Main IKNEWIT Discussion

Collapse/Expand Topics
 

Trogdor
Topic
11:36:40 PM Feb 2nd 2015
It says this is a trivia entry - shouldn't it be a YMMV Entry? Trivia entries are simple facts that are out of universe, while YMMV entries are reactions and thoughts out of universe. These predictions aren't things that everyone saw coming, so logically it should be a YMMV Entry.
SeptimusHeap
12:59:10 AM Feb 3rd 2015
Well, no, YMMV is for opinions. I Knew It is a factual statement, not an opinion.
Larkmarn
06:10:54 AM Feb 3rd 2015
But YMMV is for Audience Reactions and this does seem more like an audience reaction than anything else.
SeptimusHeap
06:36:19 AM Feb 3rd 2015
There is a difference between Audience Reactions and audience reactions. Only the subjective/opinion-driven ones go under the former.
ZuTheSkunk
Topic
06:11:08 AM Apr 22nd 2014
I can't help but notice that there's at least one case of this trope being used in-universe, and the site still considers using it on the main page of a work as incorrect. Any suggestions what could be done about it?
Larkmarn
07:54:50 AM Apr 22nd 2014
If you put an In-Universe tag on it, then it won't be viewed as incorrect.
FlintlockWolfman
Topic
09:15:54 PM Oct 5th 2012
What show is this example from? "Right after he was introduced, fans began to predict that Nate was the stalker Maya mentioned and also killed her. They were right. ". Should i delete it?
GGGG
11:19:18 AM Oct 11th 2012
I deleted it. I sent a PM to the troper who made the edit so they can write the example properly next time if they want.
deadmanRise
Topic
11:35:08 AM Aug 1st 2012
What's the difference between this and Ascended Fanon? Both involve something that hadn't been revealed yet being speculated on by fans, and when The Reveal happens, it turns out the fans were right. If someone can come up with a clear difference, they should note it in the Canonical List of Subtle Trope Distinctions, and possibly also on each tropes' page as well; if not, we should talk about merging the two.
MrDeath
11:54:39 AM Aug 1st 2012
This is when the fans just guess right. Ascended Fanon is when the fans come up with something, the writers see it, and then incorporate it into the show.
58.174.177.40
Topic
03:32:32 AM Jun 24th 2010
Should Tsubasa Reservoir Chronicles be added, for every one who guessed that Sakura's and Syaoran's real names were 'Tsubasa'
DrakeClawfang
Topic
06:32:55 AM Jun 23rd 2010
I'm not sure if this page should note personal examples or not, but I personally have a case of "I Knew It" regarding Kingdom Hearts - http://kingdomhearts.wikia.com/wiki/Talk:Xion#New_Theory. Technically she was a Replica, not a Nobody, but otherwise my theory about her being built out of Sora's memories of Kairi is 100% correct. Should it be added or no?
Collapse/Expand Topics