Main Vic Mignogna Discussion

collapse/expand topics

07:03:58 AM Sep 14th 2011
In one of recent threads, http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/posts.php?discussion=12939978090A23863300&page=1, it was reiterated that tropes should not be used to describe real life people unless it's being used for the roles He/She play. I'm going to go ahead a delete the tropes about Vic Mignogna but leave the ones up about his roles.
03:48:59 PM Jul 5th 2011
edited by Bakazuki
Carrying this discussion over from the Troper Tales discussion page to the main one.

Yeah. As I said before, The Troper Tales page is like a ticking time bomb. I've deleted all the non-troper blog posts (which coincidentally were also most of the negative ones), but I can see that going bad again if tropers actually do begin posting negative stories from their own experiences.

Should we just lock the Troper Tales page in order to avoid dealing with inevitable Edit/Flame wars? Or do we keep, with some very strict guidelines on what stays and what goes?
03:51:21 PM Jul 5th 2011
Delete it. Troper Tales is shaky as it is, but real life people aren't even tropes.
11:22:58 AM Jul 6th 2011
Hold for a minute. You mean delete just the Troper Tales page and not the main page, too, right? 'cause we have an entire index full of real people (actors, etc.). Let me fix up those subject-ambiguous pronouns to clarify what I'm suggesting...
04:10:55 PM Jul 8th 2011
It was inevitable I suppose. I have no idea why the dude is such a polarizing person (and whether the rumors are just that, or if there's any truth to them) but this is for the best. Pages like that shouldn't be for complaining about people you don't like.
05:40:02 AM Aug 13th 2011
He's such a polarizing person because he's so outspoken about his Christian faith. After all, Jesus himself said things like that would happen to anyone who followed him. Kinda makes me wonder what kind of vitriol has been spread about his costar Caitlin Glass.
02:40:19 PM Nov 14th 2010
So, is it just me, or is the introduction to this article a bit biased (presenting Edward Elric as seemingly being more important than all of his other roles)? Whatever happened to Broly? It just bugs me.
12:08:15 PM Nov 29th 2010
I'd say Edward Elric has been his biggest role so far since Broly really is more of a side character in the Dragon Ball mythos as a whole.
04:11:20 AM Feb 10th 2011
Late comment, but didn't he voice-act Dark Mousy before Ed? *checks imdb* Yeah, he did. Dark Mousy was a pretty big role, too, even though it didn't show on Adult Swim. It's not as big as Edward, but 2nd or 3rd; however, it barely garners a mention on his tropes "about" section. Perhaps we could give it a few more nods?
05:39:56 PM Jul 15th 2010
I'm a little embarrassed to ask, but how do you pronounce his last name?
05:58:03 PM Jul 15th 2010
"min-YAN-yah" At least I think that's it. It could also be "mah-DERP-ah-derp"
03:42:24 AM May 3rd 2010
Um.... how the hell is Crowning Moment of Awesome applicable? The moments listed were Crowning Moments of FAIL, if anything.
05:41:02 PM Jul 15th 2010
What do we keep saying? Your Milage May Vary.