What's Happening

Troperville

Tools

collapse/expand topics back to Main/MaggieGyllenhaal

Jabroniville
topic
02:33:20 AM Jan 7th 2011
Not that I'm complaining (it DOES seem rather mean to put Your Mileage May Vary on a living person's page regarding their attractiveness), but why are fetish-based comments and obvious fans gushing over her looks allowed, but comments about varying people disliking her looks not? I realize that living people's pages are gonna be prone with gushing about all their attributes (or else EVERY actress' page will have to be edited), but what's the deal here?
Phrederic
02:08:37 AM Jan 20th 2011
We're more of a nice site than a mean one. I'm not trying to be mean, but you can find people to make fun of her looks on practically any other site out there.
ExterminatorZed
08:48:48 AM May 2nd 2011
Commentary on personal tastes regarding how someone looks — for good or ill, in my opinion, should be relegated to another page, not the main entry. Main entries should not be a place for subjective entries, but rather factual, useful information. A majority of these actress pages are just entry-wank over an actress' good looks rather than useful information.
GrieverVIII
topic
04:27:01 PM Oct 13th 2010
edited by GrieverVIII
So what was up with her dad? He seemed regular looking to me.

Phrederic
topic
10:36:05 AM Jul 25th 2010
Sorry, maybe it's just me, but that is not a very good picture of Maggie, she looks...off in that one (It's the eyeshadow, and the apple covers to much of her face), I google her and I get ten better looking and more iconic pictures, so, maybe a switcheroo?
SomeGuy
12:05:41 PM Jul 25th 2010
ThinksTooMuch
05:01:38 PM Aug 4th 2010
SomeSortOfTroper
topic
04:49:42 AM Mar 16th 2010
re:cut

You know what all these actress pages on the cut list are? They're one editor complaining about the work of another editor. The answer to that isn't the cut list, it's the edit button.

There are a number of relevant and neutral tropes amongst the fetishist ones, the descriptions with their career highlights are useful, as well as the pictures. Yes, I'd prefer a change of focus but on the other hand, it's their agents' wet dream and I can alway just change things out, use a different picture and swipe off something I don't think applies. It is still far from defunct.
back to Main/MaggieGyllenhaal

TV Tropes by TV Tropes Foundation, LLC is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.
Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available from thestaff@tvtropes.org.
Privacy Policy