What's Happening

Troperville

Tools

collapse/expand topics back to Main/ptitleueswu2fx0swd

Korval
topic
03:50:57 PM Aug 25th 2010
This:

  • The brutal oversimplification of the tabletop strategy game Battle Tech done by Microsoft for the Mechassault series (not to be confused with the Mech Warrior series which for the most part is pretty faithful). This included such things as force fields, a gun that shoots lava, magical glowing green piles of salvage that instantly repair damage, infinite ammo, and contact with the ground causing all mechs to explode violently
    • Mech Warrior 4 also added variable-damage weaponry in the form of the Bombast laser, and claimed that the vacuum of space provided improved cooling over air.
      • Small Battle Tech note. A variable-damage weapon was later added to BT, but it was not the Bombast laser.
        • As of the recent core book, Tactical Operations, there are two kinds weapons that can vary damage: Bombast Lasers and any PPC with a capacitor. Not counting Ultra and Rotary Autocannons, and range-variable weapons like Heavy Gauss Rifles and Snub-nosed PPCs.
          • Mechwarrior 4 takes plenty of liberties all the same. Clantech is far too abundant, especially in the Mercenaries sequel which has even backwater rebel militias armed with cutting edge Clan Omnimechs!

You could call it adaptation decay, but I see no evidence that the makers of Mech Assault didn't care about what they were making.
DOmen
topic
03:00:01 PM Oct 7th 2010
edited by runawayjoincircus
Pulled this out.

  • Nintendo is usually known for their good localization work(the Mario And Luigi RPGs wouldn't be as awesome without the great localization they gave the series), but their localization of Metroid Other M is truly inexcusable. Awful voice acting abound, incomprehensible dialogue, and a horribly miscast Samus. But they also commit the biggest cardinal sin of any bad localization: leaving out the (vastly superior) Japanese voice track. Even Sin And Punishment Star Successor had the original voice track!

I could say Fan Dumb, but let's just consider it a heavy case of Your Mileage May Vary. Way too heavy to be on the page (passed as fact, even).
MrDeath
03:14:19 PM Oct 7th 2010
Yeah, that's just bitching and moaning. It seems like there's no shortage of it in regards to Other M.
AndrewGPaul
topic
06:22:42 AM Mar 8th 2011
The Tekken and King of Fighters examples under Film are awfully long, are they not? They're two or three times as long as any other Film example, even without the natter.
Lots42
topic
04:59:43 AM Mar 28th 2011
edited by runawayjoincircus
The promotional material for the HAVOC vehicle from G.I.Joe shows a red-and-white uniformed man firing guns. This is Lifeline, an avowed pacifist who at the time would never have fired any guns.
WillBGood
topic
05:36:15 PM Jul 17th 2011
Quite a lot of the entries here don't seem to be about production values at all, but about Adaptation Decay, Did Not Do the Research, or Executive Meddling (and the Ko F entry that I opted to remove just smacked too much of someone complaining a thing was RUINED FOREVER).

I could do more aggressive paring-down, but I'm a little worried about overreaching my authority.
WillBGood
06:11:11 PM Jul 17th 2011
Ah what the heck, I'll go ahead and pare aggressively; worst-case scenario the page can be restored from an earlier version.

Pulled: All Anime/Manga entries except the Dragon Ball movie dub and Yu-Gi-Oh Abridged comment entries: rest are more Did Not Do the Research. Film: Scarlet Letter entry (really Adaptation Decay) Film: Hackers entry (too much natter) Film: Dead Like Me (Adaptation Decay) Film: Highlander (which seems to be commenting more on Highlander 2— which might warrant its own entry if someone wants to write it) Literature: Friday the 13th (Adaptation Decay, maybe.) Literature: Disney's Aladdin (Did Not Do the Research, or maybe they did according to the sub-entry) TV: Buffy the Vampire Slayer (Did Not Do the Research, though what exactly they got wrong wasn't even detailed) TV: iCarly (kind of lacking detail) TV: Tales from the Neverending Story (Adaptation Decay) Entire Theatre folder — both examples look more like Adaptation Decay or at least Alternate Character Interpretation of a crazy sort rather than shoddy production values. Video Games: It'd almost be easier to list what wasn't removed for actually being about Adaptation Decay, Didn't Do the Research, Your Mileage May Vary, or even Seasonal Rot, Blind Idiot Translation, or Contemptible Cover. Western Animation: Jungle Book (it's either Adaptation Decay or Executive Meddling) Western Animation: Transformers Beast Machines (mostly a big fat Take That at Dan Di Dio) Western Animation: Tom & Jerry the Movie (just an entry writer ranting about why it sucked) Western Animation: Bionicle (Adaptation Decay) Western Animation: Captain N (Adaptation Decay) Western Animation: Busy World of Richard Scarry (are the historical segments supposed to be educational or are they dictated by Rule of Funny?)

Yeah, a lot of stuff pulled out— and there's still an entry or two I'm not sure belong. This trope may need an overhaul.

CyberTiger88
topic
01:39:40 PM Sep 30th 2011
I think this trope is Darth Wiki worthy. Who agree/disagrees?
back to Main/ptitleueswu2fx0swd

This wiki is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 Unported License.
Privacy Policy