TV Tropes Org
site search
Howard The Duck back to reviews
Comments
Industrial Light and Magic takes a vacation
One has to wonder what executive producer George Lucas was thinking when he greenlit this idea. "Let's make a movie about an anthropomorphic duck sent into Cleveland by some type of interdimensional laser beam who ends up saving the day against a cosmic abomination." Already, just that sentence alone makes one think "what the hell?", but it doesn't end there. Pretty much every facet of the film seems determined to go further and further over the top but somewhere along the way, they just lost their sense of fun.

Many of the problems stem from the characters. Howard is a sardonic wisecracker, but rather than funny, he comes across as intensely unlikable within minutes. He's just not a nice person at all. Lea Thompson as Beverly is the usual sort of shrill damsel in distress, but has the added bonus of seeming way too sweet and innocent to be in an eighties punk band. Tim Robbins plays perhaps the most irritating portrayal of a geek to hit the silver screen... and breaks suspension of disbelief with the revelation that he's dating one of Beverly's attractive, "desperate" band mates.

But it's not the first time suspension of disbelief will be broken. Oh, no. Whether it's the disturbing sexual teasing between Howard and Beverly or the police simultaneously being the most incompetent and corrupt force in the universe, there's plenty of level breakers all around. Then there are the special effects... according to the credits, Industrial Light and Magic did them, but that's really hard to believe. Certainly one giant step back from Star Wars.

All of this sounds like great fun for a camp lover, but the film doesn't even quite get that right. It introduces all these goofy concepts, but plays them much too seriously. It's as though they forgot they're making a live action film about an anthropomorphic duck. The result is a dour experience, a total downer from start to finish.

The plot (such as it is) plods around without direction and just kind of dies around the fifty minute mark. From there, it's nearly an hour of chase scenes (including the single worst flight sequence ever) and embarrassing special effects. Stupidity drenches the whole production, but not that fun kind. Just the brain cell killing type. Every second of it feels like apoptosis in your noggin. This is a film only bad movie lovers could ever enjoy.
comment #908 doubledragons 30th Aug 09
Duck tits about sums it up.
comment #909 Mr Lostman 30th Aug 09
Ignore, technical error.
comment #910 Noimporta 30th Aug 09 (edited by: Noimporta)
I actually found myself enjoying Howard The Duck when I watched it many years ago. I think that, once I realized how absurd the premise was, I gave it a higher Willing Suspension Of Disbelief threshold and just went with it. Some movies can't be appreciated any other way. For me this is definitely a So Bad Its Good movie.
comment #915 Fighteer 31st Aug 09 (edited by: Fighteer)
ok the movie sucked but comic book howard is actually cool, why they did an alien instead of his nemesis dr, bong ill never know
comment #1783 69.41.118.194 1st Feb 10
The comic book Howard was not just an anthropomorphic duck, he was design to be as if the duck from You Bet Your Life had come to life and landed in Cleveland. The comic was intended to be farce. It didn't just require you to suspend disbelief, but to willingly and joyfully throttle it. Comic book Howard was able to draw you into his world and make you never want to leave. My personal feeling is that he was based at least a little on Groucho Marx, even if he hadn't been a duck from YBYL. Ironically, the ALF character, created for the TV show of the same name, comes much closer to what Howard should have been in the movies, with way less special effects. Much of the joy of the comic book was the dialogue, which the writers/producers of the movie seemed to overlook in favor of special effects. Howard's voice was the worst. I honestly believe if they redubbed the voice and rereleased it, it would play better. Maybe get the guy who did ALF. (Only cause Groucho is dead.)
comment #5044 163.231.6.66 5th Nov 10
In order to post comments, you need to Get Known
TV Tropes by TV Tropes Foundation, LLC is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.
Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available from thestaff@tvtropes.org.
Privacy Policy