Is there any chance we could get some sort of consensus on exactly how closely cropped the pictures of the Doctor are supposed to be? Some are head-and-shoulders, while some get everything from the waist up. I'm more of an advocate of the former, really, as most Doctors have assorted outfits and it's the face that's the important bit, but in any case some consistency would be nice.
I made a mock-up of a head-and-shoulders version, for comparison.◊
It's the same height and width as the current one, and the only picture I swapped out was Tennant's because the source image crops out his entire left shoulder. Granted, I don't think most of these work well as headshots, but I assumed they were voted on or something and I wanted to respect that.
edited 11th Aug '14 12:47:20 PM by Wackd
I don't know that there's ever been a vote so more options might be nice but I like consistency and I think the suggestion looks good.
In which case, I'll set about making a new mock-up with better head shots.
No, the other one.
Here's the suggestion at 350 px...had to do it as a high-quality JPG, would've been way
too big as a PNG even optimized.
I knew I should have made 9's face bigger.
Alright. New version, with more head-shot appropriate pictures.
edited 11th Aug '14 10:52:26 PM by Wackd
I like it.
3DS FC: 2981-6375-5798
Another Wizard boy
I like version #7.
7's pretty good, too...not sure which I prefer.
Both are good. I probably prefer the OP, wikisized in #5.
If it means anything, my preference is for 7. Properly black-and-white 1st and 2nd Doctors, no more lobster-faced 3rd, no more 4th at that absurd angle, and an acknowledgment that 8th was in things besides the TV Movie.
Good points — I missed the black-and-white technicolour for the 1st and 2nd doctor.
So, how exactly is it determined whether or not it gets used?
Generally speaking, an image must have a consensus. The current image was chosen in an IP thread, too, and since this is very similar and an improvement, it's probably going to be approved soon. We just need more votes and then a mod (Willbyr in this case) can call it and close the thread.
No, the other one.
I've thought for about as long as the thread's been open, and I'm still not sure which one I prefer. Probably #5, but #7 is good too.
In uffish thought
I prefer 7 to five, and I like the consistency in having them all be headshots, but I prefer the current overall because of how it formats Capaldi's image; in the suggested layout, it seems kind of tacked on and floaty. Still, any of them are good with me.
I personally prefer #7.
...if you don’t love you’re dead, and if you do, they’ll kill you for it.
No. 7 is a winner.
edited 17th Aug '14 7:13:40 PM by Tero
Time is not the boss of me. It is more like my secretary.
The Augmented People Person
I like the new version.
I too like Wack'd's version. Is this enough consensus yet?
Yup, we're good. The new pic's swapped in and the tag's adjusted. Locking up.
The system doesn't know you right now, so no post button for you.
You need to Get Known
to get one of those.