Main Everyone Calls Him Bar Keep Discussion

Collapse/Expand Topics

11:16:57 AM Aug 30th 2013
This page needs some clean-up. A lot of the examples (maybe most of them) are of characters who are often, but not exclusively, referred to as something other than their real name. There are two problems: (1) the idea of this trope is that they are only called by their descriptor or job title; and (2) many of the appellations listed are just nicknames, which would place them under "Only Known by Their Nickname," not this trope.

To cite one offending example as illustrative of the problem, the entry for Hocus Pocus remarks that the character Max is addressed by bullies as "Hollywood" because he came from Southern California. All the other characters in the movie call him by his real name, and furthermore, "Hollywood" is not a job title or a descriptor of what Max does, which is what the trope description calls for.

There are many such examples.
10:59:28 PM Jul 7th 2013
Just a warning: looks live Film-Live Action is bleeding into Live Action TV. There are examples from The Fugitive and La Femme Nikita just at a glance.
09:53:50 AM Jun 1st 2013
I have a real life example of this. On my fire station we have a red head who we obviously called Ginger, and only called him Ginger. The annual banquet comes around and the Chief reads off a list of members that have finish their training and are now full members, and referred to him by his real name. What followed was a collective"who?" and a very awkward pause followed by "Oh you mean Ginger" funny as hell in retrospect
09:45:26 PM Jun 15th 2010
Soupdragon: What!? No real life examples? How is this possible?
Collapse/Expand Topics