What's Happening

Troperville

Tools

collapse/expand topics back to Pantheon/GrandUnitedAllianceOfGood

MysteriousZorua1994
topic
03:32:55 AM Nov 20th 2014
Should we include the Hacking Quintet into the GUAG as well? The Friendship Asylum made the founding three quite noticeable to the GUAG, and with two more members joining recently, it's big enough now.
TPPR10
08:04:19 AM Nov 20th 2014
I personally think not. Because, well, there really isn't a good counterpart in GUAE for it.
MysteriousZorua1994
08:30:14 AM Nov 20th 2014
True, but they've got a nemesis in the Master Control Program. Maybe we should create a evil equitant of the quintet to bring in as a foil group, with the MCP as it's leader (though we'll need to ascend Sark in, as well). Also, one upcoming story will put them at odds with the Yandere Quartet.

I'm not saying we should; it's only a suggestion.
TPPR10
12:39:59 PM Nov 20th 2014
You don't need to ascend any one in. Especially if its to fill up a slot in a group. Especially if there would already be some one from same works in it. There are plenty of other people who would apply there.

Just saying.
robertman2
topic
05:09:58 AM Apr 23rd 2013
edited by 216.99.32.42
Should we move Optimus Prime to the Robot War Division? I mean he is a giant robot after.
robertman2
topic
05:07:44 AM Apr 23rd 2013
edited by 216.99.32.45
I think we should move Cav Johnson over here.
CerotechOmega
topic
10:08:02 PM Dec 19th 2012
Heyo. Since the GUAG Combat Division tends to fill up quick, I was wondering if an "Intelligence Division" would be in the works. You know, something for spies, scouts and ninjas within the GUAG.
DonaldthePotholer
topic
01:26:54 PM Jun 13th 2011
Given that Cosmos is the commanding Officer of the GUAG, personages who were voiced by her voice actresses should have the title of "______ Herald of Cosmos" (where ____ = the language of the actress).
OldManHoOh
topic
04:33:25 PM Jan 2nd 2011
That seems to be it. Can anyone better acquainted with these guys move them to the right subsection?
OldManHoOh
topic
09:21:41 PM Dec 30th 2010
Me again. Would the Toku Base examples be separate from the other divisions, or overlap? It's hard to tell from context.
SchizoTechnician
08:01:47 AM Dec 31st 2010
edited by SchizoTechnician
Separate, I think, for the Saints. Saints that also have a god title also go in the respective division.
DonaldthePotholer
01:28:27 PM Jun 13th 2011
Sidepoint: Why is the Toku Base itself not part of the Combat Division, like the Robot War Division?
ChrisX
03:58:31 PM Jun 13th 2011
Because those from Toku Base don't go into the usual Main House, while those from the Robot War Division existed in the Main House.
OldManHoOh
topic
08:33:39 PM Dec 30th 2010
edited by OldManHoOh
This sort of applies to the Alliance of Evil, too...maybe I'm overthinking this but, would the Alliance really need non-Pantheon good guys under its membership?
OldManHoOh
topic
05:36:43 PM Dec 30th 2010
I notice that Mario apparently opposes the sort of fun that harms others. What about in Mario Party or New Super Mario Bros. Wii or (to an extent) Mario Kart?
SchizoTechnician
08:22:10 PM Dec 30th 2010
edited by SchizoTechnician
Eh, they always have more lives. Nobody is ever permanently injured or killed in the Mushroom Kingdom, you'll notice, save for extra-dimensional invaders and the Shroobs, so it doesn't count as hurting them if Mario knows that there'll be no lasting harm.
OldManHoOh
08:29:02 PM Dec 30th 2010
edited by OldManHoOh
Ehh, guess you're right. Maybe a case of Gameplay and Story Segregation between the players that fuck with one another in NSMB Wii and what Mario, Luigi and the two Toads REALLY do. (That sounded a lot less dirty in my head)
Meeble
topic
10:37:26 AM Dec 12th 2010
This page needs to be split, as its current size has reached a point where new edits to the article cause server performance issues. Details can be seen in this thread.

Since there doesn't seem to be much of a standard order for entries in the pantheon, I was thinking of splitting them up by their Domain or Sphere of Influence. The main page would become and Index, which would list the sub-pages and include a listing of each character that is on those pages. What I envision would end up looking something like this:

(Note: I am currently in the process of copying over each entry to the above sub-pages, so the lists are not complete at this time.)

I would like to get some feedback from those who regularly edit these articles to see if this would be an acceptable means of splitting the page or not. If action is not taken soon, this article could end up being locked due to its size.

SchizoTechnician
02:14:27 PM Dec 12th 2010
edited by SchizoTechnician
Its already been split a bit into GUAG Combat Division, GUAG Support Staff, GUAG Psych Warfare, and GUAG Token Evil Teammates; see the discussion for the Trope Pantheons page in general. We still need a leadership division and maybe a breakdown of the Combat group even further.
Meeble
03:11:49 PM Dec 12th 2010
Ah, good to know! I will cutlist the domain pages I had started, in that case.
ChrisX
09:40:08 PM Dec 13th 2010
I'm planning to get one sub division in the Combat Division... Giant Robots Division. Basically, those who rides robots and is capable of entering the Super Robot Wars or such. We got a lot of good guys over there.
KrisMahai
07:22:57 PM Dec 28th 2010
Can we get some progress on this? It's currently over 100,000 characters over the limit where it starts crashing the servers, and no one in the thread mentioned above has any idea how to split it. I don't mean to be rude, but this is one of the only pages not split, and it's because none of the people splitting the pages have any idea how you guys want it split.
SchizoTechnician
08:10:55 PM Dec 28th 2010
edited by SchizoTechnician
The existing categories should be self-explanatory: split based on character abilities as if the Alliance was an actual military force. I was the one that started the split, and I really can't go any farther, as the unsplit characters I don't know enough about to sort if they would be combat personnel (skilled in fighting), Robot War (giant robot pilots) psychological warfare (aka, entertainment and morale boosting for the good guys and demoralization of the enemy), medical division (healers), support (other/misc), or what. Once people familiar with Touhou and whatnot have copied them into the proper divisions, we can reduce the main GUAG page to a list of the divisions.
Meeble
10:25:17 AM Dec 30th 2010
edited by Meeble
Question: Can the Gods that are already listed on the Division sub-pages be safely removed from the master list? I would not mind going through those pages and removing all that have already been split in one fell swoop, which would leave only those Gods that have not already been assigned.

Let me know if this would be OK.
OldManHoOh
05:02:00 PM Dec 30th 2010
edited by OldManHoOh
It won't place it under 400,000 characters, but the unelaborated list of "Others" right at the bottom seems pretty useless to me.

Though to answer Meeble's question, if you ask me, it seems redundant to list them on both this page AND the subpages.
OldManHoOh
05:34:48 PM Dec 30th 2010
Given this note just above the examples, I think you can go right ahead.

Please note that the goal is to make sure that we've got all the gods listed below in the proper place(s) among the above divisions; when we are sure of that, the examples on this page can safely be wiped, which is made necessary by this page's incredible wiki-breaking length.
SchizoTechnician
08:20:53 PM Dec 30th 2010
Yeah, go ahead. I would have deleted as a made 'em, but the main page was in big-page-lockdown when I did so, and I don't have the initiative to go through it with a fine toothed comb a second time.
Meeble
10:36:06 PM Dec 31st 2010
edited by Meeble
Thanks! Sorry I haven't been able to look at this since I asked my question initially.

It looks like Command division is done, and Combat division is being worked on by OMHO. I will start on the Psych division now... will update this post when I'm finished.

Edit: Psych Warfare is done. And that gets us below 400k! Great work so far!! I'll see how it looks tomorrow and try to take another page or two.
Meeble
07:27:22 AM Jan 1st 2011
edited by Meeble
I will start on Support Staff now, and will again update when I'm done so that others will know when it's safe to edit.

Robot and Medical divisions may not be done after all, as I noticed there was some overlap on some of the lists. I will look at them more closely later.

OldManHoOh
07:54:42 AM Jan 1st 2011
I'll probably continue with Combat this evening, if not tomorrow.
Meeble
07:57:14 AM Jan 1st 2011
Support Staff is done! We're down to around 300k now.
Meeble
01:08:14 PM Jan 2nd 2011
I did another check, and it looks like the members of the Command, Robot, Medical, Support, Token Evil, and Toku Base divisions are all off of the main page. Once the Combat division is done, we'll be "caught up", and any new entries to those divisions can be deleted from the main page at the same time they're added to the sub-pages.
79.97.167.141
topic
05:24:00 PM Nov 26th 2010
What does it mean that Yue is "loyal to Nodoka... unless Negi-sensei says otherwise"? (In Nodoka's section.) That doesn't reflect their relationship at all - Yue places her relationship with Nodoka above that with Negi, and Nodoka is the other way around (see the relationship charts and trivia for the characters), so if anything that should read Nodoka as being loyal to Yue unless Negi says otherwise. Not that that makes much sense either.
Committee
topic
09:03:57 PM Nov 17th 2010
I took the liberty of moving Commander the Non-Entity General to Token Bad Guy Members. Should the Non Entity General considered evil?

Can neutral members of the pantheon be considered bad guys?
201.143.239.118
topic
05:56:20 PM Jul 25th 2010
edited by 201.143.239.118
I found curious how Melkor find less threatening someone who has been victim of The Worf Effect only once(Signum) than someone that is being hitted with that severeal times(Vita).
ChrisX
07:03:38 PM Jul 28th 2010
edited by ChrisX
Well, in that case, let it be not only Signum that we discuss... but ANY of those put in 'Those Hit With Badass Decay / Chickification' list.

What shall be the requirement for characters with it?
201.143.71.103
02:18:37 PM Oct 22nd 2010
there's actually knowledge about someone who has hitted that list but manage to rise out of it in the past?
ChrisX
03:04:46 AM Oct 25th 2010
You'll have to make it up.
back to Pantheon/GrandUnitedAllianceOfGood

TV Tropes by TV Tropes Foundation, LLC is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.
Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available from thestaff@tvtropes.org.
Privacy Policy