What's Happening

Troperville

Tools

collapse/expand topics back to Main/Doublethink

 

GuesssWho
topic
02:52:12 AM Sep 9th 2012
I think this should be a No Real Life Examples page, because just looking at the Real Life section of this pissed me off and made me want to write a long angry rant about the people who voted for Bush the second time even though he was obviously making things worse and oh God I'm blithering.
LordGro
04:21:14 AM Sep 9th 2012
Take it to this thread.
Xzenu
topic
03:04:14 AM Jan 8th 2012
Hmm, I seem to have botched the inclusion of the YKTTW thread when I launched this one. :-(
MoG2
topic
11:37:53 AM Jan 6th 2011
Actually, I think George Orwell was misinterpreting the Stalinists thoroughly. (Keep in mind that 1984 also is a big Take That from an ex-Communist who had sympathies for Trotzky, fighting the lost battle again on paper.) In Real Life, Stalin and many of his followers were anything but ideology-driven - they said, did and made friends with whom-/whatever they thought was useful for the moment. (Don't forget Stalin's pact with Adolf Hitler!) From the POV of an intellectual (which Orwell was) their behavior must have looked like following a completely erratic ideology, which is all about telling lies all the time, changing these lies at a whim, then acting like the new lie had been their true ideology all the time, and demanding from the followers to believe them while knowing they're nothing but lies. But from the POV of Stalin, ideology is just a tool you can use to fool the masses (and some intellectuals), and you can't survive in a rapidly changing world if you follow a strict, un-changing ideology. Especially if said ideology was thought up by ivory tower intellectuals (as Communism was).

TLDR: Stalin was a realist who wanted power and was willing to do anything to get/keep it, and ideologists like Orwell can't understand realists.

Xzenu
03:03:00 AM Jan 8th 2012
Actually, ENGSOC in 1984 can reasonably be considered to be all about using ideology - and science, and history - as nonthing more than a tool in the exact same way as you describe Stalin doing.
back to Main/Doublethink

TV Tropes by TV Tropes Foundation, LLC is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.
Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available from thestaff@tvtropes.org.
Privacy Policy