Main Insane Equals Violent Discussion

Collapse/Expand Topics

05:55:19 PM May 1st 2012
I've been thinking about this particular trope and wondering whether to split it, or make a subtrope, for the villain who commits a crime, pleads insanity, and either goes to a cushy mental hospital or gets out entirely. It's like a cross between this and Cardboard Prison. You usually see it in horror movies with an insane villain... it makes him more scary because the audience sees his insanity as a "get out of jail free" card. (It's not, in real life; it just gets you put in the prison hospital ward instead of general population, but it does make for dramatic storytelling.)
11:55:02 PM Aug 25th 2011
I think it should be made clear that violent behavior is indeed a result of being mentally unsound, but NOT the other way around. A Cloud Cuckoo Lander is a perfect example of a "crazy" individual that isn't really portrayed as violent.
01:40:26 AM Aug 31st 2011
Come to think of it, my friend actually fits that perfectly. Especially since the most "violent" thing she's ever done is kill a ladybug. And she cried over it!
04:47:05 PM Jan 20th 2011
Sad, isn't it? Having a disability that people can't 'see,' automatically renders you to be assumed either crazy (and therefore violent) or stupid.
10:10:09 AM Apr 28th 2011
edited by ride
never mind
08:27:07 PM Jun 22nd 2011
It is sad. I have a friend with schizophrenia and the minute someone at my school learns she has it, they automatically assume she's crazy, stupid and will hurt them. This is ignoring the fact that she's one of the top students in the school and she is pretty quiet and shy. Heck, when I first met her, I thought she was mute or almost mute! Apparently, people also don't pick up the hint that she's harmless by me hanging around her. If she were really this violent and crazy psycho she's made out to be, I wouldn't be her friend.
05:14:36 PM Oct 4th 2014
edited by
I had a classmate back on highschool who is schizophrenic, and he WAS prone to violence. So I think there's always the possibility to happen.
Collapse/Expand Topics