Back to Reviews

Reviews Comments: Decent, but nothing to write home about. My Little Pony Friendship Is Magic whole series review by mudge

Pretty good for a kids show, but nothing special otherwise. Starting off, it takes no real risks with the characters. The tomboy having self-worth issues, the shy one having a hidden strength, the bookworm and "straight man" so to speak being not so above everything after all, the seemingly high-class one actually being sweet, none of that is new. It's all been done before and frankly, all been done better.

The Aesop's are often subject to Fridge Logic and Unfortunate Implications, with Mysterious Mare-Do-Well, Dragon Quest and A Friend In Deed being three of the most prominent examples. There have been entire headscratcher, wall banger and dethroning moment pages on those, so I won't go into them further here.

The world-building is lacking to say the least. Despite seeing griffons, minotaurs, zebras and dragons, we know almost nothing about any of them (other than dragons being jerks every time they're seen). Plot elements often come out of nowhere despite opportunities to set them up earlier, such as Shining Armor. This is likely in part due to the episodic nature of the show, but it's still jarring.

One would expect a largely slice of life series to not have many overarching plotlines, and one would be correct. Powerful threats like Discord, Sombra and Chrysalis are brought up and then dealt with in two episodes at absolute maximum. There isn't much build-up, nor are we given much insight into them. Where they come from, how they came to be the way they are, any sort of insight into their characters simply isn't there.

This ability to take down seemingly epic threats easily and then spend a whole episode trying to figure out who ate a cake or an entire episode not realizing they have the wrong person can also jar a more serious watcher and threaten to break the suspension of disbelief.

Now, I've been pretty negative here, so let's get on to what the show does right. The animation is fluid and easy to watch. The songs (with a couple of exceptions) tend to be well-written and enjoyable, and it does manage to work the aesops in without being irritating.

As a childrens show, it is a good, though not spectacular series. However, it fails to build the world, tell any sort of continuous, compelling story over the seasons, or go very deep into anything, and generally lacks to substance to be anything more than a good kids show


  • JackStats94
  • 21st Jul 13
I feel the same why about this show
  • sabrina_diamond
  • 4th Sep 13
Me too
  • AquaSableye
  • 9th Dec 13
Ah, so I wasn't the only one who thought that about the story arcs. I mean, I remember when I watched the first episode, I was fascinated by the idea of how the main cast would grow together to defeat Nightmare Moon. I thought it would be some kind of overreaching arc. And then I watched the next episode... and she was defeated. Instantly. I double-taked when that happened, and I remember thinking "Did I skip a few episodes by accident...? There's no way that could have been resolved so quickly!" But no, it was literally resolved by episode 2. And then I checked the other episodes with King Sombra, Discord, and such, and found they were also resolved within two episodes.

I guess I shouldn't be so surprised they did this, since this IS a slice-of-life show. But it's just... why introduce these seriously awesome threats if you're not going to flesh them out? Why add them if you're only going to have them for two episodes, and then immediately forget about their existence and go back to episodes about daily life? It just bothers me.

In order to post comments, you need to

Get Known