Suggestion: Chubby Chaser

Eddie pulled the pic on Chubby Chaser, and, honestly, it was a good pull. It's a little low quality, but I think either panels 1 + 3 or 2 + 3 of this◊ could work for a new pic. I also thought about this◊ but it might be too NSFW. Thoughts?

edited 31st Dec '13 11:53:38 PM by Willbyr

1. 1 Looks good and fits.

2. 2 Is hot probably NSFW.

Good pull, definitely too PTTF. 1.2 hardly counts as this trope (unless it's in a Hollywood Pudgy sense). 1.1 works though.

edited 1st Jan '14 12:18:46 AM by treelo

1.1 in the 1+3 format work for me. 1.2 is not better than the previous image, plus (personally) I am quite displeased at seeing people's hindquarters on TV Tropes.

1.1 for me.

1.2 looks even worse than the pulled image

1.1 is great.

Cropped.

I kinda liked panel 2 as it did sell it a little more but it's good without.

I think 1+3 looks better than 2+3.

One or two more votes for 7 and we can run with it.

I kind of didn't mind the one that got pulled, but the one suggested in 7 works.

Indeed.

I don't think it was a bad pull, I feel the dialogue pushed it over the edge of pandering if the imagery didn't.

The second panel doesn't add enough to justify the extra space it would take up, in my opinion. for 7.

Good enough. 7 is up, potholed, and tagged. Caption or no?

EDIT: Actually, instead of a caption, how about using "Fat-bottom girls, you make the rocking world go 'round!" as the page quote? The current quote seems to be more like the motherly tendency to make sure people are well-fed.

edited 2nd Jan '14 8:08:13 AM by Willbyr

I see no issue with a quote switch.

I prospose Link and Tracy from Hairspray: [1]◊ [2]◊ [3]◊

We're already done.

7 > 17.2 > the other 17s for me, anyhow.

I prefer the quote suggestion in 15 to the current as well.

I much prefer the Rose is Rose pic to any of the ones in 17.

edited 2nd Jan '14 10:00:39 PM by Willbyr

I've taken the quote suggestion to that repair thread; locking this thread.