Main Continuity Nod Discussion

Collapse/Expand Topics

10:36:14 PM Oct 9th 2014
"A nod that affects the plot in some way can be considered a Chekhov's Boomerang." "Distinct from a Call Back, as it does not actually drive any plot development,"

So if it affects the plot, which is it? What's the difference between Chekhov's Boomerang and Call-Back?
08:45:59 AM Sep 29th 2013
I think there needs to be a clean-up, because Continuity Nod keeps being used to refer to any kind of story arc or plot thread.
10:52:08 PM Jan 14th 2013
I wasn't sure where Chill Out, Scooby-Doo! went in Continuity Nod itself so I put it in Western Animation and Film.
03:37:10 AM Feb 20th 2012
Took this from Gilbert & Sullivan, it's not the same continuity:
  • For example, during the Major-General's Song in The Pirates of Penzance, the Major-General counts among his achievements the ability to "whistle all the airs from that infernal nonsense, Pinafore", a reference to HMS Pinafore, the operetta which immediately precedes The Pirates of Penzance in the G&S chronology.
01:32:57 PM Oct 16th 2011
edited by VVK
Just making a note of this because I can't open a Trope Repair Shop discussion just now (and maybe someone can enlighten me).

It says: "Distinct from a Call Back, as it does not actually drive any plot development." Except that Call-Back doesn't say anything about that. And as that would be the only difference, as far as I can see, there is no difference whatsoever between these two.
10:47:05 PM Oct 9th 2014
From Call-Back: "More or less a Shout-Out to itself but if that's all that it's doing, then it's a Continuity Nod; a Call Back brings back an element that is actually relevant again."

So maybe driving a plot element isn't exactly consistent, but the general idea is that a Call-Back brings back something relevant to the current story, while a Continuity Nod is just something you mention for the sake of mentioning it but doesn't go further.

If I'm understanding this right, then when the Doctor grumbles that he misses Amy when they're tied up and Clara's legs aren't long enough to reach something that would help them escape, that's a Continuity Nod. When the Doctor can't use his sonic screwdriver on a wooden cyberman because it doesn't work on wood, that's a Call-Back to the times he couldn't open a wooden door.
Collapse/Expand Topics