Literature Harry Potter And The Deathly Hallows Discussion

Collapse/Expand Topics

08:35:00 PM Jan 30th 2017
Did a lot of pruning on the Literature page. Mostly, I got rid of all the examples that actually are found in the film instead of the book. Those should go on the work pages for the films.
10:37:56 AM Jun 15th 2012

  • Foe Yay/Ho Yay: Dumbledore and Grindlewald in the backstory. And canon too, at least on Dumbledore's part.

I'd have just moved it to YMMV, but the event it describes is an objective component of the work (if only by Word of God), so the actual problem is that it's being described with the wrong trope.
11:55:32 AM Sep 18th 2011
One thing about the film does niggle at me. Did anyone else notice that the only Irish student (Seamus) is portrayed as a mad bomber type who blows up the bridge?
10:57:50 PM Jan 8th 2012
What about Luna?
06:15:53 PM Nov 20th 2010
Folderized the JBM page. Unfoldered page can be found here
10:03:19 PM Jun 9th 2010
"This is the only one to end inside Hogwarts, if you don't count the epilogue, that is (Book 6 ended on the grounds)."

What does this mean? Books 1 and 2 ended in showdowns in hidden rooms of the castle: The Chamber of Secrets and the room hiding the Sorcerer's Stone. And if Book 6 ended on the grounds, arguably Book 3 did as well.
12:18:29 PM Jul 11th 2010
Huh? No they didn't. Books 1 and 2 ended on the train at Hogsmeade. I think Book 3 did too.
05:12:41 PM Aug 24th 2010
I think they mean that DH is the only one that ends inside the castle.
Collapse/Expand Topics