Main Godwins Law Discussion

Collapse/Expand Topics

09:12:36 PM Jun 2nd 2018
"O'Reilly makes the argument that society needs religion to be moral because Stalin, Pol Pot, and Mao were all atheists (this is pretty common in many atheist vs. theist debates-it could almost be a trope of its own, though here it is part of Hollywood Atheist)." Is the parenthesized part okay to have in a wiki article? It seems like gratuitous commentary on a controversial topic to me. Besides, if someone is suggesting a trope, it should go to the Trope Launch Pad, not this article.
05:44:10 PM May 14th 2017
"The Greek political party Golden Dawn has been used for the same purpose, though it is still mostly used in European parliaments and it is very likely that the only reason why is because only they know what it means."

...what? I know Golden Dawn's a Neo-Nazi party, but I honestly cannot figure out what this sentence is trying to say. Members of European parliaments compare other members of European parliament to Golden Dawn? Only European politicians know what Golden Dawn is? I need clarification, and I think the page needs it too.
06:10:42 AM May 12th 2013
May I propose a related law that applies to feminism-related discussions? It seems like once someone runs out of arguments when a feminist issue is discussed, they're more likely to use FGM to diminish said issue.

As it's inspired by real comment thread (on redesign for Brave's princess Merida), let me give an exact quote here: "I see bouncier red curls while african girls have their clitorises smash off with rocks." Yup.
07:25:22 PM Jul 20th 2015
Hitler is squicked by your comment.
11:50:12 AM Aug 11th 2012
edited by S3fbfbfb
Here's my version of the card:
some caption text
should we switch the ancient for this one?
02:17:05 PM Jan 16th 2016
I hope so, this one's way easier to read.
08:56:14 AM Dec 13th 2011
edited by Danteventresca
I propose a corollary to Godwin's Law called Graham's Theorem. Whereby the longer the participants in an argument try to avoid using Hitler, the likelihood of using someone else who has committed attrocities, most often Stalin, becomes greater,
12:12:44 PM Nov 29th 2010
I'm curious, from where it is found that Hitler's greatest wish was to be remembered forever?
07:49:09 AM May 28th 2010
How do these things get created anyway?
07:50:59 AM May 28th 2010
edited by MrDeath
You put Godwin's Law inside special brackets like this: [=ŢGodwin's LawŢ =]. And ptitles are not at all grounds for cutting. In fact, they're encouraged for titles that have punctuation in them.

Edit: Okay, it doesn't seem to be letting me display the right character to demonstrate, but still. ~
07:58:44 AM May 28th 2010
Oh okay.
09:53:57 AM May 28th 2010
This is a proper ptitle. Godwin's Law is, strictly speaking, supposed to have the apostrophe, and you can't put an apostrophe4 in a title without a ptitle. In fact, apostrophes were a driving force for inventing ptitles, IIRC.
09:59:32 AM May 28th 2010
Collapse/Expand Topics