What's Happening

Troperville

Tools

collapse/expand topics back to YMMV/FullmetalAlchemist

 

Discontent
topic
12:26:27 AM Sep 6th 2014
Pulled these examples:

From the Manga and Brotherhood section:
  • Unfortunate Implications:
    • Garfiel, particularly in the omakes, where he's frequently the butt of jokes about how gross effeminate men are, and is portrayed as a sexual predator for laughs.
    • Grumman slapping Rebecca's rear being played for laughs. In the manga, she at least gets to yell at him for it, but not in the anime.

From the 2003 anime:
  • Unfortunate Implications:
    • Claus, the girl who dresses like a boy in episode 4, stops doing so after she gets over the death of her sister. The implication being that dressing as the opposite sex always stems from something negative, and is "just a phase" that people grow out of when the negative thing is resolved.
    • Barry the Chopper being a Villainous Crossdresser, once again reinforcing the idea that there's something wrong with those who dress as the opposite sex.
    • Rose getting an obliquely-presented, but obvious, case of Rape as Drama offscreen, which she never gets to actually discuss (because her trauma turned her mute). Her treatment in the show is pretty excessively sadistic overall, but this is the worst of it.

As per the Unfortunate Implications page: 'no example may be added in this article or on a work article, without proof that it's not just one person thinking.' In other words, citation is required.
MajorMajor
topic
03:15:37 AM Jun 21st 2014
I just wanted to say that "Colons don't work like that" explanation of the last edit was the best piece of unintended hilarity I saw this month. Unintentional kudos to the editor.
Tropesofknowledge
09:26:46 AM Jun 21st 2014
Unintentional thanks right back at ya.
lupine123
topic
01:34:05 AM May 13th 2014
edited by 66.58.237.97
About this: "Edward calling Ling "squint-eyed" and similar things is played for laughs and never addressed as a bad thing. Might also count as cultural dissonance as Japan to this day is prejudiced against people from China."

I'm pretty sure that the "squinty eyes" comments were about Ling's character design and what that implies about his personality? None of the other Xing characters share that trait with Ling, and it seems like a rather American/European stereotype.

Hodor
05:11:02 AM May 13th 2014
I agree I think. Maybe the English translation is covering up racism, but as far as I can tell, he 's called "shifty eyed" not "squint eyed" and it's because he has "evil" looking eyes- which is why he's usually Eyes Always Shut. As noted, none of the other Xingese characters have eyes like him.
lupine123
10:17:24 AM May 13th 2014
edited by 66.58.237.97
Yeah, I have the viz manga translation and I can confirm he definitely does say "shifty eyes," I think that Brotherhood's english dub has him say "squinty eyes" though; so it might translated differently by one or the other.

lupine123
01:28:29 AM May 30th 2014
edited by 66.58.237.97
Ok, if no one has any objections I'm going to take it down. It's flamebaity and the fact that it's characteristic of Ling and Ling only, Eyes Always Shut is a common anime trope that fits Ling to a T, and is translated as "Shifty" in the manga (a term that's even mentioned to be common translation on the Eyes Always Shut trope page) And In the next panel Al even mentions that *Ed* has pretty shifty eyes too.

I'm pretty sure the joke was probably about Ling's character design being common with sly and sometimes villainous characters who sometimes like to fein obliviousness, not a racial stereotype.

However, there are unfortunate implications in the fact that the dub decided to translate this as a Fantasy!European person calling an visitor from Fantasy!China "squinty-eyes." Especially considering that dub is being translated in place that the term "squinty eyes" *is* demonstrative of Western prejudice against people from Asia.
Hodor
topic
10:00:16 AM Nov 1st 2013
Wanted to ask a question about this Hilarious in Hindsight example:

  • The villains' argument that the millions of people they kill will still live as Philosophers' Stones inside the conspirators is pretty much the same as the Catalyst's infamous fan-infuriating Insane Troll Logic in Mass Effect 3.

What I'm wondering, is that I don't recall any such argument (can someone refresh my memory here?) From what I recall, neither the hommunculi nor the conspirators really care about those casualties, and as I understand it, the conspirators don't necessarily think as many people will die as Father had planned- specifically, they expected some people to be left for them to rule.

BobBensonIsHomunculus
topic
07:04:54 PM Oct 27th 2013
edited by 50.133.133.198
It shouldn't have to be said, but: can we keep Tumblr drama away from TV Tropes?

Or at least, can we not have one Tumblr blog's "feminist analysis" of the 2003 series - that is based on half-remembrances, and plenty of other people have already debunked - stated as though it's a common criticism? Really, we shouldn't be posting stuff that's just one person saying it here anyway, but at least if you're going to include it, make it out to be what it is - one person's analysis, someone who's not exactly a well-respected critic or anything - and make sure it's acknowledged that there are a lot of people (including other feminists) who disagree.

It mainly seems to be one user adding these things, but s/he is a persistent one, and it's getting annoying to constantly have to check this page to revert their edits - which seem to be more based on reading that blog (since it's the same "criticisms" there but re-worded or exaggerated) than their own viewing of the 2003 anime.
Tropesofknowledge
08:36:57 PM Oct 27th 2013
edited by 72.200.24.45
YMMV pages were made so that people could express their opinions without putting them on the main page so as to seem like facts. The only way to remove ymmv items is for the example to not follow the trope definition. Otherwise, his opinion (or a blog's; it doesn't matter) has just as much right to be there as yours do.

If you would like to take down any of his examples at any time, please prove why the examples he wrote are not proper examples of their respective tropes.
amarielah
10:11:33 PM Oct 30th 2013
I've been given to understand that YMMV is not actually for individual opinions, but for prevelent subjective opinions in fandom as a whole. Is this not the case?
BobBensonIsHomunculus
05:33:30 PM Nov 1st 2013
edited by 155.41.120.94
Also, we're also allowed to remove things that are factually wrong about the work, correct? Because as I was trying to indicate with the note about them being based on "half-remembrances", a lot of these criticisms about how the 2003 series is supposedly "anti-feminist" are based on wrong information - complaining about things that didn't actually happen in the series, leaving out things that did happen that would disprove their arguments, and so on.

Also, I'd like the clarification amarielah asked for as well. From my experience on other YMMV pages, there seems to be a new rule that Unfortunate Implications examples in particular need to be something that is a common impression viewers have, not just one person's opinion, and need an outside citation to show this. (Personally, I like that new rule; since TVT is a reference, it should reflect what are frequent impressions - positive or negative - that some fans have about the series, rather than allowing one person to bias everything toward their particular, highly-individual take on the series. Especially if it's a contentious topic where ranting about it violates Rule of Cautious Editing Judgment. I've seen this as a problem on YMMV pages for other volatile fandoms, too, and it seems to be what the person who I mentioned above is doing, when the things s/he is adding aren't just outright incorrect.)
MajorMajor
10:35:13 AM Mar 19th 2014
Ditto for quoting tumblr blogs in FMA Brotherhood YMMV as a source behind Unfortunate Implicatons around racism.

Plus "It's the same justification as many racists use!" is just an ugly argument that leads to drama.
lupine123
09:21:42 PM May 1st 2014
edited by 137.229.209.243
tbh I kinda don't think that we should be linking to tumblr for either ymmv section for either series, if only because the fandom infighting is so ugly there.

Outside of tumblr the drama sorta started peetering out back in 2012, so there are probably other sources that could convey the same information without dropping people into active fandom battle grounds.

EmmaWoodhouse18
topic
07:14:56 PM Mar 4th 2013
edited by EmmaWoodhouse18
Along with sections for the Manga/Brotherhood and the 2003 Anime, could we maybe have a section for things that apply to both works/the fandom in general? A lot of the stuff (such as some of the stuff about ship wars, or the Broken Base over comparisons between the works) doesn't make sense to put in one or the other.
SeptimusHeap
topic
05:30:04 AM Feb 3rd 2012
This entry is Thread Mode, can it be chopped down a bit? WITHOUT the personal stuff and Natter?
  • Misaimed Fandom:
    • Roy destroying Envy in the most painful way possible isn't supposed to be enjoyed by the audience. You're supposed to be worrying for Roy's sanity, not cheering for him to kick Envy's ass. The anime clears this up a bit, largely with the way the voices sound: Roy's tone is clearly that of a savage madman, and Envy sounds like a scared ten year old.
    • To be fair, a lot of readers/viewers believed that Envy totally deserved it.
      • Whether Envy deserved it or not isn't the point. If Scar had been torturing him/her, it would have been all right, because Scar had already surrendered to his rage long ago. The part you're supposed to focus on is Roy making the same mistake.
      • Surely there's a middle ground where we can simultaneously enjoy Envy getting what's coming to him/her and fear that Roy's going past the point of no return.
      • The characters agree that Envy needs to die (Riza plans on finishing Envy off herself, although Roy claims he doesn't want her to dirty her hands), but believe Roy doing it for vengeance is wrong.
    • You can't fight how you feel about the scene, but there is room for both reactions. The shift from 'this is awesome' to 'this could get ugly' is roughly around Envy's Clipped Wing Angel form reappearing.

KSonik
topic
10:47:25 AM Dec 26th 2010
Added the Character Alignment. if you have a problem with it discuss it here.

back to YMMV/FullmetalAlchemist

TV Tropes by TV Tropes Foundation, LLC is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.
Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available from thestaff@tvtropes.org.
Privacy Policy