Take it to the Image Pickin' forum if you want to get a vote going.

Handy-dandy link to Image Pickin'.

Fanboys, probably.

The IJBM page was half a discussion about The Game which had only a tangential relationship to the comic, and half someone complaining about one comic in particular being "The most NSFW comic ever."

If people want to bash the comic, they can do it in plenty of other places. ...How does that tie into the rest of your point?

My point is that a substantial part of the bile that gets heaped on many controversial pages like xkcd seems to be derived from the idea that a discussion of the subject cannot be complete without mentioning every example of hatedom that exists. That's not the point of the wiki. In fact, we're on a general mission from the admins to cut out this kind of cruft and reduce the use of Subjective Tropes and tropes that apply to the fandom rather than the work. We are not Wikipedia, but we also aren't ED.

Put it this way: can you think of a good reason why xkcdexplained needs to be on this page? Having it here only increases the likelihood of attracting Natter, as can easily be seen from recent edits.

The alternative to self-policing is to have pages scrubbed and locked and tropers banned.

Just add a new paragraph (preferably before the list.) listing the actual trivia tropes, for example like this:

Miscellaneous trivia tropes and information

• That escalator actually exists, blah blah blah...

Lists of xkcd images used on TV Tropes

• Blah Blah Blah
• xkcd

Done!