Fanfic Recs Dragon Ball Discussion

Collapse/Expand Topics
 

HyperPeanut
Topic
03:14:02 PM Aug 29th 2013
Comments: Three words: Black Hole Sue. Goku is reduced to a COMPLETE moron, even worse than the Buu saga, kissing Cell's feet, describing him as truly perfect, outright says that it would be wrong to have Cell give up his perfect form and let 17 and 18 out because "He worked hard to achieve it." Yeah, mass murder and forcefully eating two people. 16 is casually killed off and Goku and Gohan are happy about it, despite 16 never doing anything to hurt the Z fighters in the series, and when the Dragon says that he can't revive Cell's victims because their souls are still inside Cell? GOKU SHRUGS THIS OFF AND MIND WIPES THE WHOLE PLANET's MEMORIES OF CELL! And then, Cell gets his own city named after him and goes on to beat Buu with ease. Mr.Cell is a God Mode Black Hole SUE!

This is the comment bullet under Mr.Cell. Shouldn't commentary like this be put into the review section of the fic instead?
Peteman
Topic
06:23:12 PM Jan 28th 2012
Do the abridged series count?
AnonymousMcCartneyfan
Topic
11:13:53 PM Nov 7th 2010
Before we cut this — there are Dragonball series that are not Dragon Ball Z. We need a place for recommending fics for the original, GT, and Kai.
Indalecio
09:05:11 AM Nov 8th 2010
Well the main page TV Tropes page is Dragon Ball. That should cover original, Z, GT, and Kai. Besides on the fanfic page, there doesn't seem to be a difference between the three, anyway.
SomeSortOfTroper
11:14:06 AM Nov 8th 2010
Dragon Ball Z does not have a main page. I don't know how that was missed but it should be obvious that in such a case you don't make a subpage for the redirect. Not only does it go against the already agreed upon groupings and division, no-one can see the buttons.
Indalecio
Topic
12:09:07 PM Nov 6th 2010
edited by Indalecio
There's two pages for Fanfic Recommendations for Dragonball. One thats linked to the main Dragonball article. Another thats linked from the Fanfic Recommendations page.

Anyone have suggestions on reconciling the two?

The other one is here.

http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/FanficRecs/DragonballZ
Iaculus
12:56:14 PM Nov 6th 2010
Might as well merge the smaller Dragonball page into the larger Dragonball Z one, and index that on the Fanfic Recs page if it isn't there already.
Iaculus
01:04:50 PM Nov 6th 2010
While you're at it, this would be an excellent opportunity to bring the merged page in line with the new system as detailed in this thread.
Indalecio
08:09:53 PM Nov 7th 2010
I added the shorter Fanfic Recommendations to the cut list. It only has two entries, and both of them are already on the longer page. Once its cut, we can change the link on the Fanfic Recommendations page to link to Dragonball, instead of Dragonball Z.
Iaculus
08:40:28 PM Nov 7th 2010
Fair 'nuff.
Collapse/Expand Topics