TV Tropes Org
site search
I Carly back to reviews
Comments
iCarly
This is, in my opinion, the second worst show that the once-great Nickelodeon has come out with this century. And I'm a little shocked that I happen to be in the minority (of teens, kids, and even other adults) who think this. I mean, the premise is a neat idea, but it's execution is totally botched. I guess it was supposed to be like a 21st century version of SNL's "Wayne's World," but this falls totally flat.

To start, none of the characters get a laugh out of me. Carly isn't interesting or funny, her brother is a moron (and not a funny one), Sam is an annoying jerk (and her "funny" lines are just painful), and while to Freddie's credit, he is most likely the most tolerable out of the main characters, he has Carly's same problem of overall blandness.

As with many shows of this nature, Carly and Spencer, despite their parents being nowhere in sight, and neither of them having a day job, they seem to live in a relatively nice apartment. As for the other two? Well, we get hints that Sam has no father and that her mother is a deadbeat of some sort, and Freddie also has no father, and his mother is a smothering hypochondriac. Heh heh, unhappy homes are funny....

The jokes are just horrible, and the laugh track that seems to be begging viewers to laugh along with it is just obnoxious.

Bottom line: I think this show is awful. I may be in the minority, but I'm fine with that.

comment #4643 Sabertooth1000000000 2nd Oct 10 (edited by: dal0525)

comment #4673 Fhalei 4th Oct 10 (edited by: dal0525)

comment #4702 OnTheOtherHandle 5th Oct 10 (edited by: dal0525)

comment #4726 axel100 8th Oct 10 (edited by: dal0525)

comment #6025 son 24th Jan 11 (edited by: dal0525)
You can make any joke seem unfunny with sarcasm.
comment #6036 150.212.51.238 24th Jan 11
I see a ton of deleted comments, all deleted by someone else. A stark reminder of why the ability to edit comments was removed. :/
comment #15784 BonsaiForest 13th Aug 12
I am inclined to agree with this review. I thought that when the series started it was okay at best, and actually funny at times, but it had some painfully obvious Seaosnal Rot to the point where all of the characters just repelled me, except for probably Freddie.
comment #23078 Lucymae2 2nd Feb 14
^ I mean Seasonal Rot
comment #23079 Lucymae2 2nd Feb 14
In order to post comments, you need to Get Known
TV Tropes by TV Tropes Foundation, LLC is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.
Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available from thestaff@tvtropes.org.
Privacy Policy