What's Happening

Troperville

Tools

collapse/expand topics back to Franchise/Pokemon

leoryff
topic
12:38:25 PM Jun 7th 2014
There is a Pokemon support site called "We All Live In A Pokemon World". It is rather in depth and well researched. I wonder if it has a Trope page or is mentioned anywhere? And, if not, should it be?

Here is the site: https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=4&cad=rja&uact=8&sqi=2&ved=0CEIQFjAD&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.kimsites.net%2Fpokemon%2F&ei=H2mTU7fxAaiJ8QHZ64HIBA&usg=AFQjCNH7yF6IyaIPwp-1W_qMNf-e_jZN5w&sig2=9TuZLgpwfkT8xSb6Arzwqg&bvm=bv.68445247,d.b2U
pinkiestar
topic
08:23:18 AM May 9th 2014
so is it pronounced poke-E-mon or poke-AY-mon?
leoryff
12:35:55 PM Jun 7th 2014
'Po-KAY-mahn" or "Pok-uh-mahn"

You can hear this best at the very end of the first English opening.
DracoKanji
topic
11:39:15 AM Jan 8th 2013
How should the Pokédex 3D Pro be added in? Unlike the first one, it's actually got a trivia game built into it, so I think it should qualify as a Spinoff Game. I don't think it has enough to stand as its own page though, but it's got some ridiculous requirements for true 100% completion, which is what I really wanted to add.
BlueKirby10
03:20:22 PM Sep 18th 2014
Remember, There Is No Such Thing As Notability. You can probably go ahead with it, but just in case, check with a Mod first.
PinkCelebi
topic
09:06:52 AM Jun 5th 2012
Telcontar
moderator
09:12:35 AM Jun 5th 2012
On the Trivia tab.
Troublethecat
topic
11:30:00 AM Apr 4th 2012
What's wrong with the trope page for Pokemon + Nobunaga's Ambition? When I try to go to the page it redirects to Video Game Genres
PinkCelebi
topic
12:23:19 PM Apr 2nd 2012
This will happen when you need [1] trade with yourself.
PinkCelebi
topic
06:43:49 AM Apr 1st 2012
PinkCelebi
06:44:12 AM Apr 1st 2012
Oh, and I know what it is, but I won't say, lol.
homogenized
topic
09:00:12 PM Mar 12th 2012
edited by homogenized
Denjiman claims that this is false info:
False as in it doesn't exist (which would be wrong, it's Pokémon RéBURST) or false as in it's not more mature/doesn't fit under Darker and Edgier (which I wouldn't know as I haven't read it)?
sirbacon
topic
01:23:53 AM Jan 31st 2012
Isn't Pokemon technically the Trope Namer for A Wild Rapper Appears?
Cider
01:07:42 PM Feb 13th 2012
Yes?
whereismytea
topic
07:04:14 PM Jan 27th 2012
Trying to crosswick a page but I have no knowledge of Pokémon. Could someone who knows where this belongs copy it over?

  • Forgotten First Meeting: Barry doesn't remember that he and Dawn met when they were younger. Granted, they're probably only ten or eleven...
Jarkes
topic
05:24:19 PM Oct 29th 2011
The You Gotta Have Blue Hair trope: I can never figure out if Lucas and Dawn have blue hair or black hair. In the official artwork, it looks like it could be either, but, in the game and the anime, it's clearly blue. Please help.
Sol9000
topic
11:33:52 PM Oct 8th 2011
About that Last bit of Fridge Logic:

Me: Surrender or I'll call the cops—

Lv. 100 Rayquaza *With Nasty-Looking Stare*: Surrender or DIE!

Guess which one Team Rocket/Plasma/Etc. is gonna surrender because of
homogenized
topic
10:43:06 PM Sep 4th 2011
Is Pokémon really the Trope Namer for Energy Ball? I wasn't around for the trope's creation, but it sounds like a really general name to me, at least more so than Bullet Seed or Brick Break. And when I checked the trope's history a while back, it appeared that Pokémon wasn't even mentioned on the trope page until sometime after it's creation, unfortunately the history doesn't go back that far anymore.
pinkiestar
08:07:48 AM May 9th 2014
I'm actually pretty sure portal is the trope namer.
BlueKirby10
03:23:45 PM Sep 18th 2014
Actually in Portal, it's called the Aperture Science High Energy PELLET. It probably goes to Pokémon for trope naming, at least for now.
Scrawly
topic
06:52:35 AM Sep 3rd 2011
"Hello there! Welcome to the world of Pokémon! My name is [Oak/Birch/Rowan/Juniper]* Note that the lack of Professor Elm is not a mistake; Professor Oak introduces players to the game in all games where Professor Elm is the professor who gives out starting Pokémon. ! People call me the Pokémon Prof!"

The quote on the main page seems to be, largely, irrelevant pedantry. I can see the appeal of opening the page with the first lines heard in the game, but the footnotes and so on just clutter things up horribly. Wouldn't it nicer just to have Oak introduce the page?

"Hello there! Welcome to the world of Pokémon! My name is Oak! People call me the Pokémon Prof!"

homogenized
04:35:24 PM Sep 3rd 2011
edited by homogenized
I for one wouldn't mind it. I think that's the way it was before, then people decided to add the other Profs and others then decided to correct them, then added the footnote because people kept adding Elm back because they don't bother reading %%comments.
OldManHoOh
05:54:54 PM Sep 3rd 2011
edited by OldManHoOh
As I recall, one of them readded Elm, and added %%don't care NEXT TO the comment.
Scrawly
06:08:10 PM Sep 3rd 2011
Is there a precedent for changing it? It's such a minor thing, but this is a high-traffic page and I don't particularly feel like making waves by going about it the wrong way.
homogenized
10:13:15 PM Sep 4th 2011
edited by homogenized
I don't believe there is. You could edit it, state the reason and mention this discussion in the provided space, and then let what happens after go. If someone disagrees they can change it back, if not it'll stay.

@OldManHoOh
Yeah, I saw that back then. It was obvious he was trying to make it look like he purposely went against it to hide his error, especially since he added the "don't care" in a separate edit.
DeathToSquishies
topic
09:40:43 PM Jun 14th 2011
Some of the text that got deleted was about the Pokémon games being the first to use multiplayer. It got wiped by homogenized cause he pointed out that there were other multiplayer games on the Game Boy... but I think he mistook the text as saying that the 'mon games were the ONLY ones to utilize multiplayer on GB, when it only said that it was one of the first games ever to start using it. I want to re-add that text, but I dunno if in fact Pokémon was one of the first games to use multiplayer.
homogenized
08:22:45 PM Aug 26th 2011
edited by homogenized
Ugh, I feel old. The Game Boy had been out for over 6 years before Pokémon Red and Green were released. Do you really think that there were only a few multiplayer games in that huge span of time?

And I couldn't have mistaken the text, here it is, copy-pasted directly from the edit history:

"in fact, these games were the first to use the multiplayer capabilities of the Game Boy"

They were nowhere near the first. Seriously, being too young to know can only excuse so much. People should check their "facts" instead of coming straight here and posting what they read from places like 4chan and GameFAQs.
pinkiestar
08:10:28 AM May 9th 2014
The most accurate thing to say would be "one of the few multiplayer games on the gameboy" or something like that, because there were some before it, but there definitely weren't many multiplayer games on the gameboy at all. (not counting gbc games)
kct43
topic
08:59:32 AM Jun 1st 2011
"Most likely the most important example of them all is the Dark type. The original name is Aku (Evil) and not the Japanese Dark equivalent Yami. This is why the various evil teams typically use Dark types, all Dark moves not named Dark Pulse or Night Daze are combat pragmatism bordering on just plain being a Jerk Ass, and over three Dark type families are based on criminal stereotypes."

Hmm... Let's see... note to self: Dark != evil. Go check on certain Dark-type Pokémon. I have a feeling that this either needs clarification or removal to another trope or something.
pinkiestar
08:11:30 AM May 9th 2014
This is probably why everyone thinks Giratina was evil.
PLA
topic
04:13:55 AM May 19th 2011
On Asskicking Equals Authority, I'm not sure Clay and Elesa are good examples. Most Gen V Gym Leaders have day jobs, Elesa being a fashion model and Clay being as of yet the most notable business man in the region, with hordes of actual employees.
92.40.253.36
topic
01:17:58 PM May 6th 2011
"in fact, these games were the first to use the multiplayer capabilities of the Game Boy." I know this isn't wikipedia, but the above line from the Page is wrong. Tetris was the 1st game boy game to use the multiplayer capabilities.
Luigifan
topic
09:53:25 PM Apr 11th 2011
What the hell's happened to Smogon's servers?!? I can't get onto any pages on the site... is it just me, or are others having this problem too?
SpellBlade
10:03:43 PM Apr 11th 2011
I'm having problems as well.
Luigifan
08:15:54 AM Apr 12th 2011
Grrr... I wonder what happened...
Luigifan
12:22:33 PM Apr 17th 2011
Okay, Smogon's servers have been down for the last eight days. What the **** is going on?!?!?
bwburke94
12:32:42 PM Apr 18th 2011
Smogon is just like that sometimes. They've been down for longer before.
BadWolf21
topic
09:31:06 AM Jan 29th 2011
Why were all the Pokemon page names switched to the full ptitle? If there's some reason it absolutely had to happen, then fine, but it makes any potholes to the other games, or the anime, completely unreadable.
Correctedsun
topic
03:40:51 PM Dec 5th 2010
I'd like to request a warning be put up on the Pokemon main page regarding Bulbapedia. The website has infected or tried to infect two of my computers in the past two weeks with a Vundo Trojan style virus. Actually, i'll put the warning up now and if the problem goes away we can remove the warning.
kct43
06:32:25 AM Dec 6th 2010
edited by kct43
You sure about that? And it isn't your computer? I am not getting that at all. Sometimes, you need to check whether it's your stuff acting up or not. I think that part should be removed. Or if it shouldn't, report it in the forums. There's a thread for it: Bad Ad Reporting Thread. http://bmgf.bulbagarden.net/showthread.php?t=29680
Correctedsun
11:21:42 PM Dec 6th 2010
It could be that, although the two computers were at two separate residences, using two different OS's and Virus protections. (Windows XP with Norton, Windows 7 with Kaspersky) Not to mention that google searches turn up other users who have had the same problem. If the warning needs to be removed, i won't argue, it IS right at the top of the page. I'm just concerned about the state of other users comps, especially since Vundo has ruined my computers in the past.
kct43
04:37:26 AM Dec 7th 2010
Apparently, I got lucky and never got the offending ads. Anyway, they know about the problem and is resolving it. Hopefully this will come to a pass.
SpellBlade
11:06:31 PM Dec 18th 2010
Is the problem gone? The warning was removed.
Whatshisgame
04:00:08 PM Jan 2nd 2011
FalconPain
topic
09:17:58 AM Nov 23rd 2010
A new concern has arisen. Trying to link "Pokémon" using the "bracket equal tilde" method is now returning redlinks. The only pages that link to the current Pokémon page while using the é have the ptitle typed out in full.
MagBas
topic
11:22:49 AM Nov 21st 2010
edited by MagBas

Despite the name, the normal-type is not one example of the Badass Normal trope. The Badass Normal trope is someone without superpowers that is capable of fight side to side with super powered characters(Batman is the image example)
Eriorguez
09:37:28 AM Nov 23rd 2010
Your Normal type Snorlax can fight side-by-side with Dragons and stand in the same grounds.
urutapu
11:41:01 AM Nov 23rd 2010
edited by urutapu
Even going by that logic, the only badass normals would be Normal-types who don't have any access to moves of other types. Do any of those (outside of babies or something) actually exist? And adding to that, Hyper Beam is Normal-type but hardly adheres what a badass normal would be able to do.
FalconPain
11:46:27 AM Nov 23rd 2010
Half of the Skitties and Delcatties in existence? Or is that bending the rules?
PkMARIO
09:26:43 AM Jan 1st 2011
Skitty and Delcatty barely count as Badass... Normal type is Non-Elemental and that's it.
forate
12:25:25 AM Apr 10th 2011
by that logic so is fighting, psychic, dragon, steel and if you stretch it a bit ghost.
Cider
01:05:34 PM Feb 13th 2012
Fighting types that don't get force palm, aura sphere, focus blast or moves from any other type. Dragons normal, psychics normal. Dragon Breath and psybeam aren't super powers? Steel has as many special moves as fighting.
pinkiestar
08:14:33 AM May 9th 2014
Stoutland are pretty awesome, with their giant mustaches. Plus, their data claims that they have saved people in snowstorms before, which is also quite awesome.
Pichukun
topic
06:33:49 PM Nov 10th 2010
A lot of Pokémon tropes get put in the Anime-Manga section even when not referring to the anime or any manga.

..Shouldn't they be moved then?
74.64.15.17
topic
12:50:21 PM Oct 2nd 2010
When the Pokespe Fanime comes out, should there be a page for it under fanfictions?
Pichu-kun
topic
04:39:48 AM Sep 23rd 2010
About Pocket Monsters.

Can I use that link to make a Golden Boys page? That manga is very much unknown, and GB is more known and troperffic.
Montblanc
04:51:12 AM Sep 23rd 2010
You can just make a new Golden Boys page. That way, you don't have to worry about redirecting searches for Golden Boys to Pocket Monsters.
74.64.15.17
06:31:08 PM Sep 23rd 2010
Well, okay. But why exactly do we have an apparent Pocket Monsters page? That manga barely has any scans online, and I doubt that many Japanese tropers will help.
Montblanc
09:58:38 AM Sep 24th 2010
I honestly have no idea. It doesn't have anything on its page either.
74.64.15.17
topic
12:21:45 AM Aug 22nd 2010
The manga. I see there's a broken link to Pocket Monsters on the manga list. Why a manga that very few western people have access to? Why not Golden Boys or the Mystery Dungeon manga?
70.134.48.188
topic
09:12:23 PM Aug 21st 2010
Removed because I played through the game and didn't see anything like that:

DonaldthePotholer
topic
09:47:54 PM Aug 10th 2010
Not wanting to clutter up the Four Girl Ensemble page discussion as the Tropers here would be better to ask then general Tropers; just want to doublecheck before I make a complete fool of myself: Even though I haven't read either of the Magna and stopped at halfway through the game itself, I think I found an Intercontinuity example (of a Four Girl Ensemble) in Pokémon Diamond and Pearl and its three main adaptations. Specifically, the female lead:
138.110.206.100
topic
03:21:08 PM Jul 29th 2010
Why did Some Guy just delete a bunch of tropes from the page without explanation?
SomeGuy
03:58:30 PM Jul 29th 2010
edited by SomeGuy
What? It said right there, "general cleaning".

All right, sorry. To be specific, what I deleted were the entries with Natter, and the entries which were misplaced. Since we now have individual pages for the Pokémon games, only tropes about the Pokemon series in general belong here. Tropes belonging to specific versions belong on the individual game pages.
Montblanc
06:56:12 PM Jul 29th 2010
Man, that must have taken forever. Definitely needed, though. I think we might need a disclaimer at the top of the page to put game-specific tropes on their own page.
MagBas
topic
06:12:51 AM Jul 17th 2010
  • Never Say "Die": Worried by the moral ramifications of capturing dead souls and forcing them to do your bidding? Worry no more, children! Gastly and co. aren't "real ghosts"! They're just sentient balls of poisonous gas!

About the first: This is not by censorship. This is from the original japanese version and there yet heve the graveyards of pokemons. About the second: well, the motive to they said "faint" is because, well, the pokemons REALLY are not supposed to have died,by umbelievable that this looks .
Metalhead467
01:08:29 PM Jul 18th 2010
  • Also, You 'do' see a real ghost in R/B. Remember that Marowak? And the Pokemon Tower was basically an entire Pokemon graveyard. And it's fainting because it would be irritating to hae to catch a new pokemon each time they died.
Luigifan
08:17:11 AM Apr 12th 2011
The fainting is more a case of staying away from Family Unfriendly Implications.
pinkiestar
08:17:28 AM May 9th 2014
Nevertheless, Lavender Town is still a thing that exists.
SomeSortOfTroper
topic
11:53:49 AM Jun 29th 2010
I found this lonely page on Lucario and the Mystery of Mew and note that we don't have anything to cover the film pages.
94.9.179.3
06:39:10 PM Jul 2nd 2010
Ironchew
topic
03:21:06 PM Jun 27th 2010
Explaining how to add the é symbol is nice and all, but I think it would be more efficient to enforce consistency by doing periodic sweeps of the page and replacing each instance with the correct one. Off the top of my head, I can think of: <oldtext sed 's/[Pp]okemon/Pokémon' > newtext (Yeah, I know the server runs on Windows, but it can be done, I'm sure).
homogenized
09:36:27 PM Aug 20th 2010
Maybe the same person that went and manually "fixed" all the "e"s while complaining all the way a while back can do it.

He/she was the reason I added the instructions for typing the "é", since he/she apparently never stopped to think that maybe the reason why people were "typing it incorrectly" was because they didn't know how.
pinkiestar
08:19:38 AM May 9th 2014
besides, you can always just do " e' ".
pinkiestar
08:19:39 AM May 9th 2014
besides, you can always just do " e' ".
pinkiestar
08:19:39 AM May 9th 2014
besides, you can always just do " e' ".
pinkiestar
08:19:39 AM May 9th 2014
besides, you can always just do " e' ".
pinkiestar
08:19:39 AM May 9th 2014
besides, you can always just do " e' ".
pinkiestar
08:19:40 AM May 9th 2014
besides, you can always just do " e' ".
pinkiestar
08:20:26 AM May 9th 2014
OH GOD I DIDN'T MEAN TO DO THAT
Eriorguez
topic
04:20:35 PM May 11th 2010
Would anybody be interested in moving the current Characters page (which is the anime one, in any case), and remplacing it with the individual species of Pokemon (or, better yet, families)? Asking, because those species is pretty much what every itineration of the franchise has in common, and, despite being a daunting task, is more appropiate for the hub of the franchise to have that, instead of having the characters of the anime. Just my opinion, anyway...
Cider
01:00:14 PM Feb 13th 2012
I don't get it. Try asking on the forum cause no one else seems to either.
72.231.24.134
topic
01:19:17 PM May 9th 2010
What's with all the "PokĂ©mon" and "Pok?n" in articles instead of "Pokémon" or "Pokemon"? They don't even redirect anywhere.

urutapu
04:52:57 PM May 9th 2010
A while ago all the unicode characters were going to hell. That seems to be all there is to it.
DRCEQ
topic
08:20:47 AM Apr 30th 2010
Would anyone be interested in adding Professor Oak, Ivy, Elm, Birch, Rowan, and other reoccurring characters such as Nurse Joy, Officer Jenny, and Ash, May, and Dawn's moms to the character sheet?

I'm not too familiar with all of them enough to get some tropes really fleshed out for them.
Jekyll
topic
12:50:09 PM Apr 27th 2010
Pk MARIO insists that following fridge horror doesn't apply here, while I disagree. Removed lines:

  • Fridge Horror: Where to start? So, we have countless children roaming the countryside, imprisoning all these Talking Animals (well, okay, they only say their names, but in the anime it's implied through Meow that any pokemon can learn to speak even more (I would assume that there are very obvious reasons why they are denied this learning)) in a very small and confined space, then unleashing them to fight each other until senseless. Of course, these fights involve a transaction of money, as any good cockfight should. Oh, and steroids. And forced evolutions. It's no wonder that Cubones are so bat-shit-crazy, I mean, all of their mothers always die (how, does the young cubone kill it, or does some random trainer?) when they are young and then they don the mothers skull? By the way, if one's mother did this and one's child will do this, how many skulls are there inside one another at the end? Oh, and try to be a vegan in pokeverse, when even the vegetables are sentient. This enough?

The reasons given are that this horror is too cynical and doesn't fit in the Pokemon world. The Fridge Horror article has following to say: "Quickthaw: The nightmare fuel isn't there until you take a good, long, deep thought and think about it. Can occur at any age." which implies that the horror does not have to be authoritative. Furthermore, many of the examples under the article feature similar instances where the horror is far removed from the spirit of the world it is set in.

Am I alone with my opinions? There is no fridge horror in Pokemon? Having talking animals beat each other senseless isn't horror because it doesn't fit the spirit of the world?
urutapu
02:15:33 PM Apr 27th 2010
"Doesn't fit the spirit of the world"? Who said it had to? I don't think Pk Mario gets the point of the trope, if that's his rationale.
homogenized
07:32:31 PM Apr 27th 2010
Remember that the game canon is separate from anime canon, in the games most Pokemon make generic sounds or sounds that fit the animal they're based off of. Still, some of them are rather intelligent according to their Pokedex entries, and staging fights between living things regardless of intelligence can be considered horrific.
Jekyll
07:25:09 AM Apr 29th 2010
So, three against one that this would qualify? Would that make it okay for me to put it back in the article? Would some one else like to put it back, so it wouldn't be considered edit war? I'm kind of new here so I don't yet know how I should act in a situation like this.
Redesignated
10:01:53 PM Apr 30th 2010
edited by Redesignated
The only problem I notice is that it could use a rewrite, aha ha. Well, that, and there's a small continuity crossover: Meowth only speaks in the anime, which has its own article, and is probably meant to have its tropes kept seperate from the games'.

We don't see what attacks do to Pokémon in the games; everyone assumes injuries are superficial as a result—an idea helped by fainted Pokémon being able to use HMs in the field. Despite that, some of them have absolutely horrific implications: Guillotine, Earthquake, Slash, Explosion, Self-Destruct… Then there's the Pokémon themselves, which range from: cute yellow mice; genetically altered psychics; ghosts made of poisonous gas; a creature that inflicts perpetual nightmares without intent; a dimension-hopping giraffe-dragon; a giant, frozen hockey mask that eats its prey after coating them in ice… One of the biggest Fridge Horror moments comes from the discovery that humans probably eat Pokémon like Miltank, Tauros, and Magikarp, with the latter being canon.

Really, if the series didn't honestly seem to be aiming for that E for Everyone rating, it wouldn't be a pretty little Gotta Catch 'Em All game anymore.

I don't think adding it back at this point would be considered an edit war.
Sangome
topic
03:14:40 PM Apr 21st 2010
edited by Sangome
I have a question about this, listed under The Scrappy entry, which concerns the Spiky/Notch-Eared Pichu:

  • It doesn't help that the in-game event to get said Pichu (which also requires ANOTHER special Pichu to activate) actually replaces the Ilex Forest event for getting Celebi.

Where exactly has this been confirmed? I've searched all the relevant pages on places like Serebii and Bulbapedia to confirm this for myself, and absolutely none of them say anything about it being replaced. [If it counts for anything, the cave in Tojo Falls where you encounter Giovanni in said event is still present in the English version, as is Elm talking about the Spiky-Eared Pichu being friends with Celebi or something like that when you take her to him.] This strikes me as odd either way; the Celebi event reveals a rather important bit of backstory about Silver and Giovanni, and Nintendo/Game Freak just randomly replacing it in this day and age, especially when they've been pretty good about the other event Pokemon the past couple of years, seems kind of absurd. [Though they DID replace the slots with Voltorb Flip in all non-Japanese versions, so I guess it can't be ruled out entirely.]
Montblanc
07:59:56 PM Apr 21st 2010
I'm pretty sure that entry was made before the game was released, and that the troper thought it was replacing the GS Ball event from GSC. The Giovanni event is still in the game; I've already done it with a cheating device.
Cider
12:58:09 PM Feb 13th 2012
Not replaced in coding replaced as in they skipped over the Celebii event and gave us Pichu instead, though Fridge Logic means you could apply that to any event we did get versus any we did not.
urutapu
topic
11:54:53 PM Apr 18th 2010
Should we maybe put closable folders on the Character page so there can be a section for game characters and anime characters? The game characters deserve their own tropes too, especially considering how dense the main page is.

Or if we split the page into the individual games, those could just have character pages I suppose...
Montblanc
07:00:01 PM Apr 20th 2010
I'm willing to help with this. We should probably divide it up by region, however, to make things easier to navigate.
urutapu
topic
09:02:23 PM Apr 14th 2010
  • Also from the Red/Blue games, the random number generator was influenced by what buttons were pressed. The most notable way this manifested? Hitting A in a specific animation frame as the pokéball came to land would result in the number it generated being absurdly low, virtually always below the capture rate. It became an infamous "cheat code."

Was this actually proved? I had assumed this was analogous to a placebo effect.
Afti
topic
08:50:03 PM Apr 6th 2010
May I suggest splitting this off into a series article and an individual article for each set of games? It'd be far neater, and there are precedents.
SomeGuy
11:25:16 AM Apr 15th 2010
While that's a reasonably good idea I have no idea how such a feat would be achieved logistically, considering the overlap in tropes between the games. It would require someone familiar enough with the whole series to be able to tell us which tropes appear in all of them and which only show up in a specific version.
Redesignated
12:24:09 AM Apr 19th 2010
The one problem I could see happening is there not being enough examples for individual game pages; otherwise, it's just a matter of devoting the time. There are bound to be plenty of tropes with knowledge of even the earliest games, so it could work.

Assuming this goes through, and you're taking volunteers, I'm up for working on the articles for Ruby/Sapphire/Emerald and newer.
Afti
09:37:18 AM May 1st 2010
I have the spare time, and the familiarity. I can do it; allow me to throw a tentative Gold/Silver/Crystal article together.
SomeGuy
11:38:22 AM May 1st 2010
As I've only played the first two games of the series, I'm weary of helping myself for fear of spoilers. However, for all interested in affecting this split, I can assure you that your efforts are wanted and appreciated.

Here's what we can do to start out- Pokémon Red and Blue, Pokémon Gold and Silver, Pokémon Ruby and Sapphire, and Pokémon Diamond and Pearl are probably the most reasonable individual titles, as they describe the basic generations without getting overly long. You can save whatever progress you make on individual pages on the wiki proper- don't worry about bandwith or anything like that, as these pages won't likely receive Wiki Magic until the product is finished. The more annoying problem is having to delete individual tropes off of the Pokémon main page, although copy pasting could probably allow an individual user to perform both feats at the same time.

We can probably assume anyone familiar with Yellow, Crystal, Emerald, and Platinum knows which series they fold into. Likewise with Fire-Red, Leaf-Green, Heart-Gold and Soul-Silver (Updated Re-release versions of the originals). Barring all that, the only real obstacle to completion of this project is the wherewithal to affect a split.

As an irrelevant incentive, I'll give a Made of Win to the first troper to successfully split off one page.
Carls493
01:24:50 PM May 1st 2010
Hmmmm... impressive. Didn't someone do this to Fire Emblem and each of its different respective continents? I vote to do the same for Pokémon, too. Someone should get started on this.
Afti
11:52:12 PM May 1st 2010
Why don't we split by generation? That'd be viable, I think.
Redesignated
03:37:34 PM May 2nd 2010
Splitting by generation sounds good. I think a soft-split (like what's been done with the Lady Gaga page, in regards to person vs. works) to seperate the originals from the remakes might be in order, too.

How should we handle trope overlap? Obviously, things like Gotta Catch 'Em All are present in every single title, and would be placed on the main series page, but what about the ones that appear in only, say, two generations? Should they go to said generations' individual pages?

On a side note, I'm almost finished with Pokémon Ruby and Sapphire, at this point.
SomeGuy
03:47:51 PM May 2nd 2010
edited by SomeGuy
That's the main iffy point. If a trope only appears in two titles, then we should probably just list them in those two pages. Tropes like that tend to be plot elements anyway, and so would have to be contextualized in the case of each game.

An exception to this would be gameplay elements, like breeding. In which case those should be treated as universal and on the main page, but it should say "from generation II onwards" for the sake of reference.
Montblanc
05:38:20 PM May 2nd 2010
So will we be doing character sheets for each game as well?
Redesignated
08:26:22 PM May 2nd 2010
edited by Redesignated
Sounds good to me. I'm assuming tropes related to Pokémon (e.g. Lanturn's Alluring Anglerfish/Dolphins, Dolphins Everywhere) should be included on the page for the games they come from?

Edit: A somewhat simple page Ruby, Sapphire and Emerald is here. Shall I go about removing entries on the main page?
Afti
02:24:59 AM May 3rd 2010
edited by Afti
That'd be fine by me. However, I would say FRLG should have their own pages, as opposed to sharing Red and Blue's. There's enough new content for it to be merited. Same for Gold and Silver versus their remakes.

EDIT: Lanturn is GSC.
SomeGuy
08:27:03 AM May 3rd 2010
edited by SomeGuy
Simple is fine. You can wait for Wiki Magic to do the rest or, if it's working too slowly for you, use the body text search to find mention of "Pokemon Ruby" and replace the Pokémon pot holes with Pokémon Ruby and Sapphire ones. Now that you have the basics done feel free to move tropes directly from the main page to the sub-page, and be sure to delete the originals. This page is way too long, and this split is a good thing.

On FRLG and HGSS, I'm not convinced there's enough new content to warrant their own pages, but I think there's probably enough that the tropes for those games should be listed separately on the Pokémon Red and Blue and Pokémon Gold and Silver pages compared to the ones that appear in all versions.
Montblanc
01:14:08 PM May 4th 2010
All right, I'm in the process of making a Ruby/Sapphire character sheet. I'll link it to the Ruby/Sapphire page when I'm done. And feel free to fix any formatting mistakes, it's my first time making a character sheet, so it could probably use some work.
Redesignated
09:19:17 PM May 4th 2010
Derp, I always make that mistake with Lanturn. I've performd a little Wiki Magic on my own for the main page, just to cut down on some of the clutter, and now I'll do a text search like you said.
Montblanc
02:11:45 PM May 6th 2010
Okay, Ruby and Sapphire now have a basic Character Sheet. I've only played Emerald, so add in any Ruby/Sapphire-only tropes. I'll throw together a quick character sheet for the other games, too.
Montblanc
03:04:36 PM May 6th 2010
I added really basic ones for DP Pt and RBG now, but I don't know what to do for cameo characters in GSC. Any thoughts?
Redesignated
10:21:46 PM May 6th 2010
Pokémon Red and Blue, as well as its accompanying character sheet, should have every trope originally listed on the series page. I'll get to pruning tomorrow, if someone else doesn't beat me to it. (It's time for sleep now.)
homogenized
01:18:59 AM May 13th 2010
Should tropes from the anime be allowed on the character pages for the games?
Delta4845
topic
11:34:27 PM Mar 17th 2010
edited by Luigifan
Would the slots that are replaced by the card flip game in all but the Japanese versions of HeartGold and SoulSilver count as No Export for You?
urutapu
03:47:23 PM Mar 19th 2010
I dunno, but something needs to said about it any case. I shouldn't actually need to play to get coins and get Flamethrower, Ice Beam, and Thunderbolt. ಠ_ಠ
PinkCelebi
12:21:19 PM Apr 2nd 2012
edited by PinkCelebi
derp wrong button.
back to Franchise/Pokemon

TV Tropes by TV Tropes Foundation, LLC is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.
Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available from thestaff@tvtropes.org.
Privacy Policy