Main Humor Dissonance Discussion

Collapse/Expand Topics
 

MasamiPhoenix
Topic
10:16:30 PM Feb 24th 2015
Removed this from the Tiny Toons example:
  • The short "The Anvil Chorus" is especially egregious. In it, Babs and Buster cause anvils to repeatedly fall from the sky on top of Plucky Duck...and that's it. That's the cartoon. It's so repetitive it's boring, so mean-spirited it makes you feel sorry for poor Plucky, and of course, it's not funny. Yet the No Fourth Wall gag is used to Anviliciously tell us that what we're watching is funny. In between anvils, Plucky gets berated by a Moral Guardian who claims to be the Chairperson of the Adults Against Funny Cartoons (she should've had no problem with this one). And at the end, it's revealed that the studio audience loved the cartoon, so Babs and Buster can subject Plucky to "The War of 1812 Overture" (basically the Anvil Chorus but with cannons instead).

No gag in the cartoon actually states that it's funny nor does anybody respond to it being funny. The Chairperson is against the Tiny Toons in general, and is targeting this cartoon due to it's violence. (Also Tiny Toons constantly attacked censors and media watchdogs) and the audience clapped, but never laughed.
indridcold13
Topic
07:51:19 PM Apr 19th 2013
PLEASE PLAEASE PLEASE! Can someone explain Guinan's original joke from the script? I can't stop thinking about it! I NEED TO KNOW THE PUNCHLINE!
Caswin
03:40:03 PM Nov 29th 2013
It reads like the closest thing to a punchline would be in the middle. Being "under a commitment to keep a secret about nothing" could be funny with the right setup. (I could go further speculating on how this came to be in the script, but maybe later.) On closer inspection, it may be supposed to not quite add up ("no soap radio") and leave Data as confused as the audience on this one.
GreatLimmick
Topic
01:44:12 AM Nov 28th 2011
Contrary to what the example entry insists, enough is not said about Borat to justify its presence on the page. Ordinarily I would clarify myself, but I haven't actually seen the film and don't intend to.
kairu
Topic
12:27:21 PM Feb 17th 2011
I think the point of 'fish dicks' was that it was such an obvious pun, yet one nobody had ever done before. the 'undiscovered' aspect of the joke was half the point. That, and the first couple times, it was extremely funny.
SteelBeast6Beets
Topic
12:37:03 PM Jun 15th 2010
Shouldn't this trope be consider the counterpart of Narm?
99.21.83.77
Topic
12:24:35 PM Mar 31st 2010
The laughing scene from FFX was not supposed to be funny. It was indicative of Yuna's emotional repression. Why can't people get that?
SteelBeast6Beets
12:35:12 PM Jun 15th 2010
Methinks this is one of those situation were viewers are indeed morons.
Collapse/Expand Topics