What's Happening

Troperville

Tools

collapse/expand topics back to Main/FairPlayWhoDunnit

MickeyFrogeater
topic
08:51:09 PM May 3rd 2014
Does this type of Mystery allow the the murderer's boss who runs a criminal syndicate like Carmen Sandiego's V.I.L.E to play private detective with the story outright showing that She/He is the The Big Bad who hired the murderer and that the Chief Inspector is the real detective(thus not decieving the audience) without the actual murderer(criminal under the Big Bad's employ) being revealed?
Jaqen
topic
04:10:15 PM Dec 28th 2012
The Harry Potter books are like this; the mystery plot is deliberately littered with Red Herrings to lead Harry (and the reader, by extension) down the wrong path at first, but an acute reader can pick up on the actual clues and determine the true culprit before Harry does.

I disagree. The Reveal is always Dumbledore pilling stuff out of his ass. Even when Dumbledore dies, his ass continues to be an infinite source.

Change "but an acute reader can pick up on the actual clues and determine the true culprit before Harry does."

or just put the whole example in YMMV but NOT on the main page?

DonaldthePotholer
topic
11:58:15 AM Aug 22nd 2012
Just gotta say that the concealing of the clues in the second FriendshipIsMagic example is (IMO) justified insofar as the first clue was a Smoking Gun, as likely was the second. Upon seeing said first clue, we would've been like Pinkie Pie and said "Case Solved" when it wasn't. After all, what would a Tomboy/Lad-ette be doing wearing fake eyelashes?
back to Main/FairPlayWhoDunnit

TV Tropes by TV Tropes Foundation, LLC is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.
Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available from thestaff@tvtropes.org.
Privacy Policy