Main Judd Winick Discussion

Collapse/Expand Topics

10:55:10 AM May 6th 2010
Okay, so, um. I've never been a fan of Judd Winick. I've read precious few of his stories that I'v enjoyed. And I cringe whenever I see his name on a cover.

But this article is a hackjob. It's nothing but a screed copy-pasted from the Wall Banger page, with increasingly longer "examples"—ie, complaints—tacked on the end. We should rename this page "Why Judd Winick Sucks".

Really, people. We're better than this.
07:47:07 AM Sep 22nd 2010
Actually, the examples on Wallbanger originally came from this page. I should know. I was the original author and I started writing things here before realizing that the examples would be more appropriate to that section. But before I could remove it, other people started adding on their own examples of Winick's hackery and... well, I decided it wouldn't be fair for me to delete all that.
08:01:44 AM Sep 22nd 2010
edited by Iaculus
Still doesn't change the fact that the page needs some serious TLC, though. Regrettably, I'm not familiar enough with the subject matter to do it myself.

The purpose of this wiki is to catalogue tropes, not bitch about writers, and if the latter gets in the way of the former, it needs trimmin'.
04:47:22 PM Dec 10th 2010
Someone deleted all the examples from the main page, so I created a YMMV subpage to put them on. I know nothing about this guy myself, but the page clearly needs work.
Collapse/Expand Topics