YMMV South Park Discussion

Collapse/Expand Topics
 

SWFMax
Topic
08:26:40 AM Apr 19th 2015
The banner at the top of the YMMV page says we can use the discussion page for discussing these items, since they're subjective, so I'm using this to do that.

"Alternative Character Interpretation: Either The Movie didn't really happen and Sheila Broflovski has just naturally matured or it really did happen and Sheila has been atoning for her actions ever since.". I don't think it's either. The Movie happened, because in "Terrance and Phillip: Behind the Blow", it shows footage from the Canadian-American War. Plus, in "The New Terrance and Phillip Movie Trailer", it has a trailer for Asses Of Fire: 2, implying that there was already an Asses of Fire movie, which only happened in The Movie. As for the interpretation that Sheila has been atoning for her actions, at the end of The Movie, she finally respects Terrance and Phillip, so she wouldn't have to atone after the events of The Movie.

"Hilarious in Hindsight: The Movie (which depicts Saddam Hussein in Hell and as the Big Bad) was made years before to Saddam Hussein's death, interestingly enough." I don't really think that counts as Hilarious In Hindsight. Hussein's death was inevitable, he wasn't immortal.
SWFMax
Topic
07:26:11 PM Apr 9th 2015
I'm not sure about the entry for Creator's Pet that says "Some people think Randy Marsh is becoming this". For starters, it has very little context, and a Creator's Pet is by definition The Scrappy (plus other things). According to a recent poll made by the official South Park website, Randy is actually a fan favourite, beating out every other character, and therefore not The Scrappy.
SeptimusHeap
12:57:03 AM Apr 10th 2015
I've removed it completely - Creator's Pet has a lot more criteria to meet than that.
SWFMax
Topic
08:55:10 PM Dec 26th 2014
It looks like Hilarious in Hindsight is long enough for its own page.
Collapse/Expand Topics