Literature The Silmarillion Discussion

Collapse/Expand Topics
 

LordGro
Topic
08:52:29 AM Aug 6th 2015
Pulled this. Repair, Don't Respond, don't Natter. The trope may apply or it may not, but the main wiki is not the place to discuss that.
  • Humans Are Bastards: Pretty much so. Every Elvish defeat is due to human treachery or incompetence. And Númenor!
    • Huh? I grant you Numenor but Humans aren't even around when the Noldor rebel and the Fathers of Men fight loyally beside their High Elven allies. Doriath is destroyed by the Sons of Feanor; Gondolin is betrayed by Maeglin, an Elf; Turin bears responsibility for the fall of Nargothrond but by pushing bad strategies not treachery; and it's the Sons of Feanor - again - who destroy the last Elven Kingdom in Beleriand.
MaiaMaiden
Topic
10:54:34 AM Feb 13th 2013
ELVES DO NOT RAPE.

Read it right to left, read it left to right, read it backwards and in Hebrew.

Elves do not rape anyone, nor can they be raped, for they die if someone even tries to do it to them.

Elven rape does not exist.

This is canon. It's written black on white in Ho ME. No matter how much noncon happens in fanfiction, in canon no Elf ever, ever, ever has raped anyone.

So stop flaming Elven characters you don't like by implying they're rapists. They're not. The end.
ArcadesSabboth
02:58:50 PM Mar 16th 2013
Please calm down. See replies in the Characters/ discussion.
Collapse/Expand Topics
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/remarks.php?trope=Literature.TheSilmarillion