What's Happening

Troperville

Tools

collapse/expand topics back to FanficRecs/Firefly

 

Cousjava
topic
02:28:04 PM May 29th 2012
Browncoat, Green Eyes: Not sure about the recommendation. Harry seems too much of a Mary Sue, he seems to be able to do just about everything, he can fight anybody, help River's mind, cure someone who's ill whom Simon can't and doesn't have any real setbacks. He even manages to make Mal rich. There doesn't seem to be much that goes wrong. I feel its more 'Harry Potter curing the ills of the 26th Century' than living a life on the edge only just managing to be still flying. The storytelling is okay, but its not amazing and doesn't want me to see what happens next. However, I'm not doing anything on the page due to the Rule Of Cautious Editing.
ProgenyExMachina
03:21:19 PM May 29th 2012
You might want to post that as a review if you really want to get your feelings heard.
Ophicius
topic
06:21:14 AM Mar 19th 2011
edited by Ophicius
Changed: "Do warn when a fanfic may head into homosexual or non-canon territory. Some people just don't like it, and as we all know, Shipping is Serious Business."

To: "Do warn when a fanfic may head into non-canon territory, and for shipping fics, please list the pairings involved - as we all know, Shipping is Serious Business."

Warning for slash and not het is offensive - and I don't think either are necessary as long as the pairing is stated.
Iaculus
11:56:02 AM Mar 19th 2011
edited by Iaculus
That's the standard top-of-page warning for Fan Fic Recommendations. I don't really see what's so offensive about noting that some folks don't like slash, either - I mean, I'm fine with slashfics existing, but that doesn't stop them from being a niche interest that not everyone enjoys reading.

Also, the issue with listing pairings and not whether there is slash is that it doesn't tell us which of the pairings is explored in particular detail. See, the difference between 'Pairings: Mal/River, Simon/Jayne, lemon' and 'Pairings: Mal/River, Simon/Jayne, lemon, slash' is that one implies that yes, we're going to get intimate detail of Jayne and Simon boinking, whilst the other leaves it more ambiguous. Meanwhile, a note of 'mild, occasional slash' tells us that the boys are probably going to be restricted to kissing and references to off-screen sex whilst Mal and River get inventively freaky all over the ship. Given that, let's face it, a majority of people read lemons to get their rocks off, and different people are going to be turned on by different pairings and orientations, it's useful for them to have as much detail as possible about whose sexytimes they're going to be reading about. You follow?

Given that this is such a common warning on the recs pages, though, changing it wholesale would be a big deal, and that means you probably want to Take It to the Forums where we can have a more general discussion.
back to FanficRecs/Firefly

TV Tropes by TV Tropes Foundation, LLC is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.
Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available from thestaff@tvtropes.org.
Privacy Policy