Main I Am The Band Discussion

Collapse/Expand Topics
 

XenMon2
Topic
01:56:59 AM Jul 3rd 2015
Edited out the part on En Esch under the KMFDM entry. Considering how he was not a founding member, and had little-to-no input on several albums (Opium, Money, Nihil (Sascha mentioned in an interview that Esch did not "participate so much this time in the actual writing"), Xtort, and Adios), it's tough to argue that he could really be considered for this trope. That's almost half of their pre-reformation discography, to say nothing of the eight albums released since he officially left.

I realize that some people aren't fans of their newer stuff, but that doesn't really warrant revisionism. I mean, come on.
OmegaX123
Topic
07:43:16 PM Feb 21st 2012
Should Darude (and other actual one-man acts) really be in this article? The way the intro reads, it sounds like it's more about 'bands with more than one member, but only one original member left/only one name people recognize'.
24.41.4.55
Topic
06:02:46 AM Apr 19th 2011
Shouldn't Fall Out Boy be in here? I and I'm sure many others had no idea Pete Wentz wasn't the lead singer (and therefore I am the band) for all the media hype he garners compared to his less hollywood-handsome Patrick Stump
Collapse/Expand Topics