Back to Reviews

Reviews Comments: You want to hate the moral... but you can't Monsters University film/book review by Lale

The hardest-working, most studious, most diligent, undaunted outcast of a student ignores the doubters and critics who say he doesn't have what it takes and that he'll never achieve his dream, ignores the party scene and hits the books, proud of the fact that he has to work hard for what he wants instead of having it handed to him like some annoying unjustified egomaniacs, never giving up no matter what they throw at him, and in the end... it doesn't work. How badly he wanted something and how hard he worked for it wasn't enough to get it. It sucks, it's disappointing, it makes you want to call it a Wall Banger and... it's completely realistic. Audiences hate it when Reality Ensues (that's my personal theory why readers hate, for example, Mansfield Park), but the fact is, a lot of people will go through exactly what Mike goes through and learn that the major you had your heart set on just isn't right for you (that's why it's so common for students to change their major in college). Pixar sacrificed the most emotionally satisfying resolution for realism, and you can't fault them for that... well, I can't, anyway.

This is no Toy Story 2 or 3, but it's no Cars 2, either. Mike and Sully are no Buzz and Woody, but they're still a great duo. It never made me cry, burst into laughter, or glow in the face of a heartwarming moment like you're used to from Pixar, so it's not their best, but it's no Cars or Brave. It's a great journey with a great climax and mostly great characters (ex. I love the Dean, I hate Oozma Kappa). I hope Mike got Sully's message that he should've learned, not that it's okay just to be okay, but that he is great, even if it's in different ways/at different things that he expected. I hope everyone gets the message, not that the supposedly-mediocre and supposedly-great are all equal, but that you can't always judge who's great by what's on the surface. Greatness is a good thing to strive for, but it doesn't come from heritage or appearance or popularity but from hard work, intelligence, and courage, and what you turn out to be great at may surprise YOU as much as it surprises others. That's the ultimate impression I got from this film, which isn't mind-blowingly awesome like other Pixar films but is still great to watch.

Comments

  • BrightLight
  • 2nd Feb 18
Well, unfortunately I view Cars 2 as Pixar\'s best film to date, and Monsters University as an inferior prequel.
  • astrokitty
  • 2nd Feb 18
^ So, that\'s just your opinion.
  • Psi001
  • 2nd Feb 18
The key to the moral working is that it\'s more than just soul crushing and mean spirited, it makes clear the character doesn\'t have to be defined by failing at that one thing. There\'s some things you\'ll never be good at, but that\'s because there\'s other things you are.
  • Tuckerscreator
  • 2nd Feb 18
I like that the film shows that Mike\'s efforts weren\'t totally to waste. Yeah, he isn\'t capable of being a Scarer, but he\'s a fantastic coach. His talent there is what brings him to end up working at Monsters Inc just like he dream of anyway. Plus, we know from the first film that eventually the economy will change and Mike will be in a new environment where his comedic talents are prized instead.

In order to post comments, you need to

Get Known
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/review_comments.php?id=10292