Main Shana Clone Discussion

Collapse/Expand Topics

01:34:56 AM Jul 29th 2014
Would Shimakaze from Kantai Collection count? I don't know much about that franchise, but her appearance seems to fit.
02:46:32 AM Jul 29th 2014
The Google search including images and character descriptions suggest that she does fit the trope.
09:41:30 AM Oct 15th 2013
Why haven't I seen any Joss Whedon characters in here?

Anyways, nominating Severa and Viridi as examples.
09:36:14 AM Apr 22nd 2013
I noticed that Kotetsu from The Adventures of Kotetsu was removed. It doesn't fit the archetype?
11:38:33 AM May 20th 2012
Okay, I know *DATA EXPUNGED* is an SCP Foundation running joke, but it's not very useful as an example here.
08:04:59 PM May 22nd 2012
Agreed. No place on this article. What should we replace it with though? Should we just get a new picture?
11:11:24 AM May 28th 2012
What does the SCP example have to do with the picture?
01:43:58 PM May 28th 2012
How about the same picture, but with Nagi Sanzenin from Hayate No Gotoku replacing She-Who-Must-Not-Be-Named?
03:27:23 PM May 28th 2012
The image is fine. It has a mod request not to touch it.
09:42:28 AM Sep 12th 2011
To be honest I dont think that Victorique from Gosick is much of a Shana clone. She doesnt really look or act in a way fitting for this apart from being short. Shes is a tsundere but shes definitely not that bad of one compared to Shana herself.. The example on the page comes with no description as to why either. Her gothic lolita clothes also do fit at all aswell. Id really like to know how she fits.
10:45:40 AM Apr 5th 2012
That's because she is not. The article was originally called "Tiny Tyrannical Tsundere", but somebody had the "brilliant" idea of renaming this as "Shana clone", thus most of the article doesn't make sense anymore. They were forced to rename it because Tvtropes has a new anti-anime policy, thus any articles with "weird" 'foreign sounding' terms are immediately erased, so sadly we have to conform with these sub-par and inferior articles until the admins of this site change their mind.
09:07:59 AM Jul 12th 2011
Any word on why this was cut?
09:10:32 AM Jul 12th 2011
10:45:56 PM Jul 12th 2011
Ah... that makes me sad. -_-
06:34:22 PM Jul 28th 2011
edited by jcdietz03
How do you appeal the decision or start voting on it? It seems like the trope does not have the problem that moderator / admin thinks it has. It seems like the most tropers like this name and don't want to rename.

For people who want to discuss the issue, there is the YKTTW for this.
03:44:17 PM Jun 21st 2011
It sounds like this trope would be related to Abusively Sexy Woman, but I'm not familiar enough with any of the examples to say so.
Collapse/Expand Topics