What's Happening

Troperville

Tools

collapse/expand topics back to SerieS/StarTrekTheNextGeneration

 

Laudanum
topic
10:10:38 PM Nov 13th 2014
I'm having some issues with the below entry and I would appreciate any input:

  • Informed Ability:
    • Troi's counseling skills, and even her empathy (or at least her application of it). Whenever we see her counseling someone, she's condescending at best, and outright hostile at worst. Usually this leads to whoever is being counseled to leave and ignore her advice. When a plot requires that someone get important therapy or even just good advice, they turn to Guinan instead.
      • Although it is worth noting that Troi's counseling sessions are rarely shown unless it is to reveal that some issue Troi is having is affecting her ability to do her job.

As far as I remember, it is true that Troi's counseling sessions were only shown if they were a plot point in some way, either elucidating someone's personal problem (like Reg Barclay), or showing when Troi's ability to do her job is affected (and this is in the majority). However when Troi is doing her job normally I can't recall any time when she was hostile or condescending (or at least not more so than any counselor or psychiatrist I'm familiar with). Her job is to counsel someone about their personal problems and try to find a solution, and she often suggests a path they should take based on her expertise, and I don't know if this is being interpreted as condescending, maybe? But I'm currently re-watching some TGN episodes and I can't see anything to support the premise that she's condescending or hostile towards her patients in normal counseling. I'd say Guinan was more condescending than Troi in fact, and I don't consider Guinan particularly condescending when you take into the fact her hundreds of years of life experience. (I agree that people tend to go to see Guinan about advice for their life problems, but that fits her role as the bar-tender).

In addition, although Troi's counseling skills are mostly informed, I wouldn't say her version of empathy was, considering she uses that on a regular basis. Also, despite rarely seeing her counseling someone in private, she does counsel Picard and some of the main staff during casual conversation.

In any case I just can't find or remember anything to support the above statement about Troi, and I'm not a fan of the character so I can't put it down to partiality making me blind to that aspect of her. It could be that my memory is faulty, but I just can't see it.

So I'm going to change the above to what I've written below. If anyone agrees or disagrees with me or what I've written, I'd like to discuss it, and ultimately if anyone else is convinced I'm incorrect, they're of course free to change what I've written back to the above, but I would like to know they're reasoning for doing so if possible.

  • Informed Ability:

    • We rarely see Troi's counseling skills in private sessions. Her counseling sessions are only shown on-screen to either elucidate someone's plot-relevant personal/psychological problem - and this is done rarely - or, more commonly, to reveal that some issue Troi is having is affecting her ability to do her job, which normally results in her abusing the poor patient by being overtly condescending, downright hostile, or just acting really strangely. Typically when someone has a problem they need help with, they are shown talking to Guinan for advice, who uses her position as bar-tender to full effect (usually using some tough-love to manipulate or force someone to face their problems).

TheLyniezian
topic
03:22:46 AM Aug 7th 2014
Thew New Media Are Evil example has a lot of sub-points making reference to quite modern videogames. The trouble is it's trying to explain a series that aired twenty years before FarmVille and World of Warcraft ever came out... are there any games from the late '80s or early '90s that could be comparable? (Were they that addictive and absorbing back then, given the limitations on technology?)
TheLyniezian
03:23:12 AM Aug 7th 2014
edited by 86.21.146.228
(Not counting Tetris, of course... ;-))
SeptimusHeap
moderator
04:52:23 AM Aug 7th 2014
According to Wikipedia, that episode aired in 1991. The Contra and Nintendo originated in the 80s, so it's at least accurate from that sense.
AwSamWeston
topic
02:43:28 PM Aug 21st 2013
Y'know how J. J. Abrams has been making the reboot movies of The Original Series?

If they ever do a TNG reboot, I would like to nominate Wil Wheaton, formerly Wesley Crusher, to play Will Riker.

Wheaton not only has the face (and the beard!) to play Riker, but he also has the golden opportunity to make jabs at his own character!
New!Wesley: (Something annoying.)
Wheaton!Riker: Shut up, Wesley!
Can you say Ascended Meme?
CleverPun
topic
09:11:24 PM Apr 27th 2012
There are regular tropes in the "trope based episodes" section, im working on sorting them correctly, but any help would be appreciated.

Also any new examples being put int the correct sections would be great
back to SerieS/StarTrekTheNextGeneration

TV Tropes by TV Tropes Foundation, LLC is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.
Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available from thestaff@tvtropes.org.
Privacy Policy