the antagonists along the way or even see them being all that antagonistic.

Quite a few areas have been hacked out entirely (even ones in promotional materials!) and interactions with NP Cs are pretty limited aside from overhearing conversations. Surprisingly, few that you meet seem all that upset or freaked out about their country being invaded and leaders killed.

Perhaps my biggest gripe is that the game itself feels very empty. For all the space you\'re given to explore, you won\'t really find rewards or secrets waiting for you... just a lot of scenery. Living, breathing NP Cs are scarce and at no point so far has it felt like a major crisis has occurred. By the point massive tragedy has stuck my initial feeling is \"..and why should I care about these guys?\" The plot does get DARK but the buildup is very hit and miss.

Don\'t get me wrong - this is a fun game. But it\'s a game that, given its creation time, doesn\'t live up to the hype. But seeing as how it\'s a Final Fantasy, it will sell fine.

Comments

  • Immortalbear
  • 6th Aug 17
There was an entire chapter dedicated to Noctis grieving Luna and the group fraying over how to treat Ignis. Ignis is largely dead weight to the party and is very aware of this, all while he tries to keep the party together. I wish there was better pacing to the drama but its not like they don\'t focus on it.

Except in the Dark World, where the plot is rushed. It felt like they could have added another 10 hours introducing this new environment, possibly have Luna as a ghost or ascended as a higher spirit. There was so much they could have done so much with Dark World, redefine the the three squad members you have been spending so much time with, and learn what they had done in this new dystopia. New hunts, new battles, and monstrous new bosses I still out hope for DLC focusing on this.

The side quests are admittedly lackluster. A few lighthearted sidequests would have been fine but most should have focused on the resistance efforts against Niflehiem or foreshadowed Ardyn and the coming of demons.

I watched both Kingsglaive and the anime and all they provided was background about Noctis and his father\'s death. They really did not impact my viewing of the game. The promotional material did just that, they promoted the game, nothing more nothing less.

The NP Cs aren\'t great but FF NPCS have never been that good. What was important is they made a good well-developed team of protagonists and I felt they did a good job writing Luna as a sympathetic character, which is better than a lot of FF games.

  • Immortalbear
  • 6th Aug 17
There was an entire chapter dedicated to Noctis grieving Luna and the group fraying over how to treat Ignis. Ignis is largely dead weight to the party and is very aware of this, all while he tries to keep the party together. I wish there was better pacing to the drama but its not like they don\'t focus on it.

Except in the Dark World, where the plot is rushed. It felt like they could have added another 10 hours introducing this new environment, possibly have Luna as a ghost or ascended as a higher spirit. There was so much they could have done so much with Dark World, redefine the the three squad members you have been spending so much time with, and learn what they had done in this new dystopia. New hunts, new battles, and monstrous new bosses I still out hope for DLC focusing on this.

The side quests are admittedly lackluster. A few lighthearted sidequests would have been fine but most should have focused on the resistance efforts against Niflehiem or foreshadowed Ardyn and the coming of demons.

I watched both Kingsglaive and the anime and all they provided was background about Noctis and his father\'s death. They really did not impact my viewing of the game. The promotional material did just that, they promoted the game, nothing more nothing less.

The NP Cs aren\'t great but FF NPCS have never been that good. What was important is they made a good well-developed team of protagonists and I felt they did a good job writing Luna as a sympathetic character, which is better than a lot of FF games.

  • Immortalbear
  • 6th Aug 17
Triple posted sorry.

In order to post comments, you need to

Get Known
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/review_comments.php?id=16475